RANDY’S ALS MANUAL LIVING WITH ALS (LOU GEHRIG’S DISEASE)
A GUIDEBOOK FOR RECENTLY DIAGNOSED PERSONS WITH ALS, THEIR FAMILIES AND SIGNIFICANT OTHERS
In Memory of Randy Roberts 2007
Compiled by Randy Roberts in association with members of The Living with ALS Group, 11/2006, and dedicated to all courageous persons with ALS: past, present and future
This guidebook is free of charge. It was designed to be read or downloaded into your computer. TO READ ONLY, SCROLL DOWN CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE CURRENT GUIDEBOOK
In order to download the manual you must have Microsoft Word installed on your computer. To download the manual to your computer right click on the link and select [save target as] and in the box that pops up select where you want to save the manual on your computer. It may take awhile to download on a slow Internet connection. If you don’t have access to the internet, please ask your clinic/program to print a copy for you.
PREFACE
By Randy Roberts
Following the shock of my diagnosis of ALS in 4/04, and lacking any preparation, I felt lost in a nightmare, overwhelmed by negative thoughts. Gradually, by going to numerous websites and other sources, I learned something about coping but it wasn’t until February, 2005, when I joined Living with ALS, a message board group, contributed to by patients and their family members, that it all started to come together. There, I picked up practical and basic information, all with the personal contact missing from other sources, and a philosophy of learning to live as fully as possible with ALS. The supportive and compassionate nature of the posts helped me through some rough times and, through reading the messages and chat transcripts, I came to better understand the meaning of courage.
Eventually, I regained my bearings and had, in the process, accumulated a great deal of information on coping with ALS and related areas. The idea spontaneously arose to use what I knew to compile a Guidebook/Manual for those who had been recently diagnosed so that they would have one resource to turn to that offered integrated information presented in a positive, patient/peer oriented framework, rather than having to go through the time consuming process of sifting through many sources on their own. Thus, this Guidebook was born.
The Guidebook could not have come into existence without the help of the Living with ALS members. Thanks are due toSherry, Susan, Jeff, David, Erin, Wayne, Cookie, Ruth Anne, Lee, Lisa, Alper, Don, Edith, Thom, alsfrombothsidesand the whole group, too numerous to name, from newbie to veteran, who have taught me so much. A special thanks goes to those who contributed personal stories and articles to the Guidebook.Danny Dandignac reformatted the Manual and made it look more professional. Jerry Bergen created my webpage so that the Guidebook could be read on line and/or downloaded and comments left.
I want to thank my two children, Brett Roberts, M.D. and Heather Roberts for sharing their knowledge of Microsoft Word. Without their help, I would still be copying and pasting. Finally, I wish to thank my wife Pam for her loving care and steadfastness throughout my ordeal with ALS.
Randy Roberts Ellicott City, Maryland January, 2006
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Clicking on the link below will take you to that section of the web page.Clicking the back button will bring you back here.
CHAPTER 1 |
Welcome and Introduction | Page 5 |
CHAPTER 2 |
ALS: The Disease | Page 6 |
CHAPTER 3 |
Coping with ALS | Page 7 |
CHAPTER 3A |
Especially for CALS | Page 39 |
CHAPTER 4 |
Major Organizations and Websites | Page 44 |
CHAPTER 5 |
Benefits and Entitlements | Page 51 |
CHAPTER 6 |
Participating in Clinical Trials | Page 60 |
CHAPTER 7 |
Advocacy | Page 63 |
CHAPTER 8 |
Materials and Resources Available at No Charge | Page78 |
CHAPTER 9 |
Research | Page81 |
CHAPTER 10 |
Definitions of Medical and Related Terms and Supplemental Information | Page 89 |
CHAPTER11 |
Reading List | Page92 |
CHAPTER12 |
Closing Comments | Page94 |
When you want to move a body part, say your arm, an impulse is generated in your brain and the signal to move is then sent via motor neurons to the spinal cord and finally out to the muscle. And then the arm moves. In ALS, however, the neurons begin to die off and the command to move does not reach the muscle as well.
Muscles that receive diminished signals from the neurons will weaken and shrivel up. Muscles cannot stay strong without continual input from neurons. Wherever the neuron death begins, it gradually spreads to other motor neurons in the body, causing further weakness. The rate of this spread is called “progression” and can vary quite a bit between PALS, but tends to stay steady for individual PALS.
The disease affects only motor neurons in the body and only those neurons that serve muscles over which we have voluntary control, such as limbs, swallowing, eating, etc. The heart muscle, for example, over which we don’t have voluntary control, is not affected by ALS. The illness does not affect sensory neurons.
There are 30,000 to 40,000 people in the US with ALS. It can strike as low as the early 20’s and as late as the 70’s, but onset tends to peak at late middle age. ALS is not as rare as people think. It is diagnosed with nearly the same frequency as MS (Multiple Sclerosis), a much more recognized disease. ALS is much more lethal than MS so our numbers (prevalence) is much lower.
There is yet no effective
treatment for ALS (Rilutek, the only medicine for
ALS,whichincreases life span by only a modest amount),
nor is there any scientific understanding of what causes the disease. However,
more research is underway now than ever before.
- If you cannot
swallow - get a gastrostomy.
- If you cannot breath
- get a tracheostomy and a ventilator.
- If you get
contractures (stiff joints and muscles) - get range of motion exercise.
- If you cannot talk -
get a computerized machine that talks for you.
Right now you are
probably thinking: "How can I possibly handle all of those physical problems?"
First, while ALS is a
progressive disease, it also reaches plateaus where it stays without new
developments and this allows time to adjust and then prepare for future
progressions. Second, I am living proof
that it can be done. As of this year (1999), I have survived 26 years with ALS
and am looking forward to 26 more. I am in no pain, I am involved in many
projects, and I truly enjoy my life. My outlook is; I am NOT SICK! I am a very
healthy person who has some physical handicaps. I am sure that Stephen Hawking,
one of the greatest scientific minds of the twentieth century who has had ALS
now for over 35 years and continues to work, would agree with me that ALS is not
fatal.
ALS AND PERSONAL GROWTH
By Randy Roberts
It may
seem strange or even repulsive to link this disease, which so cruelly ravages
our body, with anything even remotely positive. But as ALS pushes us to our very
limits, we have the motivation and opportunity to see ourselves and our lives in
very different ways. For me, it has been a spiritual awakening, in the broad
sense of that word. The psychological walls that I have constructed to protect
myself have been crumbling and my heart is open as never before.I have become
more sensitive to thesuffering felt by those who have lost their health and
more attuned to the pain experienced by so many in this world of ours.I have
come to feel a new appreciation of life and all the gifts given to us, gifts
that are taken for granted when healthy. I know now that it all isn’t about me
(surprise!) and that there exists a vast and indefinable presence that connects
all of us. And I have felt brief moments of peace that I have not experienced
before.I have
also seen the power of living in the present moment or, more precisely, of being
the moment. When we are able to still all the internal chatter of reliving the
past and thinking of the future, all of which are just dreams and imaginings,
what is left is moment by moment living. I have
also obtained a clearer distinction between image and reality in ALS. Image is a
projection of all of our negative ideas about what it is to be disabled, learned
from conventional societal attitudes. Reality is what people actually experience
when living with ALS, which can be much more positive than our images, as
personal stories in this Guidebook illustrate.Many
sources have helped contribute to my new found awareness, including my spiritual
training which began in earnest about a year ago, but reading the daily posts on
the Living with ALS forum has been an important factor. One’s
heart cannot but melt when reading posts of deep distress, helpfulness, courage,
compassion, caring, optimism, determination, good humor and encouragement.While ALS
takes away options that were once present, it can also act as a stimulus to
develop new ways of perceiving oneself and life. I feel that I have barely
scratched the surface and look forward to going more deeply into the spiritual
and personal development realms as time goes on.
ALS -- NOT CURABLE, BUT TREATABLE
By Edward Oppenheimer, M.D.
Dr.
Oppenheimer was on the faculty of UCLA Medical School Neurology Department. He
was a strong advocate for PALS and was a member of Living with ALSA, where he
often answered questions and wrote valuable, informative articles, such as the
one below.Many diseases can, of
course, cause death if not treated. High spinal cord injury, a serious
infection, an appendicitis, etc., can kill when neglected. When treated, these
are still serious conditions, but usually life can continue and death can be
prevented.
It's true that the average length of life of people with ALS today is about four
years. However, this reflects the fact that people with ALS often don't have
optimal treatment and resources.
If ALS is to be fully treated, people with the disease should have;
- Adequate
information about the treatments available
- Access to health
professionals who are interested in and experienced
- With all the
available options in the care of ALS
- The encouragement
to go forward
- The needed
resources to go forward
- The desire to use
available care
When the patient lacks
the desire to use available care, after having been fully informed and provided
with a positive approach from professionals such as doctors, nurses, physical
and occupational therapists, social workers and others, not proceeding is
acceptable. However, when any of the needs cited are insufficiently filled, not
treating ALS to the fullest is regrettable. Ideally, this situation shouldn't
exist.
What is "fully treated" ALS? The answer is my "wish list" for all people with
ALS;
1. A positive and experienced team approach to assist patients and their
caregivers in solving any of the problems that typically occur. This means a
patient should have access to a team of adept and enthusiastic health
professionals who are available even when the patient isn't taking part in a
research protocol. The team should include professionals who can make home
visits and coordinate care as needed.
2. Very good nutrition to maintain appropriate weight. At some point this may
include using a gastrostomy tube (feeding tube) if swallowing problems occur.
3. Regular social interaction with friends and the community. It's vital that
the person with ALS get out of the house by using mobility assistance, stay
engaged in living and maintain ways to communicate even if speech becomes
difficult. Good alternative and augmentative communication devices are
essential.
4. Personal assistance to cover each 24 hours as needed, without placing an
undue burden on family members.
5. Vigorous treatment for infections, particularly respiratory infections. This
can often be provided at home with appropriate antibiotics when needed.
Medication can be given by mouth, via a feeding tube or even intravenously,
depending on the person's condition.
6. Monitoring of breathing capacity so noninvasive assisted ventilation can be
available when capacity is decreased and related symptoms are present. An ALS
patient can receive mask-delivered or other noninvasive ventilation as long as
this works, and then shift to tracheostomy (invasive ventilation, via a tube
into the trachea) if that becomes necessary. Equally important are good
attention to effective coughing and clearing of secretions, and prevention of
aspiration (inhaling particles, such as food, into the lungs). The decision to
stop using a ventilator at any time, or to use only noninvasive ventilation and
not go on to tracheostomy ventilation, should be made by the patient.
7. Access to ALS research centers and protocols when desired, and access to
excellent ALS care even when there is no desire to participate in research.
8. Very good supportive care.
9. Good symptom-relieving care when major aspects of treatment are no longer
desired or appropriate.
When most of these aspects of care are available to people with ALS, they can
often continue living in a productive way and avoid life-threatening
complications related to ALS most of the time. ALS motor neuron impairment may
become severe, but life and spirit and social ties can continue.
Ideally, people with ALS should have choices. They should know that there are
options that will allow living to continue even if the resources needed are
considerable.
SIGNATURE EXPRESSIONS
Gathered from different
sites, these expressions, placed at the end of posts, illustrate coping
mechanisms in highly condensed form. They are little gems.
Don't forget to live!
Your friend in the fight
Laughing is good
exercise: it’s like jogging on the inside
Living & loving everyday
There is no such thing
in anyone's life as an unimportant day.
When you find yourself
in a hole . . . first stop digging!
It's not in our
abilities that we show who we truly are, it's in our choices
I know God will not give
me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn'ttrust me so much. (Mother Teresa)
Life's a dance, you
learn as you go
PSYCHOLOGICAL ISSUES OF NEW PALS AND COPING
IDEAS
By Randy Roberts
I am afraid of
dying: will itbe painful, will I
suffer, will it happen soon.
You are getting
way ahead of yourself; ALS is a gradually progressing illness.Morbid thinking
creates lowered mood, let such thoughts go. Focus on living now. Find
interesting activities to preoccupy your mind.Nobody, sick or
well, knows when they will die, only that all of us will pass away at
some time.Become involved
in spiritual work.There are many
ways to extend your life span. Be proactive, stay ahead of the disease.Remember, ALS
does not have to be fatal, you have a choice.
My life will
never be the same; how can I give up all my dreams, hopes and plans.
Grief is a
normal, painful stage that all PALS have to work through. It doesn’t
last forever, but may return after each new loss.You may continue
with your regular life for awhile and follow thru on some of your plans,
just sooner, like special vacations, etc.As you adjust to
your limitations, new plans and goals will be set.Reread the
personal stories in this section. Pay special attention to PALS’
descriptions of their meaningful, rewarding and happy lives even with
ALS.
I feel depressed
andanxious all the time.
Depression and
anxiety, like grief, are expected reactions.Identify what
you are thinking when you feel bad. Is it a negative?Observe how it
worsens your mood and then try to let the thoughts go.Stay aware of
such negative thoughts and let them go each time.Seek spiritual
guidance.Work at focusing
on positive goals, projects, things that interest you but you didn’t
have time for in the past.Focus on what
you still have. Appreciate that which is taken for granted when healthy
are truly special gifts.If bad feelings
persist, discuss antidepressant/anti anxiety meds with your doctor or
increase what you are now taking.Join
Living
with ALS, ask for suggestions, establish an on line peer support
network.Let yourself be inspired and encouraged by what you read.Consider
counseling or therapy.Communicate your
feelings to others. Don’t let yourself get cut off from family and old
friends. Build a new support network.A little humor
can work wonders. Find somebody or something that makes you laugh every
day.
I am fearful and
embarrassed about becoming dependent on others.
Again return to
the present. Let negative thoughts dissipate. You are getting ahead of
yourself.When the time
comes, you will be surprised that you will welcome the assistance, as it
becomes exhausting and risky to try to do something independently when
capacities diminish. You can now use your energy more productively on
other things that really matter.Aren’t all
people dependent on others, anyway?Your
embarrassment or shame will wither away as you realize that it is no big
deal and your caregiver views it as no big deal.
I keep thinking
of what liesdown theroad
Go back to the
present. Worrying about future events leads to worsened mood. Let the
thoughts go as they are preventing you from living well now.Nobody knows
what lies in the future, e.g. an effective drug against ALS could be
discovered soon. Become involved
in interesting and productive activities instead.
I am so angry
all the time
Anger is a
normal reaction to what has happened and is a stage that must be worked
through. It becomes a problem when it persists and you become bitter and
closed off. Then you are not living with ALS, but are being eaten up
inside.Chronic anger
and irritability may reflect underlying depression. Speak to your health
care professional about it. Try a
visualization technique. Imagine ALS to be an object of some sort. I
visualize a hideous looking scarecrow, and then proceed, in my
imagination, to inflict all kinds of punishment to him: kicking,
chopping, punching, bludgeoning, till he is reduced to pulp. I may do
this for 5 minutes and I always obtain a sense of satisfaction and
release. Just give back to him what he has done to you, no holds barred.Join
Living
with ALS. As you read the posts your heart may open up.Bitterness and
chronic anger prevents you from living your life to its fullest; they
close off options and keeps you imprisoned in their grasp.
How is my
illness going to affect my marriage or relationship with my significant
other.
It’s very
stressful on caregivers, but many handle it well. Some CALS, however,
are not able to manage.Discuss issues
directly with your CALS; don’t assume anything.Help make
arrangements to reduce stress, or encourage your spouse or other family
caregiver to do so, when things become too difficult for him/her, e.g.
paid care providers, help from family and friends, etcExpress your
appreciation. Thank yous, and expressions of affection are helpful.Don’t take out
your resentment on your spouse and make an effort to apologize if you
should slip.Working together
can bring you closer.If conflict or
dissatisfaction become intense, and can’t seem to be resolved, consider
counseling or begin to think of alternative living arrangements. The
earlier you can detect problems in your CALS’ commitment and/or major
shortcomings the better.
Why did this
happen to me?
Every PALS and
their CALS ask this painful question. It seems to demand an answer but
of course there is no answer. Coming to grips with it is part of the
acceptance process. It lessens in intensity and frequency over time.
COPING WITH ALS
By Loris Buccola
This piece integrates many of the ideas
presented in this chapter
I was diagnosed with limb onset ALS in November 1999 at age 58. I'm pretty much
completely quadriplegic, retaining head and neck movement. I still have my voice
with volume somewhat diminished, swallowing and breathing also diminished
(forced vital capacity below 30% at my last measurement a year ago) but intact.
I had a feeding tube placed December 2004 and use it for supplemental
nourishment once a day. I use a BiPAP at night and portable ventilator (LTV 900)
as needed during the day. I have a Permobil power wheelchair with four-way seat
adjustment, Switchit head controls and a Roho cushion. I sleep on a Pegasus
Airwave mattress and an adjustable bed. I use Dragon Naturally Speaking,
Smartnav head mouse, dwell click software and Skeleton Key (an on-screen
keyboard) to navigate the computer. I have a tablet computer for my wheelchair
with which I can control electronic devices. I have a Ford Windstar with a VMI
wheelchair access conversion. Although I'm retired from a 40 year teaching
career, I still continue to do professional counseling, writing and e-mail
correspondence with friends and family. I still "read" using the Talking Books
Program (through the Oregon State library) extensive library of books on tape.
I'm also a movie buff and subscribe to the Internet DVD service, Netflix. Here
are some techniques and attitudes I have discovered which have helped me to
continue adjusting to this disease, avoid depression and continue to appreciate
life.
1.Attitude is everything.
ALS is a challenge to adapt, rather than a battle to be won,
an opportunity to learn the art of acceptance. Learn how to pick your
"battles" by
learning new skills instead of struggling to deny the
reality of what is happening to your body. People will think you are really
wise and spiritual and
will want to be around you. It's magic.
Although it will be difficult at first, resolve immediately
to learn how to ask for and even enjoy getting help from other people. If
this disease can
teach us anything, it is that we cannot survive alone. It
will bring you closer to them and them to you. Some people may not be able
to handle whatis happening to you except by
staying away. That is their problem, not yours.
2.Plan realistically for the future.
The name of the game with this disease is adaptation. Try to
avoid wasting valuable time which you need to plan for the coming changes in
your life.
If you wait for a crisis, it will probably be already too
late.
Begin now learning to conserve your energy by not trying to
do more than you are realistically capable of. Deciding what is realistic
and what is thebest use of limited energy is a
major step in adaptation.
Anticipate the future just enough to ask yourself how you
will adapt as your physical strength declines. For example, I began learning
how to usespeech software before I really needed
it. By the time I did, I was proficient at it. It took six months to get
wheelchair I needed. Learning to usehead
controls, getting used to using breathing assistance, feeding tube, etc. all
takes more time than we anticipated.
If you have not already done so, consider attending an ALS
support group. It will be difficult at first to see people in all stages of
this disease. I hadto resolve to go back for
three group meetings. By that time I was already getting used to this look
into the future, learning how other people cope. with what is happening in.
We do not easily recover from setbacks from illness or
physical injury as we did prior to the onset of this disease. Time wasted is
time lost foradaptation. So, for example, don't
push yourself to continue walking until you fall and break a bone.
In spite of what you may hear, there is no cure for this
disease. Pursuing claims of cures will only cost you money and put you in a
time deficit. Once you have been diagnosed, avoid
falling into the trap of believing that it is something other than ALS (Lyme
disease, mercury fillings, etc.). When aneffective treatment is discovered we will all know about it and someone will
no doubt get the Nobel Peace Prize. My own rule on this: put me in touchwith three people who are clearly diagnosed who have at least six
months on this "treatment" and let me talk to them personally about how it
hasworked.
3.Dealing with Depression
ALS is a lousy disease and quite unfair. But try to avoid
taking it personally. It did not happen because of anything we did or did
not do. Giveyourself the luxury of feeling sorry for you only on a limited
basis, for example an hour a day or, even better, an hour a week.
Avoid dwelling on or worrying about all the awful stuff you
may have to go through in the future, or ruminating on all the things you
did not do in thepast. Of course, some of us with
ALS have other things to be depressed about besides the disease and this can
make avoiding depression much moredifficult.
4.Do something every day that gives you pleasure.
I love my morning coffee, having my head scratched, getting
a warm shower, watching a good movie, listening to a great book, listening
to jazz andblues, following the sports scene.
Be with people whom you love and who love you. You have a
right not to be with people who sap your energy. People will like being with
you if you
can help them get used to what is happening to you. Be nice.
Plan for things in the future that you can look forward to,
like visits from children and grandchildren, friends etc.
Cultivate a sense of humor about this disease. Some of it is
so ridiculous that it is actually funny. For example, I have unbitten
fingernails for thefirst time in my life.
Seriously consider antidepressant medication. It is not
addictive and it is not a weakness to need medication to help out with the
symptoms ofdepression.
If you have not already, begin to cultivate a spiritual
approach to life. There is more to this life than meets the eye. You will
have plenty of timeto think about these things,
the ultimate meaning of life, the nature and existence of something or
someone beyond us and upon which we depend. Youdon't have to have any formal religious training or upbringing. The process
of discovering meaning and purpose beyond our own little worlds is thebeginning of spirituality. Spirituality does not have to have any
complicated theology. In fact, the simpler the better.
Trust your instincts. In spite of a lifetime of religious
faith, I have come to believe that God did not cause me to have ALS, and in
fact is assaddened by the bad things that happen
to people as we are. I also am confident that God is with us in all of these
things just as he/she/it hasbeen with millions of
others over the centuries.
This disease can help us develop a sense of gratitude and
wonder about the mystery of life and death. It has taught me to embrace the
difficultexperiences of life as opportunities
instead of as obstacles to a meaningful life. I enjoyed "Learning to Fall"
by Philip Simmons, a teacher and writerwho had
ALS.
5.Taking care of your caregivers.
ALS is a social disease; it not only affects us who actually
have the physical symptoms, it also profoundly affects and changes the lives
of thosearound us who love us and care for us. We
have a responsibility, especially if we want to learn how to adapt and
prosper, to make sure we don'tovertax our
caregivers physically and emotionally. We will naturally tend to become
demanding, frustrated and impatient at times. But the more wedo this, the less people will want to be around us.
Make sure your network of care is wide enough to give people
some time away to recover and recuperate. Avoid the temptation to just pick
out oneor two favorites upon which to rely
completely. No one, no matter how much they love us can handle the load by
themselves.
You will learn gradually that you can tolerate not getting
immediate help that you don't really need: tolerating an itch you can't
reach.
TIPS ON DEALING WITH ALS BY alsfrombothsides
http://www.living-with-als.org/alsfrombothsides/
As someone quite amazed to
find herself in her 17th year of ALS and still busily,
happily, and contentedly engaged in living, I have reached the
point where I find myself saying "If I'd known I was going to
live this long, I would have taken better care of myself!"
For that reason, the main focus of this site is on dealing with
some of the medical complications we face as a result of ALS.
All too often these things are inadequately addressed because
the expectation is that we will not be around long enough to
worry about "long term" problems. These are problems that can
and must be minimized in order to assure a good quality of life
even if that life is short. In addition, I believe several
factors are going to extend the life of ALS patients in years to
come: The development of medications to slow progression.
Continued improvements in supportive care (nutrition,
respiratory support etc.)
Computer aided communication and environmental control equipment
will greatly improve the quality of life for ALS patients who
opt for ventilation. As a result more of us will take that
option and live for many more years.
There are also sections with practical tips for dealing with
some of the basic problems presented by immobility such as
traveling, and more sections to be added.
Safe Harbor
Rediscovering life on a ventilator.
Dress for success:
Toileting using a lift.
ALS Inservice for Nursing
Staff:
Read it or download it and pass it on.
Swelling of feet and legs:
Why it happens and how to minimize it.
Constipation:
Prevention and treatment tips.
Osteoporosis and Calcium in
ALS:
Why osteoporosis is "different" in patients
with neuromuscular disease.
BiPAP:
A non-life support breathing assistance
device.
Muscle Spasms -- Cramping and
Spasticity
Which is it and how can it be treated?
Travel Tips:
Some things I have learned while traveling.
The Attic:
No practical tips here, just my response to
a friend's question about what it is like to
livewith ALS.
Another aspect of coping
is knowing about assistive devices that can help compensate for weakened
capacities. At
http://living-with-als.org/
You can find reviews of
such devices, as can be viewed on the homepage:

Bathroom
Bedroom
Call Systems
Clothing
Computer
Eating/Drinking
Entertainment
Mobility
Respiratory
Speech &Communication
Travel
Miscellaneous

Many of the
questions on the
living-with-als group concern the equipment needed to deal with
disability. This section of our website was set up to help people
with ALS in their search for that equipment.
Unlike other sites that provide a
list of links to retailers and manufacturers, these pages are
reviews of specific brands written by people who have purchased or
tried them. The members of the living-with-als group hope this will
help others find the best possible equipment to keep them
living-well-with-als.
Computer Desk
Have you
designed, built, or adapted something that makes living with ALS
easier? Share your creative genius in the Do It Yourself (DIY)
section.
PEG Tubes
Buying a Van
Buying a Wheelchair
Hiring a Caregiver
ALS repeatedly presents challenges
that leave us stranded in unfamiliar territory. Dealing with
doctors, bureaucratic red tape, purchasing expensive equipment
without knowing what options are really needed, picking our way
through a financial minefield, as well as adjusting to disability is
all new and frustrating. These Tip Sheets are intended to be a
source of practical advice from the real experts -- PALS and CALS
who have been there, done that, and are wearing the T- shirt that
says "I wish I had known..."
Bathroom Design
#1
Bathroom Design #2
AccessibleHalf-Bath
Few homes
have been built with wheelchair accessibility in mind, so ALS often
requires some degree of remodeling. Share your remodeling project
with others here! Whether you want to share details such as floor
plans, before and after, tips and tricks, advice on getting the job
done, or just show off some pictures of the finished product, we'd
love to have your input.
Chapter 3A
ESPECIALLY FOR CALS
CALS go through the same
psychological stages as their PALS and, in addition, have the added
responsibilities of caring for the needs of their loved one, taking on financial
burdens and extra chores around the home. It can be overwhelming and CALS are
always vulnerable to exhaustion and burn out. The following articles convey the
strains felt by loving CALS, how to cope and how to take care of one’s own
needs.
My Story
By Trish
My name is Trish Wilson
and in my lifetime, have had many titles to my name, some being: sister, friend,
girlfriend, wife, mom and now my newest title, CALS or for you not familiar with
this new title, Caregiver of a person with ALS. Yep, Lou Gehrig’s disease.
Never in my wildest dreams did I ever imagine that this would be a title I would
have in my resume. When my wonderful husband Mike and I began searching for a
diagnosis to a problem he was having with his speech, we had no idea what this
search would lead to. We began as most of you will, with a simple visit to his
family doctor. From there we were sent without diagnosis to a neurologist due to
his tongue, speech and throat problems all along believing he had some growth in
this throat that was tying up his nerves in his mouth and neck.. Diagnosis' were
flying from friends and family only to make me a nervous wreck but having no
affect on my husband still believing it was some kind of growth that we could
have removed and move along with our lives. As we were put through an array of
testing, none of which we were told why they were being done, I became more and
more nervous every time they told me, "all of his tests are fine". I knew in my
gut he wasn't fine and wanted them to find SOMETHING wrong. I know, it sounds
insane, please find something wrong with my husband. I just wanted something to
be found so we could "fix it" and get back to normal.Needless to say, after our months of testing, two months to be exact which I now
find is a very fast time for diagnosis, the verdict was, "I think we are dealing
with Lou Gehrig’s Disease" were the words from our neurologists mouth. I, of
course, thought the man was a quack and after the initial shock, thought, I'll
take this into my own hands. If this doctor thinks Mike has ALS, I'll show him.
I'll go to an ALS specialist and prove he has no idea what he is talking about.
So, we did. We found the best specialist in Arizona only to discover once they
heard Mike was having swallowing problems, had lost over 35 pounds, felt
paralysis in his tongue, they rushed us in to see the doctor. Well, my feeling
of "that doctor was a quack" was becoming a nightmare. After seeing the ALS
specialist the very next day, it was confirmed. Mike has ALS. He was now a PALS
and I was now a CALS.Mike and I both have been through an array of emotions from extreme sadness, to
denial, which comes often, to acceptance. We have not been through the anger
simply because we do have an incredibly strong faith and believe God has chosen
our path and this is a path we have to live out with dignity. It is my husband
that shows me how to deal with this and it is my husband who is my hero for
taking this on in such a brave and unique way. Don't get me wrong, we both dream
of the days where "this can't be real" but for the most part, we are LIVING with
ALS and plan to continue doing this and embracing life for as long as God will
give us. ALS is not a death sentence, just a new way to appreciate your life.
CALS TO CALS
By Erin
Speaking CALS to CALS I want you to know you
have every right to feel the way you do. You wouldn't be human if you didn't.
Newly married or long time honeymooner's we all feel the loss, the frustration,
the anger, the loneliness.You will go in and out of all the above emotions. It is natural; it is just the
way it is.I have many years with my precious husband. But his progression was so fast we
didn't have one, two, or more years to come to grips with ALS. If he could only
do an nth of a fraction that some of our long time PALS here do, my husband and
I would have the world.So CALS, cry if you want to. Be mad, frustrated. Let those feelings happen but
then go look into your loved ones face, take their face into your hands and tell
them "I Love You". Everyday do that. After a while more love and new memories
will happen. You will always have the gamut of emotions, sometimes worse than
other times. But you will have what time is given to you on this earth with each
other.One thing for sure, you will learn the depths of love and compassion.
The emotional roller coaster can't be described. The emotions and stress, the
loss of living our day to day lives as we both knew it, as our children knew it,
is over.Some PALS with a slow progression have lived a good life for years.
Each CALS goes through a very isolated gamut of feelings and feels alone at
times. We could each write our own book and many of us have website's and blogs
to release our feelings, our progression, our journey. These sites and this
site, "Living with ALS" are the greatest help there is. Take it from me. My
husband’s progression was so fast we didn't have time to realize what was
happening. It wasn't until he finally reached a plateau that we could learn
about this thing called ALS.I never met anyone in an ALS group meeting that was at the stage of my husband.
No help there. It was early on and I needed answers, I needed help. I would
write to the ALS Digest and never get any answers. Very disappointing! It wasn't
until I discovered the "Living with ALS" site that I began to get answers and
discovered the most wonderful and compassionate people in the same boat as us.
What a base of humanity this site is to find this place with PALS and CALS that
know, that understand, that can cry with you, make you laugh with joy, allow you
to express the love, the sorrow, the frustrations, the unknown future. We all do
this together.I love you all.Erin CALS to Jeff
FROM ALSA’S INTERVIEW WITH SANDY
You and Bob continue to
enjoy vacations. What kind of preparation is needed before, during and after
travel with your husband?Travel requires a lot of
planning to be successful. At each stage of Bob's illness, we have traveled, and
the challenges increase as the illness progresses. However, the rewards are
worth it! Initially we just needed a wheelchair to get us through airports and a
roomier more comfortable car to rent at our destination. Now, we need a
wheelchair accessible room and bathroom with guaranteed access to all public
areas (make phone calls, and double/triple check!) We need to be sure that the
restaurants in the area have food Bob can eat comfortably or we need a
refrigerator so we can bring our own. We don't travel by air anymore - too many
hassles with his power wheelchair being damaged or mishandled, but we do have a
van that we are comfortable traveling in. We had an easy-lock device installed
to make tie downs fast and easy, I pack a cooler with pureed foods for him, lots
of water and syringes. Bob's computer goes on his chair up front with me, a good
map and a guidebook of accessible trails and we are off. I have to remember to
pack the charger for his chair, toilet necessities, pillows, extra clothes (he
gets cold),a blender, all his medications/vitamins, emergency communication
device(alphabet board) ,etc, and a smile. We have been very lucky and have found
that getting away even for 2 days gives us both a change of scenery and renews
our strength. We have seen some gorgeous mountain trails that are wheelchair
friendly! Once we get back home it is important to give Bob a lot of down time
in a comfortable chair, because one of the drawbacks of car travel is he is
confined to his wheelchair all the time.
How has Bob's diagnosis
of ALS changed your life?
In every way. It has
narrowed the focus of life to its essentials - love and respect, and has
deepened our love and commitment to each other. It also has me always alert
(sleeping is a challenge), and trying to care for the details of someone else's
life as well as my own is tough sometimes. With each change in Bob's condition,
using the wheelchair, having to feed him etc., we have grieved the loss and
struggled to handle it. I am, however, truly grateful for this time we have
together, and am amazed at the grace with which he makes each adaptation. No
matter how it has changed my life - his has changed a million times more!
What does the word
"Caregiver" mean to you?
For me, it is a lot of
responsibility with a lot of rewards. It is a chance to outwardly express my
respect and love for my husband. When hiring outside help I ask for kindness,
attentiveness, gentleness and respect for Bob and his changing needs. Knowing
that Bob's mind is functioning at top speed, even though his body doesn't, is a
challenge for some people. I need people who have the heart and inclination to
get to know this wonderful man.
As a primary caregiver,
it is often a challenge to maintain facets of your own personal life. How do you
maintain a sense of balance in your life?
Well, I didn't,
initially. But now, we have hired outside help (no help from the insurance
unfortunately) and I have re-established my friendships and work associations.
Not knowing how long we have together has made me reluctant to miss a moment,
but having help 5 days a week, 8 hours a day, makes the 16 hours a day I am
Bob's caregiver now have more balance. I also realized early on that I would
need guidance and I continue to see a counselor to help me deal with the
incredible loss and grief we experience daily. I try to get a massage at least
twice a month too!
LETTER FROM LINDA
ALLEN
Linda is a former CALS
and current Program Manager for Extra Hands for ALS. In this letter she
describes the challenges and rewards of long distance travel with her husband,
which personifies the idea of living fully with ALS, and also discusses the
innovative Extra Hands program, which links young people with PALS and their
families. Linda has given her personal email address and is willing to share her
knowledge about travel.Also check out the Extra Hands web site for a moving
description of the Program and its origins.
http://www.extrahands.org/linallen@swbell.net(email)and Linda@extrahands.org
My husband Marshall was
dx. Oct 31, 1996 at the age of 54 and earned his wings on Oct.27, 2000.You are
right when you say, “do all the things that you have planned on doing as soon
after dx”.We decided early on that we were going to continue to live our lives
despite ALS.We traveled by air, ship, bus, train, van, with the Permobile
wheelchair.(Europe AFOs), US and the Caribbean with wheelchair), we went to
restaurants, the theatre, sporting events, to visit grandchildren etc.We
learned to expect there would be road blocks a long the way but we believed that
we could navigate around them.We had some funny stories surrounding our
adventures, others that brought us to tears; times when we educated
management/housekeeping staff/ about things they could do to make their
establishments more handicap accessible, and coming up with innovative ideas to
solve a problem when we could not find a resource/solution for.Was it easy
“no it was not” was it worth it…you bet!I have so many wonderful memories
because we decided to continue to live life and so do our children, his two
sisters/brother-in-laws, my family and friends. I promised Marshall that
after he was gone that I would continue in the fight against ALS until there was
a cure. I am keeping that promise by working with Extra Hands for ALS.I hope
we can reach all our PALS/CALS in every area in every state with this program.What better way of spreading the word about ALS than through young people who
will be our doctors, researchers, lawyers, congressmen/women, etc. ALS families
have the opportunity to teach these young people about ALS and learn about the
disease first hand. The “extra hands” do household chores, yard work, playing
with the children, providing company to the PALS, whatever the ALS family needs
done that will take some of the burden off the shoulders of the caregiver.Instead of doing what needs to be done the caregiver can read, catch up on phone
calls, work in their shop, work on a hobby, spend quality time with the family
while the students are working etc.These students learn so many life lessons
that they would never learn if they had not been involved with an ALS family.Some PALS/CALS have had such an influence in the lives of the students that some
have decided to take up the same career as their PALS or CAL, or by learning
about ALS have decided to become a doctor, physical therapist, speech
pathologist etc.Also these kids let their families/friends know what they are
doing and teach them about ALS.The family members tell other family members,
colleagues, neighbors about what their kids are doing….more Awareness of ALS.It is my hope that we can
find teams of individual volunteers that would like to get involved and start
this program in their area. It takes a group of interested people, ALS families
that will use the service and a source in the community that will help to fund
the program.
TEN TIPS FOR FAMILY CAREGIVERS
1. Choose to take charge
of your life, and don't let your loved one's illness or disability always take
center stage.2.Remember to be good
to yourself.Love, honor and value yourself. You're doing a very hard job and
you deserve some quality time, just for you. 3. Watch out for signs of
depression, and don't delay in getting professional help when you need it.
4. When people offer to
help, accept the offer and suggest specific things that they can do. 5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
CHAPTER 4
MAJOR ORGANIZATIONS AND
WEBSITES
The first website to look
at is the Living with ALS group and the link to join is:
http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/living-with-als/messages
This forum has members
who are exclusively PALS and CALS and who range from newbies to 20 year
veterans.Posts cover a wide array of topics relevant to ALS, e.g. coping
strategies, personal issues/problems, symptom control, Medicare coverage,
equipment, just letting off steam, etc. Really, anything at all that involves
ALS. Practical and helpful information is offered, often more useful than what
professionals can provide. Members are enormously supportive, caring, wise and
knowledgeable. Many friendships are formed between members. Examples of a page
of posts are given below:
Subject
Author
Date
32205
Re: burning feetAre you taking any kind of blood thinner? Have you had a
doppler study done? I...
Danny
Oct10,2005
10:32 am
32206
Re: psychological impactI am sorry Fern that more people are not coming to see you.
When I was told I ...
COOKIEDD
Oct10,2005
10:33 am
32207
Re: Moms in the hospital again.she has no gall bladder, no appendix, no uterus, etc. they
have had to give her...
Mr. and
Mrs. Travis S...
Oct10,2005
10:34 am
32208
Re:
Nursing home
Thom, Fern and others Here is the starting page on starting
a search and how...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32209
Re: new pulse ox neededLinda I paid $199 for mine. I wouldn't pay any less.
http://www.savelives.com/...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32210
Re: Heart Race problemDanny You state the oxygen sat rate isn't affected by the
BiPAP. Here is a...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:43 pm
32211
Re: One Person Home CareJim, Our stories are amazingly similar including the size
differential and the ...
Jeff
Lester
Oct10,2005
3:06 pm
32212
Re: BiPAP Mark & LarryDear Lisa, I don't know if anyone else has mentioned this,
but is it possible...
Edith
Oct10,2005
3:30 pm
32213
Re: One Person Home CareJim, I like your innovative approach and determination. Can
you explain what...
Randy
Roberts
Oct10,2005
4:35 pm
32214
Re: Crazy Week
... of a ... say ... chair ... I know Susan, i wanted to
hide LOL! Things are...
Oct10,2005
6:57 pm
32215
Re: speech
Oct10,2005
7:00 pm
32216
(No
subject)
I was just wondering if anybody has a problem with waking up
and the covers ...
murrza
Oct10,2005
7:01 pm
32217
Re: Nursing homeA good place to find your local resources for possibly
living at home is your...
Oct10,2005
7:40 pm
32218
Re: One Person Home CareHi Randy, I was referring to a system with a overhead
hanging container...
Jim
Oct10,2005
9:26 pm
32219
peg tube stopped thanksThanks to all who answered my email. My hubby is calling the
gastro doc ...
Debbie
Oct10,2005
9:54 pm
32220
Re: One Person Home CareAllison, Jim and Jeff, THANK you for sharing your stories
with us on this...
Susan
Oct10,2005
9:57 pm
32221
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home CareHi all, I have read a few of the postings about the dilemma
about care at...
STOPALS
Oct11,2005
2:18 pm
32222
comfort curveI need to hear more feedback on the Comfort Curve mask.
Hospice won't pay for...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
2:22 pm
32223
Flu Shots for People with ALS
This is to remind PALS (people with ALS) it's time for your
annual flu shot....
Oct11,2005
5:15 pm
32224
Clinic TrialI went to my ALS clinic on Monday. They gave me my FVC
breathing test and they...
COOKIEDD
Oct11,2005
6:31 pm
32225
Re: comfort curveSherry, When I first got the Comfort Curve, I wore it only
in bed with my...
Randy
Roberts
Oct11,2005
6:33 pm
32226
Re: re [living-with-als] visionOn Thu, 8 Sep 2005 14:22:19 -0700 (PDT) Erin Smith
<erinzinn5@...> ... ...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32227
Re: Friends ~ Where Are They?Dear Sue, I can relate to that. Hang in there. God will send
new angels. Andi...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32228
Re: I'm new herewelcome Connie! Andi ... On Wed, 07 Sep 2005 06:57:09 -0000
"Connie ODonnell"...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32229
Re: comfort curve
Randy Thanks so much. I only have my bed on a partial turn.
I couldn't handle...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
8:18 pm
32230
ALS Registry Act Introduced in U.S. House of Representatives2005 Advocacy Update October 11, 2005 ALS Registry Act
Introduced in U.S. House...
lou_gehrig_054
Oct11,2005
8:19 pm
32231
Beds that turn youMy name is Bill and this is my first post. I have been
listening in for about...
netravelingman
Oct12,2005
9:04 am
32232
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home Care
Does your ride for life support your state only? In Calif, I
only get 1500 ...
rovall
Oct12,2005
9:05 am
32233
Re:
Friends ~ Where Are They?
Dear Sue, Sorry to hear that John's Mom and sister haven't
contacted you. It's...
COOKIEDD
Oct12,2005
10:00 am
The reader just clicks on
the first few lines of the post to get the complete post.
You can use a search
feature to get back posts on a subject of special interest. This site provides a
window into the world of ALS and can be inspiring, touching, informative, wise
and loving. There is also a chat room led by member of the forum and can be
accessed at:
http://www.mdausa.org/chat/calendar.html#lalsLocate the Living with
ALS chat and sign in as a visitor. Chats are held 2-5 pm on Sundays, 3-6 pm and
9-11 pm on Mondays and 7-10 pm Wednesdays. All times listed are Central time.
Transcripts of past chats are on file.
Another ALS peer forum,
Brain Talk Communities, is also quite good. Its strength lies in its many posts
on current research in the field and its section on personal experiences with
different treatments. The link is:http://brain.hastypastry.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=82The ALS Association (ALSA)is the only national not-for-profit health organization dedicated solely
to the fight against ALS. ALSA covers all the bases - research, patient and
community services, public education, and advocacy - in providing help and hope
to those facing the disease. The mission of The ALS Association (ALSA) is to
find a cure for and improve living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.
Its
website is chock full of information in every area related to ALS. The link is:
http://www.alsa.org/default.cfm?CFID=897541&CFTOKEN=9724212
The home page looks like this (below is a
photo you can’t click on it)
As you click on the blue
headings, subtopics pop up on every aspect of ALS. For comprehensive information
on any or all areas related to ALS, this should be your first stop. The amount
of information is awesome and can be overwhelming at first, but will become
easier with practice.
“The Muscular Dystrophy
Association is a voluntary health agency- a dedicated partnership between
scientists and concerned citizens aimed at conquering neuromuscular diseases….MDA
combats neuromuscular diseases through programs of worldwide research,
comprehensive medical and community services, andfar-reaching
professional and public health education.”MDA has an ALS division whose website is very
informative. It provides research updates, a newsletter, interesting articles
and very useful information. As organizations, there
is much overlap between the two. Both offer funds for research and patient
services, such as advocacy and support groups.MDA offers funds to help pay for
some or all of the cost of certain medical equipment, such as wheelchairs and
seat cushions, computers with speech synthesizers, etc. Local offices of both
ALSA and MDA have loan closets from which you can borrow durable medical
equipment of all sorts, including some your insurance will not cover. Contact
your local offices of both ALSA and MDA, which you can locate on their websites,
for more information. MDA has more dollars for research and services/DME, while
ALSA focuses more on advocacy atthe national level.
It can be reached at:
http://als.mdausa.org/
MDA’s ALS home page looks
like this: (also a photo only, not a live web page):

The ALS Therapy
Development Foundation is a nonprofit biotechnology company discovering
treatments for patients alive today.Their laboratory, the
leading drug discovery program for ALS, bridges a critical research gap.In-house expertise translates research into potential drug candidates by
screening drugs in the SOD1 mouse model of ALS. Their scientific
collaborations are designed to bring the most promising leads closer to patient
use.ALS-TDF shares emerging knowledge on the disease with patients,
physicians, and researchers as quickly and comprehensively as possible. Their
unique approach accelerates drug development for ALS. In addition, ALS-TDF
offers a forum for discussion of research issues. The link is:http://www.als.net/forum/Ride for Life is an
organization directed by a PALS that raises money for research and patient
services from various events, including their “Ride for Life”, a yearly event.
Their website is very worthwhile to view. It includes a number of personal
stories, research findings, information on grants and other material of interest
to PALS/CALS. The link is:Ride For Life Helping People Living With ALS - Lou Gehrig's DiseaseThe above are a few of my
favorites. There are hundreds of interesting and worthwhile websites that you
can choose.
Below is a list of
websites that are comprehensive and far reaching:
ALS and
Associated Web SitesCompiled By: Steve Weekes
(
)
ALS INFORMATION WEB SITES
ALS SOCIETIES, SUPPORT GROUPS &
PUBLICATIONSALS Association Chapter WebsitesALS Related Societies
ALS SOCIETIES AROUND THE WORLD(Over 40 Countries Represented)
ALS CHAT ROOMS
ALS FORUMS and DISCUSSION GROUPS
CAREGIVER WEBSITESTravel AssistanceCaregiver Chat Rooms, Forums and Discussion Groups
PALS / CALS - PERSONAL WEBSITESInternational PALS / CALS Personal Web Sites
MEDICAL SEARCHES, INFORMATION &
JOURNALSLyme and ALS Associated DiseasesAdvanced Therapies, Treatments and ResearchGeneral Health Care and Information
ASSISTIVE AIDS, DEVICES, and
SOFTWAREGeneral Assistance SitesCommunication Assistance and SupportComputer Adaptive Devices & EquipmentWheel Chairs, Scooters & VehiclesSpecific Assistance SitesMind and Spirit Resources
NATURAL & SUPPLEMENTARY THERAPIESDiagnostic LaboratoriesNon-Conventional Doctors, Clinics, Treatments, Therapies &
Theories
PRODUCTS,SUPPLIERS, ETC...
CHAPTER 5
BENEFITS AND ENTITLEMENTS
As PALS and CALS, it is
vitally important that you learn about your government benefits: disability
payments and Medicare/Medicare. It is also vital that you learn to deal
effectively with your insurance companies. What follows are some articles to
help you get started.
SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS
By Danny Dandignac
For the full version click
here
To download the full version in Microsoft
Word right click
here
choose save target as
How do we decide if you are disabled?
SSDI & SSI
The process we use to
decide if you are disabled involves five steps. They are: 1.Are you working?
If you are working and
your average monthly earnings, after considering the effect of work incentives,
are at the Substantial Gainful Activity (SGA) level, we generally cannot
consider you disabled. If your monthly earnings average less than the SGA level,
(in 2006 that level was $860 per month) we look at your medical condition using
steps 2 through 5.
2.Is your medical
condition "severe"?
For us to consider you
disabled, your impairment(s) must significantly limit your ability to do basic
work activities, for example walking, sitting, seeing, and remembering. If it
does not, we cannot consider you disabled. If it does, we go to the next step.
3.Is your medical
condition in the list of disabling impairments?
We maintain a Listing of
Impairments for each of the major body systems that are so severe we
automatically consider you disabled. If your medical condition(s) is/are not on
the list, we have to decide if it is of equal severity to an impairment on the
list. If it is, we approve your claim. If it is not, we go to the next step.
4.Can you do the
work you did previously?
If your medical condition
is severe, but not at the same or equal severity as an impairment on the list,
then we must decide if you can do your past relevant work. If you can, we will
deny your claim. If you cannot, we go to the next step.
5.Can you do any
other type of work?
If you cannot do your
past relevant work, we then see if you are able to do any other type of work. We
consider your age, education, past work experience, and transferable skills. If
you cannot do any other kind of work, we will approve your claim. If you can, we
will deny your claim.
FURTHER INFORMATION ON SOCIAL SECURITY
BENEFITS
(TAKEN FROM THE REGULATIONS)
By Randy Roberts
Find out if you're eligible for Social
Security Benefits
Benefit Eligibility
Screening Tool (BEST)
Use our screening tool to help identify all the different Social Security
programs for which you may be eligible.
Overview
We pay disability
benefits under two programs: the Social Security disability insuranceprogram and the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program.
If you qualify,
apply for Social Security disability benefits online.
No matter what kind of
disability benefits you are applying for, you must
give us information about your medical, work, and education history to help
us decide if you are disabled.
- Note: If you're an
Advocate, Attorney or Third Party Representative,
we need additional information from you on the application.
Detailed information
about each of these programs is available at the following websites:
You don't have to be
disabled or blind to collect
Supplemental Security Income (SSI) if you are 65 or older.For most people, the
medical requirements for disability payments are the same under both programs,
and your disability is determined by the same process. Use our
Disability Planner to find out medical and earnings requirements, what
happens once you’re approved, and more.Our
calculatorscan give you an estimate of disability benefit amounts based on
your record if you should become disabled. If you get Social Security (not SSI)
disability benefits you
possibly could be eligible for Medicare.
SSI is a program run by
Social Security that pays monthly checks to the elderly, the blind and people
with disabilities who don't own much or who don't have much income. If you get
SSI, you usually get food stamps and Medicaid, too. Medicaid helps pay doctor
and hospital bills.While eligibility for
Social Security disability is based on prior work under Social Security, SSI
disability payments are made on the basis of financial need.
Who Can Get Social Security Disability
Benefits
Children may qualify for disability benefitsunder either the Social
Security program or the SSI program.You can get Social
Security disability benefits until age 65. When you reach age 65, your
disability benefits automatically convert to retirement benefits, but the amount
remains the same. Certain members of your
family may qualify for benefits on your record. They include:
- Your spouse who is
age 62 or older, or any age if he or she is caring for a child of yours who
is under age 16 or disabled and also receiving checks.
- Your disabled widow
or widower age 50 or older.
- Your unmarried son
or daughter, including an adopted child, or, in some cases, a stepchild or
grandchild. The child must be under age 18 or under age 19 if in high school
full time.
- Your unmarried son
or daughter, age 18 or older, if he or she has a disability that started
before age 22.
If you become the parent
of a child (including an adopted child) after you begin receiving Social
Security benefits, be sure to notify us so that we can determine if the child
qualifies for benefits. For more information
about disability benefits for children, ask Social Security for the booklet,
Benefits for Children With Disabilities
(Publication No. 05-10026).Note: The SSI program
also pays benefits to needy disabled children under age 18.
How to Apply for Disability Benefits
Apply as soon as you
become disabled. You can file:
- Online using our
Internet Social Security Benefit Application
- By phone, mail or in
person at any Social Security office. Call for
an appointment.
Note: You may receive
back benefits from the date you became disabled, but they're limited to one year
before the date you filed for benefits.
How to Speed Up Your Disability Claim
It generally takes from 3
to 5 months to process claims for disability benefits. You can help shorten the
process by bringing certain documents with you when you apply and helping us to
get any other medical evidence you need to show you are disabled. These include:
- Your Social Security
number;
- Your birth or
baptismal certificate;
- Names, addresses and
phone numbers of the doctors, caseworkers, hospitals and clinics that took
care of you and dates of your visits;
- Names and dosage of
all the medicine you take;
- Medical records from
your doctors, therapists, caseworkers, hospitals, and clinics that you
already have in your possession;
- Laboratory and test
results;
- A summary of where
you worked and the kind of work you did; and
- A copy of your most
recent W-2 Form (Wage and Tax Statement) or, if you are self-employed, your
federal tax return for the past year.
You also should be ready to answer other questions we must ask.
Don't delay filing for
benefits just because you don't have all the information and documents you need.
The people at the Social Security office will be glad to help you.
Who Can Get SSI Benefits
To get SSI benefits, you
must be elderly or blind or have a disability.
- "Elderly" means you
are 65 or older.
- "Blind" means you
are either totally blind or have very poor eyesight. Children, as well as
adults, can get benefits because of blindness.
- A disability means
you have a physical or mental problem that is expected to last at least a
year or result in death. Children, as well as adults, can get benefits
because of disability.
You must live in the U.S.
or Northern Mariana Islands and be a U.S. citizen or national. (Certain
non-citizens also may be eligible for SSI. A Social Security representative can
tell you if you qualify.) Also, the things you own
and your income must be below certain amounts. See our publication on
Supplemental Security Income (SSI)
(Publication No. 05-11000) for details about the income limits.
How Much You Can Get from SSI
The amount of your
benefit depends on
where you live.
You could get more if you
live in a state that adds to the SSI check. Or you could get less if you or your
family has other money coming in each month. Your living arrangements also make
a difference in whether you can get SSI and the amount you can get.
MEDICARE
By Andy Etherington
Andy
was diagnosed in 2002 and is now trached and vented. He is 45, married and has
two young children. Formerly, he worked in the telecommunications industry,
writing software and working with
customers.I will try to help as
much as I can. Note that I am not an expert or a lawyer, just an affected person
with a vested interest in this topic, and have been studying these issues for
the last six months. So everything below here is my interpretation of the
issues, and may not be correct.We will start with some
definitions.
Medicare
- coveragefromthefederalgovernment that you are entitled to. There are
3
PartstoMedicare. Do not confuse the parts of Medicare with the supplement
plans described below, they are vastly different. Part A coversmosthospitalizationcosts,exceptfora deductible of
$952foreachhospital stay of less than 61 days. If you stay for more than 60
days, there is a co-insurance of $238/day for the next 30 days. After 90 days it
goes up to $476/day through day 150. As near as I can tell, no one knows what
happens after day 150. Days 91-150 are referred to as lifetime reserve
days, and can only be used once. Note also that if you are discharged
from the hospital after less than 60 days, and are re-admitted again less than
60 days after your initial admission, it counts as the same hospital stay. You
are not charged the deductible again, and counting of days does not
start over. Part A costs you nothing extra, it is funded through
a 1.45% payroll tax on all workers. Part A is not optional, but also costs
nothing.
Part B coversmostoutofthehospitalexpenses,usuallyatthe
80%/20%rate.Thisincludesdurablemedicalequipment
(DME)suchasventilators,cough assistmachines,etc.thisispaidforthrough
adeductionof $88.50permonthfromyourSSDIcheck. This part is optional, but
be careful. If you don't sign up for it when you become eligible, you must wait
until an open enrollment period (usually January 1-February 28).
For every year you are eligible for part B, but decline
coverage, you are subject to a 10% penalty for each year that you declined coverage. This penalty is cumulative, so if you had declined
for 2 years, and then enrolled this year, instead of paying $88.50 per month,
you would pay $106.20 per month. Furthermore, if the Medicare rate goes up by
$10 next year, yours would go up by $12, and would continue to rise 20% higher
than the standard each year. There is an exception to this,
however. If you are covered by an employer sponsored group health plan, either
through your employer or your spouse's, and the person whose
coverage you are under is considered to be an active employee,
even if you're not being paid, you have what is called a special
enrollment period.You may enroll in Part B without penalty
any time while you're still covered by the group health plan, or during the 8
months following the loss of that coverage. Note that COBRA coverage is provided
to people whose employment has terminated, and does not provide or extend a
special enrollment period.
Part D– the infamous prescription drug program. This is a program that is provided
through private insurance companies to help with the cost of medicine. This part
is also optional, but again, be careful! If you don't sign up for
one by May 15, you are again subject to penalties. This time it is 1% per
month for each month you are eligible, but choose not to participate.
There is, once again, an exception to the penalty. If you have
been covered by a prescription plan from your company or union, or their
retirement program (I am interpreting this to include COBRA), and it
provided equivalent or better coverage than Part D, you may join
without penalty. Part D plans cost anywhere from $0-$100 per month, depending on
the company. Each plan has it's own formulary, or list of covered
drugs. If you take prescriptions that are not on the formulary, not only do you
pay full price for it, but the amount you pay does not count toward your Part D
deductible or out of pocket maximum. So your best bet is to find a plan that
covers your high cost medications, and pay for the less expensive medicines
yourself. I also dropped rilutek, because it not only expensive, but even on
plans with it on the formulary, because limits are based on the full price of
the drugs, it was going to increase my out of pocket cost by over $1000/year.
Since I'm already on a ventilator, none of my doctors could (or would) give me a
recommendation. If you have trouble understanding the Part D limits, I have
another document that describes it in more detail.
You are eligible
for these,butnotrequiredto accept them(see above) as
of the date you became eligible for social security
disability.Mostpeopleinthesocialsecurityofficewilltellyouthatyou'renoteligibleuntil
24monthslater.These people are wrong! The law was changed
three years ago; the word just hasn't trickled down to the local offices yet. You also cannot be denied Medicare because of your ALS diagnosis!
That is what it's there for. Find more information at
www.medicare.gov
Medicare supplements
- standardized plans, labeled A-J,
often called Medigap
plans, are offered by private insurance companies to
cover the perceived "gaps" in Medicare coverage. Each company offering a
Medicare supplement is allowed to charge whatever the market will bear, but
unlike the prescription program, supplement policies are required to provide
standard coverage. Thus company 1 can provide a plan A supplement (not the same as Part A above) for $59/ month; while company 2 has a plan A
supplement for $150/month. By law, the coverage provided by both companies must be exactly the same,
despite the wide range of costs. In Texas,
I am only guaranteed to be able to obtain a supplement plan A. when I look at
the Medicare web site, I can find at least 20 companies willing to sell a plan A
to me, but only 2 say they would sell me a plan D policy, and they are such
small players that they don't even have web sites! Looking in Indiana, I only
see one company offering a plan A supplement for under 65 (Anthem), and only one
willing to sell a plan B (Bankers Fidelity). There were none selling any other
supplement policies to people under 65. That would imply to me that, with no
competition for either company, prices will be high. It may be worth it though.
Here is my take on what they provide:
Plan A supplement
–
covers the Part A co-insurance (not
the deductible, see above Part A discussion), and the Part B
co-insurance. Part A deductible is $952 for each hospital stay, but doesn't
reset until you've been out for 60 days, so it is physically impossible to incur
more than 6 of these per year. Plan A supplement also adds 365 additional
lifetime reserve days. The Part B co-insurance is the 20% that Medicare doesn't
cover for outpatient things like doctors' visits, outpatient surgery, and DME.
However, there is a comment, in the home health services section,
that says you pay 20% for DME, so I am not sure whether ventilator, cough
assist, etc. would fall in this category or not.
Plan B supplement
–
the only thing the Plan B
supplement adds is coverage for the Part A deductible (that $952 payment for
each hospital stay). Everything else under Plan A supplement is the same under
Plan B.I know that during your
initial enrollment period, they are not allowed to "rate" or reject you based on
pre-existing conditions (your ALS, for example). I don't know if they are
allowed to use underwriting (underwriting: using current or past medical
conditions to charge higher rates or reject applicants) if you're
outside your initial enrollment period. I may be finding out soon, I'll let you
know.
Medicare Select
– really a misnomer, because it applies only to the supplement policies
above, it provides the same coverage as the supplement plan it refers to (i.e.
Medicare Plan A Supplement Select), but only if you use their doctors and
facilities. Kind of like a Medicare HMO. A moot point, because the
Medicare site doesn't list any that will sell a select policy if you're under
65.
Medicare Advantage
–
you didn't mention these, but I'm
sure you've heard of them. Around here we see ads for these 40 times a day,
mostly during business hours. These plans completely replace Medicare and
supplement plans. If you choose to use a Medicare Advantage plan, you
will be unenrolled in Medicare! Every Medicare Advantage plan has
different terms and conditions. It's just like shopping for any other health
insurance. I don't know if any underwriting is involved, but it was never
mentioned during my investigation of the subject. If you decide to go this way
(I decided not to), there is one more thing to know: there are two kinds of
Medicare Advantage programs. Those that cover prescriptions and those that
don't. Consistent with the idea that you are out of the Medicare system if you
enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan, if you choose a Medicare Advantage
plan that does not cover prescriptions, you will not be allowed to join a
prescription only drug plan, and you will not be able to get prescription
coverage!
Medicaid – is a state-run program, primarily intended
for low-income patients. There are generally both income and asset limitations
for qualifying. States set their own limits, so they are different everywhere. I
have found anecdotal evidence that Indiana has their limits set to $1273/ month
in income, and $2000 in total assets (excluding certain items like house, 1 car,
etc. for a still living spouse). My SSDI payment is more than that, so I have
not pursued it. There are ways to get within these limits, but I am not familiar
with them. I would recommend that you consult an attorney that specializes in
elder care law for additional information if you're thinking of going this
route.
Risk pool
–
I don't know if Indiana has this concept,
but in Texas we have a Risk pool for individuals that are unable to get health
insurance otherwise. An ALS diagnosis automatically qualifies me for the pool.
There is no underwriting, but they are required to charge twice the going rate
for the opportunity to be in the risk pool. This policy (again, this is my interpretation
of how it works in Texas, Indiana may be
different, or may not even have a Risk pool) pays as secondary to
Medicare.See the discussion below for primary vs. secondary. Another thing to think about is respiratory therapy. Medicare does
not
cover respiratory therapy visits. The Risk pool does. That hasn't been
enough, in my case, to justify going this route yet. One more hitch, I cannot
join the Risk pool as long as I am eligible for COBRA, even
if I don't take it.
Primary vs. secondary
–
this is an issue when a patient
is covered by 2 different insurance policies, and is called coordination of
benefits, or COB. This can be caused by numerous things, like the Risk pool
example above, or group coverage from a spouse's employer. The way COB works is
that one policy gets the claim first, and forwards it to the secondary after
paying their portion. The secondary then processes the remainder of the claim
according to their policy. There are 2 ways I have heard this works. The more
favorable way, which is what I've experienced, the primary pays 80%, then the
secondary pays the rest, up to 80%. It's strange to think about, so here is an
example:My respiratory company
charges $590/ month for my cough assist machine. Medicare gets the claim, and
allows $400 (all these figures are hypothetical). My provider accepts
assignment, so they are happy with $400. Medicare then pays 80% of it, or $320.Now they pass the claim to my secondary. My provider is out of network for them,
so they would normally only pay 70%, or $280. But Medicare already paid $320, so
the secondary pays $80, and counts themselves lucky, because they paid $200 less
than what they are contractually obligated to pay.Obviously this is
advantageous to me, as I end up paying nothing. The other way that I have heard,
but not experienced, works like this:Same scenario as before,
company bills $590, Medicare allows $400, and pays $320. But now the secondary
gets it. They look at it and say "we would have paid $280 for this service.
Medicare has paid $320, so we don't have to pay anything."I'm not nearly as happy,
because I'm stuck with the $80 remainder, and am paying premiums for a policy
that never seems to pay out. Again, I have not experienced this happening, but
others on this board have reported it. How do companies decide which is primary?
In my case, Medicare became primary because I wasn't being paid, thus no FICA
taxes were being paid. If my coverage had been through my wife's employer, and
she was still having FICA withheld, Medicare would be secondary. Others have
said it has more to do with the number of employees being greater or less than
100, but I'm more inclined to believe mine, since I heard it from the COB desks
at both plans.
Medicare capped item
-
One more thing that you may want
to know about, especially if you're thinking about buying your equipment
supplier out, is the idea of Medicare capped items. Many of the things we use
are actually rented by Medicare. After 10 months of renting the equipment you
are given a choice to buy it or keep renting it. If you choose to buy it,
Medicare will pay for 2 more months (total of 12 months). Title to the equipment
goes to you, and no more payments are due, but you are responsible for upkeep.
If you choose to continue to rent, Medicare will continue to pay for 5 more
months (total of 15 months). Title to the equipment remains with the equipment
supplier, no more payments are due, and the supplier is responsible for upkeep.Now to the answer that
you didn't want, but I'm sure you knew was coming. No one can make the decision
for you. It is highly dependent on your financial position and your risk
tolerance. I would strongly recommend that you talk to a specialist in elder
care law before making a final decision.I will tell you what my
decision was. The gentleman that was here specifically to
sell me a Medicare Advantage
plan, told me to stay away from them because they weren't very good with DME
extensive conditions, of which ALS is certainly one. So I have decided that,
when they kick me off COBRA, I am going to immediately apply for a Medicare Part
D plan and a Plan A supplement. Good luck with your research. If you have any
other questions, feel free to ask. Just be forewarned: you may get another tome
like this one!
MORE ON MEDICARE PART DPRESCRIPTION COVERAGE
By Andy
Let me try to summarize
it for you.
Each state has several companies that offer Medicare Part D
coverage. each of these companies offers several plans, with different premiums,
different deductibles, and different coverage. All this adds up to an
overwhelming amount of information. In Texas I had 48 different plans that I
could choose from.
Every prescription drug
plan has a formulary, which lists the drugs they will cover, and the (up to 4)
different prices that they will charge for each drug. There are 4 different
levels of support included in each plan:
DeductibleThe
first $250 dollars of drug expenses are paid for out of pocket at full price.
Some plans have no deductible, and start coverage at the next level.
SupportAfter the
deductible is met, drugs can be obtained for either 25% or a fixed co-payment.
Each formulary uses a different base price for each drug, though formularies
within the same plan family tend to use the same price structure (Humana's
prescription drug only plans uses the same prices as the Humana Medicare
Advantage plans with drug coverage). Once you reach $2250 in total drug costs
(what you pay plus what the plan pays), you move to the next level Donut hole.
This is the part that is most confusing. Between the time that you reach $2250
in total drug costs and when you reach $3600 in out of pocket expenses, you pay
100% of the drug prices. Did you get that? That means that, between $2250 in
total drug costs and $5100 in total drug costs you pay 100% of your prescription
costs. Still with me? Ok, one more
thing.After you've paid $750 for your prescriptions
($250 deductible plus 25% of the next $2000), and before you've paid $3600 in
out of pocket expenses, you pay full price for all your medication. That's all
the ways I can think of to explain it.
Catastrophic coverageOnce you exceed the threshold of the donut hole, you get catastrophic
coverage, under which you pay the greater of $5 ($2 for generics) or 5% of the
full price.
For complete
information on all aspects of Medicare benefits, always go to
http://www.medicare.gov/
CHAPTER 6
PARTICIPATINGIN CLINICAL
TRIALS
By Randy Roberts
Clinical trials
are
formal tests of safety and efficacy of new drugs or procedures. There are three
phases in trials:
1) Safety- to assess if
the new compound can be tolerated without major side effects.
2) Safety and efficacy-involving more subjects, including a placebo group (no medication) or so called
“control” group;
3) Efficacy-
The final
phase-to determine efficacy using a much larger sample size and held at multiple
sites around the country, always uses a placebo group.
All drugs used in the
trials are free of charge. It is important to consider participating in a trial
at an early point in your illness because the studies require subjects to meet
certain criteria, e.g., FVC > 60 or 70 or the ability to walk unaided, and one
never knows how fast one will progress.PALS have to weigh potential benefits
against inconvenience, as the trial location may be many miles from home. And
PALS who volunteer are helping in the quest for a cure. Discuss the open trials
with a neurologist, to help guide your decision. Below is a current list of
trials that are recruiting patients, as of 11/06. Check back at the website
below monthly to get updates.The ALSA and MDA sites also keep updated lists of
trials, so check these, too.

Click the Logo above to see the ClinicalTrials.govweb site.
Chapter 7
ADVOCACY
Over the course of the
illness, many PALS become interested in advocating. Some become so engrossed
that it becomes a meaningful and satisfying focus of their lives. The following
articles provide you with comprehensive information on advocacy and the tools to
get involved.
Advocacy!
By Catherine Wolf
Catherine Wolf was
diagnosed with ALS in September, 1997 at age 50. Cathy had a tracheostomy in
2001 and is now completely ventilator dependent. She faces ALS with optimism, a
fiercely independent nature, and an occasional tear. Before ALS, she worked for
IBM, and was an avid runner and dancer. She has two adult daughters and is the
enthusiastic grandmother of one grandson. Cathy lives with her husband Joel in
Katonah, NY.
Introduction
What is advocacy? The
dictionary defines advocacy as “active support for a cause.“ Most people feel
better when they are doing something. We feel that our lives have
purpose. Although there is not yet a cure for ALS, PALS typically feel good when
they are involved in advocacy. As a newly diagnosed PALS, you have the physical
capability to do more than your less recently diagnosed fellow PALS. So get
involved! This chapter describes some of the ways you can become involved in
advocacy.
What are your skills
and interests?
When contemplating how to
get involved, assess your skills. Were you a bookkeeper? Perhaps you can
volunteer to keep the books for an ALS fund raiser, or help a fellow PALS
organize his/her finances. Were you a nurse? Now is the time to educate yourself
about ALS so you can explain the often mystifying jargon doctors sometimes use
about ALS. In my case, I had spent many years as a usability expert in software
design. I made sure when I was still working that the software I worked on was
usable by people with motor disabilities. And when I encountered programs made
by my company that were difficult for me to use, I suggested ways to improve
them. Perhaps most important, I made suggestions for improving the assistive
technology I used. Thus, I used my work skills to advocate for all PALS. Altogether your body will
lose physical function, there is no limit to what your mind can do, especially
when armed with a computer. Kyle Hahn, a musician, started the ALS March of
Faces, an awareness and advocacy organization. Will Hubben compiled and
distributed ALS research. David Jayne, stricken with ALS at 27, started
living-with-ALS and started a group to agitate for change in the Medicare laws
regarding homebound people. You may be thinking, “I don’t have the personality
for a major undertaking.“ Advocacy
takes many forms, large and small. For example, I shared what I learned from my
successful insurance battle with the MDA ALS News magazine.
Sometimes ALS can wake up
talents you didn’t know you had. In my case, it was poetry. I started writing
poetry about my reaction to ALS, as well as political poetry and sending it to
friends. One friend with connections finagled an article about me, ALS, and my
political poetry in my county’s section of the New York Times. That article
described ALS, and I’m sure helped raise awareness of ALS. Another article in
Neurology Now included some of my ALS poetry. The doctor who wrote it said my
poems gave her a new appreciation of the patient’s perspective. While I can’t
speak for all PALS, I know that there are many who share my optimistic
perspective. Since the magazine is distributed to every neurology office, I hope
my upbeat poems will be helpful to people afflicted with neurological diseases.
I use these examples from my life, not to toot my own horn, but because I know
them and to show one little person can make a difference.
Advocating for
yourself
Sooner or later, you will
find yourself in need of services your insurance company denies. Don’t take no
for an answer! Most insurance companies know that many people will not appeal a
denied claim. Have your doctor write a letter of medical necessity that explains
why you need the service. Notes from other health professionals can also help.
Demand that your insurance company gives you a letter of explanation for the
decision, not a cryptic code. Read your policy. Consult the social worker at
your ALS center, or if the stakes are high, hire a lawyer. MDA, ALSA, or the
local bar association can recommend one. Put everything in writing and send it
return receipt requested so you have a paper trail. If you speak to anyone from
your insurance company, get their names and make notes and date the
conversation. You’re not allowed to record the conversation without permission
from the other party. The insurance company is usually your enemy, but sometimes
you can sweet talk someone into giving you more information. I don’t know much about
Medicare or Medicaid.I assume that the same principles apply to these. There are, of course,
other reasons than insurance for which you might need to advocate for yourself.
Sometimes well-meaning caregivers or family members want to make decisions for
you. Your mind still works, and you should have as much control over decisions
affecting your care as you desire.
Advocating for a
fellow PALS
You can put your skills,
experience and knowledge to work to help a fellow PALS. Over the years, I have
helped several PALS, mostly by email. I have also written about what I have
learned in my ALS center’s newsletter. Every time you post something in
living-with-ALS you are making a fellow PALS’ life easier. As a newly diagnosed
PALS, you may have the energy and voice to help a more advanced PALS. For
example, you might organize a Share the Care group for someone in your local
support group.
Cause advocacy
Advocating for a specific
cause can be as easy as forwarding email you receive from a group supporting
that cause to everyone you know. For example, before the Senate vote on the stem
cell research bill in July 2006, I forwarded the United Spinal Association’s
email urging me to contact my senators to vote yes to family and friends. And I
emailed my senators. Sometimes you have to
write your own cause letter. The trick is to make it easy for your friends to
take action. This may include providing talking points, phone numbers or email
addresses. In June 2005 after the House of Representatives passed the stem cell
research bill, I emailed friends to put pressure on those representatives who
voted against it to change their minds. Here is an excerpt from my email.
Thank you for your help in
passing the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act. The House of Representatives
passed the bill 238-194, with 14 Democrats and 180 Republicans voting against
it. The Senate is expected to pass a similar bill soon. The sponsor of the
Senate bill, Republican Arlen Specter, says he has enough votes to override a
presidential veto. Bush said he will veto it when the bill reaches his desk. He
is obviously out of tune with most Americans, since a recent poll indicated only
28% of the people oppose embryonic stem cell research for therapeutic purposes.
Bush has little to lose by vetoing this bill because he is a second term
president. But the Representatives will have to defend their votes on this issue
in the 2006 elections. It takes a two-thirds majority to override a presidential
veto. Therefore, we should focus our efforts on the representatives who voted
against this bill or who did not vote. To see how your representative and others
voted go to
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/25/politics/25stem_rollcall.html
For convenience, I am including
the text of this article at the end of this email. . if you know people in
states with a large percentage of no votes, please consider forwarding this to
them.
To find out who your
representative (or any representative) is and how to contact him/her go to
http://www.house.gov/writerep/
[roll call vote by state
included]
Whether or not you agree with
me on stem cell research, the principles of cause advocacy are the same.
-
Be specific about
what you want your audience to do.
-
Provide
information on the topic, perhaps including talking points.
-
Provide contact
information for the people you want them to contact, or an easy way of getting
the information.
Organization advocacy
There are many groups that
raise money for ALS research or services, or raise awareness of ALS. These
include, but are not limited to, Muscular Dystrophy Association (MDA), ALS
Association (ALSA), ALS Therapy Development Foundation (ALS-TDF), Ride for Life,
ALS March of Faces, United Spinal Association, and your local ALS center. The
first two organizations have many local chapters which may hold fund raising
events such as walks, bike rides, dinners and golf outings. Some other
organizations, such as the Stamford, CT Fire Department, raise money for one of
the organizations in the first list. If you want to get involved, there are many
organizations and activities. If you’re not on the mailing list or email list
for these organizations, they will welcome your participation.
Your involvement can be as
simple as wearing a blue and white pin striped ribbon, to participating in an
event, being on the organizing committee for an event, or organizing your own
event. Fund raising is a good way to involve family, friends, colleagues and
your employer who often want to do something for you, but don’t know what. Time
for a personal story. I have always been reluctant to ask friends for
contributions. My cousin has been doing the ALSA bike ride in Boston along with
her husband and several co-workers who don’t even know me for several years.
This year they had only raised $350 towards their goal of $750. She asked me to
contact my friends for help. I figured if she could ask people who don’t know me
to ride and contribute, I could certainly ask my friends. The response was
phenomenal. We raised over $2000!
Working on the organizing
committee of a major organization, such as MDA, for a fund raising or an
awareness event has the benefit that the organization provides most of the
structure. When I worked on the organizing committee of a local MDA fund raiser,
they provided the solicitation letter, which I personalized.
If you want to organize your
own event, it is wise to recruit family and friends to help. Such events always
take more effort than anticipated. Alternatively, if you know someone who wants
to organize an event, you can let her/him be in the driver’s seat and help as
you can. Several years ago, one of my daughters organized a folk music concert
to benefit ALS-TDF and raised about $5000. ALS-TDF has family funds which are a
good way to honor a PALS and track your fund raising for the organization.
Try to attend the event, if possible. It helps to put a face on ALSWhatever form your
organizational advocacy takes, remember it is much easier to get businesses to
donate goods and services than money. It is not only a donation. It’s free
advertising.
Your life as a model
for advocacy
Finally, your advocacy
activities can inspire people with and without ALS to become advocates. Thus,
your own advocacy has a multiplier effect.
Conclusion
This chapter has
described some of the ways you can put your skills and experience to work to
become an advocate for PALS, including yourself. Advocacy can take as much or
little of your time and effort as you desire. The types of advocacy described
here are:
- Advocating for
yourself
- Advocating for a
fellow PALS
- Cause advocacy
- Organization
advocacy
- Your life as a model
for advocacy
EIGHT RULES TO GET WHAT YOUNEED
By Danny Dandignac
Danny
was Dx'd 12/2000. He retired from being a paramedic in 12/2004 after 23 years.
Currently he spends his time co-hosting the MDAchats
that are held 4 days a week and continuing the Will Hubben ResearchDigest hosted on the ALSTDF website. He is married with 2 children, ages 12 and
15. He has brought our attention to a very useful article.Bob’s friend Jason
doesn’t have ALS, but he faced a problem all too familiar to many who do: an
insurance company ruled that equipment he needed was “not medically necessary.”
Sound familiar?Jason might have started
fighting back by talking to his doctor first. His doctor may be as disagreeable
and rushed as Jason pictures him. Moreover, his doctor may work for the very HMO
that turned him down. But his doctor has a professional stake in preserving
Jason’s shoulders—and in seeing that his prescriptions are filled as written.When I picked up the
phone, Jason sounded desperate. Jason has cerebral palsy and has always walked
by leaning heavily on two canes. As a result of decades of wear and tear, he
developed severe arthritis and rotator-cuff tears in both shoulders. Most days
it’s hard for him to cross the room because of excruciating pain.His doctor told him the
pain and muscle tears were going to get worse—that rotator-cuff and
shoulder-replacement surgeries were on the horizon—unless he got a power
wheelchair. Although Jason’s doctor had sent the proper paperwork to his
insurance company, a Medicare HMO, the wheelchair was denied because it was “not
medically necessary.”“Not medically
necessary?” Jason screeched into the phone. “When will it be medically
necessary? When I can’t walk at all?”Sadly, the answer is
yes. But I’m getting ahead of the story. Because Jason’s speech is hard to
understand, he asked me to call the insurance company. In the process I
discovered that there are Eight Simple Rules for getting anything you need from
anyone.
Rule #1: Get Name,
Rank, and Phone Number
I called Jason’s
insurance company. After spending a turtle’s lifetime on hold, I was connected
to a customer representative. I tried to explain my friend’s circumstance, but
she said she couldn’t talk to me because I wasn’t “the insured” and hung up.I was massively ticked!
Back on the phone, and after another turtle’s lifetime, I was connected to a
different representative. This time I said that I was Jason and wrote down her
name, phone number, and title. All she did was repeat what Jason knew—that the
wheelchair was denied because it was not medically necessary. With an edge in my
voice I asked who made that decision. She told me that she was not allowed to
give out that information. I asked who could. She said that I would have to
speak to her supervisor, Ms. Lemon, and that she would transfer me. Before she
did, I got Ms. Lemon’s phone number—and good thing! I wasn’t transferred; I was
disconnected.
Rule #2: First Do
Your Homework
Since it was 5:00 p.m.,
I decided to do some research first and call Ms. Lemon the next day. On the
Internet I found the Medicare regulation for power-wheelchair medical necessity.It turns out that a
power chair is considered medically necessary only if you’re “bed or chair
confined,” not Jason’s situation—yet. I then got the name and phone number of
the president of Jason’s insurance company and went to the Web sites for the
Department of Health and the Insurance Commission in Jason’s state to find out
what process insurance companies must follow if they deny medical equipment. I
also decided I would keep dated notes of my phone conversations and take exact
quotes.
Rule #3: An Ally Is
Better Than an Adversary
At 9:01 the next morning
I called Ms. Lemon. Instead of screaming as I wanted to, I decided to take a
different tack: I started by saying, “Ms. Lemon, you are the only one who can
help me.” I told her that two of her representatives had hung up on me (hoping a
little guilt would soften her up) and explained the situation. She apologized. I
told her I needed to know who had denied the power chair. Pleasant as you
please, she volunteered that she had denied the chair. Aha! I had her! Victory
was mine. My homework had uncovered that this state’s law permits only a
physician to deny medical equipment.When I told her this,
she stammered and said she was sure that one of the medical directors, a
physician, had ultimately signed her denial. When I asked for the medical
director’s name and phone number, she said she was not allowed to give out that
information. However, she said she’d transfer me and (you know what’s coming) I
was disconnected.
Rule #4: Go Right
to the Top!
It was clear I was
getting nowhere talking to the hired help. So my next call was to the president
of the insurance company—let’s call him “Robert Bucks”. Of course I didn’t get
Mr. Bucks on the phone; I got one of his personal assistants. Starting again
with “You are the only one who can help me,” I quickly explained the hang-ups,
the denial by a clerical worker, and the refusal to let me talk to the medical
director.The assistant sounded
both shocked and concerned. He apologized and confirmed that indeed only a
medical director can deny a power chair and gave me the name and number of the
medical director assigned to the case.
Rule #5: Be a Name
Dropper
I immediately called the
medical director’s office and got his secretary. I asked to speak to the doctor
and was told that “insureds” were not allowed to speak to medical directors and
how had I gotten the number? I said that I had just spoken to “Bob” Bucks, and
was told to call the doctor directly. Implying that “my buddy Bob” told me to
call got me through to the medical director in a flash.The doctor explained
that he had indeed signed the denial based on the Medicare regulation that
required someone to have “severe weakness” in the arms, be unable to push a
manual chair, and be “bed or chair confined” before a power chair could be
approved.Still speaking as Jason,
I told him that my arms might not yet be severely weak, but that severe shoulder
pain prevented me from pushing a manual chair and that shoulder degeneration
would soon make me bed- or chair-confined if I kept on as I was. With the
Medicare regulation in front of me, I then quoted another paragraph which said
that “a patient who uses a power wheelchair is usually totally non-ambulatory.”
I suggested that the word “usually” gave him some leeway, since it means not
everyone who gets a power chair is totally unable to walk.To my amazement the
doctor listened! He agreed the shoulders would just get worse and that I would
eventually be chair or bed confined. “Tell your doctor to write a new
prescription and an appeal letter explaining that your shoulders are falling
apart, that you can’t push a manual wheelchair and soon won’t be able to walk,”
he said. “I can argue that it would be better to give you the power chair sooner
rather than later and save your shoulders.”
Rule #6: Tell,
Don’t Ask
Ecstatic, I called
Jason. I explained that his doctor only had to send a prescription, write a
letter, and the power wheelchair was his. But Jason hemmed and hawed. He said
his doctor was very busy and hadn’t liked filling out the insurance forms for
the power chair in the first place. I told Jason he needed to advocate for
himself. I told him he needed not to ask but to tell his doctor—quietly but
firmly—that he “was the only person who could help” and to write that letter.
Indeed, Jason’s doctor was not happy, but write a letter he did.Within two weeks the
power wheelchair was approved. I was king of the world ... until Jason called me
a month later.
Rule #7: Call in
the Marines!
Jason told me that he
was greeted one morning by a truck driver with a huge box. Inside was the
promised power chair. Jason’s excitement gave way to confusion and anger when he
discovered the wheelchair was twice as wide as he was. I asked him how this
could have happened when he had been fitted for the chair. Jason told me the
delivery was a total surprise because he had never been fitted.I immediately called the
medical director to find out what had gone wrong. The doctor coolly explained
that the insurance company provides only one type of power wheelchair from only
one manufacturer. When I told him the chair had never been fitted and was too
wide, the doctor’s response was as simple as it was final: “We had a doctor’s
prescription.” Click.The doctor’s answer was
not only ridiculous, it smelled way bad. Why would an insurance company provide
only one type of power wheelchair that was drop-shipped from another state
without being fitted?I called Jason’s state
insurance commissioner and was told that insurance companies cannot provide only
one brand of wheelchair, that wheelchairs are indeed custom items that must be
fitted. I was referred to the state department of health’s office responsible
for overseeing HMOs. And I heard the same thing. For good measure I called the
state attorney general’s office. What the insurance company was doing smelled
bad to everybody. And, since this was a Medicare issue, I called Jason’s
congressman too.Turned out that the
insurance company and the wheelchair manufacturer were under federal
investigation for—guess what?—a kickback scheme involving payoffs by the
wheelchair maker to the insurance firm.I once again called my
buddy the medical director. I told him about all the offices I had just called
and—my voice calm and even—explained that everyone believed that his insurance
company was involved in a kickback scheme with the wheelchair manufacturer that
broke bushels of state and federal laws. I told him that it wasn’t my idea to
testify against him in court or to speak at a television press conference, but
that I’d do what the attorney general asked if it would get me a usable power
chair.
Rule #8: One White
Lie May Be Worth a Thousand Truths
Of course, no one I
talked to had mentioned testifying in court or a TV press conference. But the
medical director didn’t know that, and there was no way that he was going to
find out. What was he going to do, call the attorney general and ask if he was
going to be indicted? Which is why I heard the doctor’s voice raise an octave.
“No, no, no! “he said. “You must have misunderstood me.”He quickly explained
that the brand of wheelchair that was shipped was the company’s first choice,
not the only choice, and that of course every patient’s wheelchair should be
individually fitted. He told me that the insurance company would arrange for the
chair to be returned, that a local vendor would be in contact, and that any
brand of power chair that met my needs would be provided.True to his word, within
a week the offending wheelchair had been removed and Jason was fitted for a
chair that met his needs. Jason and his shoulders are now happily rolling along.God
Bless Alexander Graham BellSince helping Jason, I
have told others about “The Eight Simple Rules” and how they have proved helpful
in dealing with everything from refusals by employers to provide reasonable
accommodations under the ADA to reversing denials for Social Security disability
benefits.The phone can be a
powerful weapon. Don’t be afraid to call anyone and everyone who could possibly
help you. State officials, congresspersons, and senators. Elected officials love
to help their constituents (read: voters).Sometimes, however, the
pen can be mightier than the phone. You can file official complaints under the
ADA, state civil rights and consumer laws with your state’s insurance
commissioner and with the attorney general. Ultimately, you may need a lawyer
specializing in disability or consumer issues if it’s time to lock and load and
take the bums to court.But if you follow “The
Eight Simple Rules”, you may get what you need without paperwork or lawsuits by
doing your homework, being pleasant but assertive, using your wits, and using
Alexander Graham Bell’s marvelous invention.
TIPS AND INFORMATION ON ADVOCACY
By David Abell
David was
diagnosed with ALS in June 1996. He was 29 and serving in the US Navy when he
was diagnosed. He has adapted to being paralyzed, ventilator dependent, fed
through a feeding tube. His attitude is “Iwill never give up.”He rarely
feels sad and has discovered numerous, meaningful ways to enrich his life.Advocacy & Awareness are important in getting funding for research andcare for ALS. Some great advocates groups for ALS areThe March of Faces
http://march-of-faces.org/
Project ALS
http://projectals.org/
Ride For Life
http://www.rideforlife.com/
There are many others but
these are my favorites.
It is up to all of us to raise awareness if possible. When friendsask if there is anything they can do, ask them to write a letter totheir Congressperson & Senators. (see below) Check the www.ALSA.orgwww.MDA.org or NORD
http://www.rarediseases.org/
for sample lettersthat you can modify for personal info. If you believe in stem cellresearch www.stemcellaction.org and
http://www.curesnow.org/ havepetitions to sign and sample letters.
Write to your congressperson. It's hard to represent you properly ifthe congressperson isn't aware of your feelings.
Select your state or territory and enter your ZIP code. You'll be givena form that will be sent directly to your representative.
If you want to contact your senator, go here:
http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm
And to contact members of the House, go here:
http://www.house.gov/writerep/
This website has tips on How to write your congressperson.
http://www.protest.net/activists_handbook/write.html
Writing a real letter or fax will not get ignored as easily as Emailbut it takes a long time for a response especially since the anthraxidiot. I do both sometimes.Anyway, there are some ideas. We can make a difference.
Thoughts on Advocacy
By Chuck Hummer
Chuck retiredas a
senior executive with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in Washington, D.C., in
1989, culminating a thirtyyear career as a government worker.He was diagnosed
withALS in October 2004, after a three yearjourney to determine why he was
falling and experiencing slurred speech.He and his wife, Sandra, live in
Pinellas Park, Florida.Advocacy is defined as
the act of pleading or arguing in favor of something, such as a cause, idea, or
policy; active support.How does this apply to ALS?In the strictest sense,
advocacy is often limited to a type of lobbying, or seeking legislation to
provide for some service or rights.In the broadest sense, I take it to mean
speaking out and up to assure public awareness of the disease called ALS.Without this basic understanding of what ALS is, how it affects those who have
been diagnosed with ALS and the sorry fact that no one knows the cause or
causes, there are no real pharmaceutical therapies to treat the disease, and
there is no cure.Unless and until we get
that message out to the broadest possible audience, including health care
workers, politicians and even our own families and friends, it seems futile to
think that we can plead or argue for any relief from the disease.In short,
education seems to be a first crucial step to advocating for those of us with
ALS.At first, this seems pretty elementary and an objective easily achieved.But if my case is typical, then it grossly underestimates the existing ignorance
about ALS or Lou Gehrig’s disease.I had heard of it, and in fact an uncle had
it and died from it.When I was diagnosed, I
suddenly learned a great deal about this disease and the gloomy prognosis for
those so afflicted.Once that sunk in, it inspired me and my wife to learn all
we could and to tell as many people as would listen that I had an incurable
terminal illness that would likely take my life in a short period of time.No
cure, no effective medicines, no confirmatory diagnostic test or tests, all of
this came as an incredible shock and led us to think, just what we can do to
learn to live with this disease and somehow stimulate the search for effective
therapies and a cure.That is when advocacy suddenly came into clear and
distinct focus for us.We had to help get the word out, the public educated and
the research community put on a fast track.It came as another shock to learn
that there is no national database of ALS patients.Without this crucial basis
on which to seek funds for therapies and a cure we were simply bouncing around
in a very dim room without much hope for an early resolution to the seemingly
endless ignorance that surrounded the disease that I now had, was dying from, my
body shutting down the use oflimbs,
speech, breathing.I was encouraged when ALSA made the National ALS Registry
one of its key legislative goals.And so it seems that the
first order of business is to educate using every avenue available, educate as
to the lack of a diagnostic test or tests, no effective therapies and certainly
no cure, nor the hope for one on the horizon.Because unless we make major
inroads on the ignorance about ALS, it seems any effort to inspire research, or
for legislation to fund increased research would be a whisper in the hurricane
of all the diseases for which cures and therapies are being sought.Now the sad fact is that
those of us with ALS don’t stay around long enough to build an effective voice
made up entirely of the afflicted.In the U.S. it is estimated that there are
no more than 30,000 people with ALS at any one time.Of those, more than likely
only a quarter or less than 10,000 are healthy enough or still have the ability
to do much more than try to deal with the rapid progression of the disease.That is not a large constituency by any means, and without any cure on the
horizon these numbers are not likely to change much.About as many die from the
disease as are diagnosed.Remember what advocacy
is, it is arguing or soliciting aid and if there are not sufficient numbers of
people with ALS to constitute an effective voice what avenues are open to us.I
think that the answer lies in those who care for us, those who are family,
friends, and acquaintances, colleagues in the work place or faith community.These are the groups that can be large enough to have sufficient voice and
volume to speak on our behalf.If one looks that those involved with the
national organizations that have grown to represent us, you will find that many
have had their lives touched by a loved one with ALS or a coworker, or friend.Thank God for that, because we PALS are a pretty anemic group if counted on our
own.Awareness, education,
appreciation, all of these must be our goal and those who we hope will advocate
for us.While we are healthy enough to speak on own behalf, we must do so, but
we must also enlarge the community around us to achieve a noise level that will
be heard when we ask for more research, for better patient care and services,
accessibility as our mobility spirals downward.We, the PALS, have to be at the
center of this effort because it is a life and death challenge for us.But we
must also grow the community around us through education, to become an effective
voice for us with enough depth and volume to make our needs heard in all the
places where action must be taken on our behalf if we are ever to realize our
hope for better therapies, therapies that will bring ALS into the community of
chronic but treatable illnesses and finally, one day, a cure.
How do we do this?I think that it requires a
multifaceted approach, but that approach needs some healthy but vocal PALS at
its center. Awareness events such as the ALSA Walk to Dfeet ALS, the Ride for
Life, Faces of Courage, and the many other public initiatives are an essential
part of this awareness effort. Seeking celebrity spokespersons, maximum
exposure and use of all aspects of the media are vital parts to this campaign.We need to use the national organizations that represent us to be our advocates
and wemust be our own advocates to
keep the rest of the advocates heading in the right direction with enough
passion and vigor to make a difference.I found that participating in the
annual ALSA Advocacy Day and Public Policy Conference has all sorts of good
results.It allows our advocates to network and in doing so become a
harmonized chorus, rather than a bunch of distinct weak voices each singing
in isolation.It also brought the face of ALS and our needs to our
legislators.Some states have set up similar events to interface with
their state legislators. It remains that the true strength comes from those
who care for us.Their lives have been touched on a very personal
level, and they willround to keep advocating on behalf long after we have gone.If their voices
become strong enough, then maybe we will see therapies come along that will
extend the lives of PALS significantly and we can break above that 30,000
ceiling that has plagued us for so long.Simply stated, each of us
has to be our own advocates arguing on our own behalf, but we need to be active
in growing and extending the advocacy communities made up of our family, friends
and coworkers, the researchers and service organization volunteers and staffs
that work for us.It isn’t going to work if we shrink into our own lonely
little space and do not reach out to others and continuously make that group of
others larger and larger, better organized and educated, to carry the message of
awareness and education that will make advocacy work for better times for all
PALS.
A Letter to Advocate for
Greater Research for ALS
By Randy Roberts
I wrote
this letter some time ago to draw attention to the fact that ALS
isunder-funded compared to other diseases. It has been
modified from the original.Dear Senator/Congressman,I am writing this letter
to bring to your attention to the fact that ALS (Lou Gehrig’s Disease), an
illness that receives far too little publicity in view of its devastating impact
on the lives of so many Americans, is under-funded by NIH (FY 05) when compared
to other diseases and to ask for your help. But first, a few words about this
disease. ALS attacks the motor neurons (nerves) that send commands and nourish
muscles. As the neurons die, the muscles that they support weaken and atrophy.
Although the disease can progress in different ways, a typical scenario is for a
limb to weaken first, and then spread to other limbs, rendering the body
paralyzed. Over time it progresses to muscles controlling speech, swallowing and
finally breathing itself.While ALS ravages the
body, it generally leaves the mind intact, so patients are fully aware of what
is happening to them. One patient who wrote about his experience with ALS said
"With keen mind and open eyes We watch ourselves die “.
In a testimony to the human spirit, many ALS patients manage to rise above
their suffering and continue to find meaning in their lives up to the end. ALS
is not an inherited disease: (95%) of all cases do not have a family history of
ALS. And it is not nearly so rare as people think, i.e., it is diagnosed about
2/3 the frequency ofMS (Multiple Sclerosis), a much more recognized illness.
It can strike at any age from the 20’s thru the 70’s (Lou Gehrig himself was
diagnosed at age 36) but tends to peak in late middle age. There is no
effective therapeutic agent against ALS and no understanding of causation.
Nobody is safe from this killer.MS seems to offer a
reasonable standard of comparison as it has about the roughly similar incidence
as ALS (10,000 new cases per year for MS vs. 6000-7000 for ALS). There are
approximately 400,000 people in theUS living with MS vs. about 30,000 with
ALS. Why the difference in prevalence if the diseases have a somewhat similar
incidence rate? The major factor is lethality. MS patients live a normal life
span while, as mentioned earlier, while ALS patients have a much shorter life
span. If ALS were not such an effective killer, its prevalence rate would
obviously be much higher.It seems reasonable that the two diseases should
have nearly equal public funding, since they both occur with the similar
frequency, but this is not the case.NIH budgets $110 million on MS research
but $41 m on ALS.It is immoral to base funding on prevalence in the context of
similar incidence rates, thereby penalizing ALS patients for the lethality of
their diseaseThe next disease for
comparison is Huntington’s disease, another disorder caused by degeneration of
brain cells, i.e. neurons, in certain areas of the brain. This degeneration
causes uncontrolled movements,loss of
intellectual faculties, and emotional disturbance. HD is a fully inherited
disease, passed from parent to child through a mutation in a certain gene. Its
incidence and prevalence rate are much lower than ALS and patients usually live
10-25 years after diagnosis. Yet, this disease has an NIH budget of $48m vs. $41
m for ALS.For the, 3rd and final
comparison, I will move from diseases involving neuron damage to one caused by a
viral infection, HIV/AIDS. This illness has a large incidence (85,000) and
prevalence (1,100,000) but thanks to advances in treatment, mortality has been
significantly reduced. The number of patients who die from this disease each
year is only about a bit more than twice the number of ALS deaths, yet HIV/AIDS
has a research budget of nearly $3b vs. $41m for ALS.CONCLUSION I: Given
itsincidence rates and high lethality, ALS is woefully under-funded compared
to other diseasesand this may explain, at least inpart, why so little has
been learned about this disease since Lou Gehrig’s death 65 years ago and why
there have been no significant advances in treatment. It does not get the
recognition it deserves because its high lethality severely limits the number of
Americans who are living with the disease at any one point in time.
RECOMMENDATION I:The NIH budget for ALS research should be immediately increased to $110m or roughly
the same amount as MS.A second issue I wish to
address is the fact that the low prevalence rate of ALS, due to its high
lethality, does not provide any incentive for major pharmaceutical companies to
search for a cure.The only drug for ALS, Rilutek, about 15 years old now,
extends life only 2-3 months, is used by many patients at high cost, yet the
maker of the drug, Aventis, claims that it loses substantial money on Rilutek.
MS, in comparison, with its 400,000 prevalence in the US alone, presents
significant incentive for drug companies to invest in research. In fact, there
are 5 meds that have proven very beneficial and sales are big. Avonex, for
example, had close to $1b in sales in the last year. Another drug, Copaxone, may
have the greatest potential to alter the course of MS and sales, once the issue
of side effects is resolved, should be huge. If we accept the view that it costs
the companies $800 m over 10 years to develop and bring to market a successful
drug, then about $4 billionhas been spent to produce thesedisease
mitigatingmedications, or $400 m per year, not including current research.The FDA offers an orphan
disease program to provide incentives to companies to invest in research of
diseases having a prevalence of fewer than 200,000. The program provides tax
incentives and other advantages for only small grants; unfortunately the
incentives offered are too small to interest large companies with all their
research potential.
Conclusion II:Because
of ALS’s high lethality, prevalence will always be low.As a consequence, big
pharma will not have the incentive to invest in ALS research and the high tech
power of drug companies won’t be harnessed to find new therapeutic agents in the
fight against ALS.
Recommendation II:Federal health agencies must provide the incentive to big pharma to invest in
ALS research.The FDA Orphan Disease Program must be substantially increased to
accomplish this.$80m per year in incentives must be allotted to get major
companies interested in working on this research.Funding could include a
combination of grants, tax credits and exclusive marketing rights, etc.The
grants could be reduced as companies come closer to marketing the new agents.
Under-funding of ALS will
not be righted without your active intervention. I am askingfor your help on behalf
of boththe 30,000+ Americans living with the disease today and the estimated
70,000 who will die every 10 years until a cure is found. ALS has been neglected
far too long.
Thank you for your
interest. We and our families are counting on you.
Randy RobertsPerson with ALS,
diagnosed 4/04
A FINAL WORD ON ADVOCACY
Our numbers are small,
our voices are too weak to be above the din, wecannot “act up” like the early
AIDS activists and we have no famous person to champion our cause.But we must
try to keep public awareness on ALS and help raise funds for research. This
chapter has shown you some ways. Use your energy and creativity to help us in
this fight.
CHAPTER 8
MATERIALS AND RESOURCES
AVAILABLE AT NO CHARGE
By Catherine Wolf
Introduction
Many organizations offer
free stuff, grants and/or services to people with ALS and their families. As a
newly diagnosed PALS, you’re probably overwhelmed by the challenges ahead. This
chapter puts in one place information about free stuff, grants and services that
can make your life easier and save you money. The conditions that apply, if any,
and how to contact the organization are included here. There may be other
organizations offering services to PALS. These are the ones we know about.
Muscular Dystrophy
Association (MDA)MDA services are
administered by the local offices. To find your local office, go to
http://www.mdausa.org/.
To receive services, you must register with the
local office, but registration is free.
Financial benefits.
These apply after all insurance has
been paid.
-
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of wheelchairs or leg braces every five years. This benefit may be used
for wheelchair upgrades.
-
Up to $500 annually for
wheelchair repairs.
-
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of augmentative communication devices. This is a one time benefit.
Other services and
free stuff
-
One physical, occupational, and
speech therapy evaluation per year
-
Annual flu shot
-
Transportation to MDA clinics
-
Loan closet containing items
such as wheelchairs, hoyer lifts, hospital beds, commodes, etc
-
Research updates, informative
publications (MDA ALS News Magazine, Quest), resources & referrals, web site
-
Support groups for
Pals, Caregivers and Family
ALS Association (ALSA)ALSA is organized
differently from MDA. Each local chapter decides what services to offer. To find
your local chapter, go to
Welcome - The ALS Association.To receive services, you must register with your local chapter, but
registration is free. I will use the services of the Greater New York
chapter as an example. But please contact your local chapter since services
and eligibility are sure to differ.
Loan of
augmentative communication devices. To qualify, you must have no
functional speech. Also, you must be in the process of applying for coverage
of such a device by your insurance, have no insurance coverage for such
devices, or have no insurance.Listening library.
Loan of books on CD or tape by mail to PALS who can no longer hold a book or
turn pages easily. Check your local library for loan of audio books. The
Library of Congress offers audio books by mail, -
www.loc.gov/nls. The New York chapter
lists a variety of nationally available sources of audio books. Go to
http://www.als-ny.org/ and click on Patient Services, then Patient and
Family Programs, then Listening Library. Loan closet
with similar items to MDA loan closet. To qualify, the equipment must be
recommended by a health professional and you must be in theprocess of applying for coverage of the equipment by your insurance,
have no insurance coverage for the equipment, or have no insurance.Transportation to
ALSA clinics and support groups. To be eligible, you must have no other
way of getting there.Home visits by
nurses, social workers and assistive technology specialists Support groups
for PALS, caregivers and family Your local chapter
can provide referrals and the national website has educational materials and
publications, see
Welcome - The ALS
Association and click Resources and Patient, Family, Caregivers
Ride for Life
Ride for Life is an
awareness and fund raising organization whose main event is a ride for PALS in
their wheelchairs in the New York area. Financial benefits
-
Respite care grants. Ride for
Life periodically offers a limited number of Care for Life grants of up to $1500
for the purpose of giving your caregiver a break. See
http://www.rideforlife.com/
-
Legal grants. A limited number
of grants of up to $750 are periodically offered for legal expenses such as
wills, dealing with insurance companies, and applying for disability benefits
under the Plan for Life program.
-
While not a direct benefit to
you, when you enter certain online stores from
http://www.rideforlife.com/, Ride for Life gets a percentage of the purchase
price.
Other services and
free stuff
-
Information, educational
materials on the web site
United Spinal
Association Membership in the United
Spinal Association is open to people with spinal cord injuries or diseases that
affect the spinal cord, including ALS. See the web site at
http://unitedspinal.org/
.Although this organization is not well known in ALS community, it provides
valuable services to PALS. To receive services, you must join the organization,
but membership is free. United Spinal is headquartered in Jackson Heights, NY
with several regional offices.
Financial benefits
-
Under the Wheelchair Medic
program, you get a 10% discount on the price of wheelchairs and scooters and 15%
off on parts. See
http://www.wheelchairmedic.com/
-
Low income members can get up to
$5000 for accessibility modifications to the home. See
http://www.unitedspinal.org/publications/action/2006/03/24/affording-accessibility-home-modifications/
-
Low income members may qualify
for grants for assistive technology and automobile refits. Call : 800-404-2898
or email
Other services and
free stuff
For a more complete
description of services see
http://www.unitedspinal.org/how-we-serve/1.ABLE to Travel is full service
travel agency that can arrange accessible transportation to and from the
airport, book flights, arrange accessible
accommodations, give information on access to medical equipment, and answer your
questions about wheelchair and disability travel. See
http://www.abletotravel.org/
2.Personalized consultations with experts in the areas
of
-
Accessibility Rights
-
Benefits Counseling
-
Social Services
-
Adaptive Sports & Recreation
-
Self Advocacy
-
Legislative Issues
-
Healthcare & Service Locating
-
Peer Counseling
-
Spinal Cord Issues
-
Veterans Benefits
-
Accessible Travel
-
Wheelchairs & Assistive
Technology
-
Design of accessible home
modifications
3.Special services for veterans under the
VetsFirst program
4.Educational materials and excellent ACTION
Online magazine,
Conclusion
You are not alone in your
fight against ALS. These organizations and others are ready to help you in a
myriad of ways. This information is accurate to the best of our
abilities.
CHAPTER 9
RESEARCH
Some PALS and CALS are
interested in learning about developments in ALS research and in looking beyond
the surface of the latest headline finding displayed on websites. Because PALS
and CALS are not familiar with the technical terms, I (RR)have supplied some
simple definitions taken from ALSA’s website and other sources which will make
the article that follows easier to read.Amino
Acids: They are the building blocks of proteins.Blood Brain Barrier
(BBB):A protective barrier formed
by the blood vessels and glia of the brain. It prevents some substances in the
blood from entering brain tissue.Central Nervous System
(CNS): The brain and spinal cord
combined.Embryonic Stem Cells:Embryonic stem cells are the "blank slates" of an organism, capable of
developing into all types of tissue in the body. Gene:Genes are the basic biological units of
heredity. They are composed of DNA.
Glutamate:Glutamate is one of the most common amino acids found in nature. It is the main
component of many proteins, and is present in most tissues. Glutamate is also
produced in the body and plays an essential role in human metabolism. It is a
primary excitatory neurotransmitter in the human CNS. L-glutamate is present at
a majority of synapses. Over-stimulation of these same receptors is thought to
trigger the neuronal damage associated with a wide variety of neurological
insults and diseases, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), lathyrisms,
and Alzheimer's disease.Glutamate
toxicity:Toxicity resulting from excess glutamated synapse.
Mutation:A
permanent change, a structural alteration, in the DNA or RNA. Mutations can be
caused by many factors including environmental insults such as radiation and
mutagenic chemicals. Mutations are sometimes attributed to random chance events.
Neuron:Neurons are the nerve cells which make up the central nervous system. They
consist of a nucleus, a single axon which conveys electrical signals to other
neurons and a host of dendrites which deliver incoming signals.
Neurotransmitters:Chemical substances that carry
impulses from one nerve cell to another; found in the space (synapse) that
separates the transmitting neuron's terminal (axon) from the receiving neuron's
terminal (dendrite).
Protein:Proteins are large molecules required for the structure, function, and
regulation of the body's cells, tissues, and organs. Each protein has unique
functions. Proteins are essential components of muscles, skin, bones and the
body as a whole. Protein is also one of the three types of nutrients used as
energy sources by the body.
RNA:
A
long-chain, usually single-stranded. The primary function of RNA is protein
synthesis within a cell. However, RNA is involved in various ways in the
processes of expression and repression of hereditary information. The three main
functionally distinct varieties of RNA molecules are: (1) messenger RNA (mRNA)
which is involved in the transmission of DNA information, (2) ribosomal RNA
(rRNA) which makes up the physical machinery of the synthetic process, and (3)
transfer RNA (tRNA) which also constitutes another functional part of the
machinery of protein synthesis.
Stem Cells:Cells that can differentiate into many different cell types when subjected to
the right biochemical signals. Stem cells are a promising new therapeutic
approach to treating CNS disorder. The most versatile stem cells, called
pluripotent stem cells, are present in the first days after an egg is fertilized
by sperm. Researchers believe they can coax stem cells to become whatever
tissues patients need. Stem cells come from embryos, bone marrow and umbilical
chords.
Superoxide Dismutase:An enzyme that destroys
superoxide. One form of the enzyme contains manganese and another contains zinc.
Superoxide is a highly reactive form of oxygen. For ALS, 20% of the total
patient population has mutations in the gene for copper/zinc superoxide
dismutase type SOD1. SOD1 normally breaks down free radicals, but mutant SOD1 is
unable to perform this function.
Synapse:A
tiny gap between the ends of nerve fibers across which nerve impulses pass from
one neuron to another; at the synapse, an impulse causes the release of a
neurotransmitter, which diffuses across the gap and triggers an electrical
impulse in the next neuron.
Toxin:A
poisonous substance of animal or plant origin.
Transgenic:An
organism whose sperm or egg contains genetic material originally derived from an
organism other than the parents or in addition to the parental genetic material.
RESEARCH OVERVIEW
By Wayne Gimlin
Wayne is 39 years old and
is an aerospace engineer.He is married with 3 kids.In Fall 2002, the ALS
clinic said that he had motor neuron disease with uppermotor neuron symptoms.They changed the "official" diagnosis to PLS in2003 but won't rule out
ALS.Today in 2006, he walks very stiff with awalking stick and trips
and falls on a semi-regular basis, speakswith aslur, and has general
weakness from head to toe.However, he still worksas an engineer and
“enjoys” life.Wayne posts regularly on Brain Talk and is a frequent
contributor to ALS-TDF.The Modern Era of ALS
Research BeginsThe modern era of
research into ALS began in 1991 with the discovery of the cause of a small
subset of ALS in its familial form, namely the SOD1 gene.
http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2006-04/nu-dsa042506.phpSoon after, this same
gene was modified in mice and a paralyzing disease similar to what human ALS
occurred.By over expressing the defective SOD1 gene in mice, scientists can
cause mice to show symptoms in their legs at approximately 90 days with death
occurring from 110 to 150 days.Although other mice and rat models (e.g. the wobbler mouse) have been used when studying ALS, the SOD1 mouse has been the
mostly widely used in the last 12 years.
The First Approved
Drug
In 1995, the FDA approved
the drug Rilutek as atreatmentforALShttp://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/796_als.htmlRilutek was first
proposed as an ALS treatment in the late 1980s with Phase I and II clinical
trials meant to show safety completed in the early 90s.By 1993, two large
Phase III trials in Europe and the US evaluated the efficacy of Rilutek.These
trials divided ALS patients into placebo and treated groups and compared the
survival rate of both groups over 18 months.In both trials, there was reported
a small statistical difference between the two groups and therefore Rilutek was
determined to be marginally effective in slowing ALS.The method of action of
Rilutek is the reduction of a chemical called glutamate that is used by motor
neurons to pass signals.It is theorized that an excessive amount of glutamate
is present that damages and eventually kills a motor neuron in a process called
excitotoxicity.http://products.sanofi-aventis.us/rilutek/rilutek.htmlDue in part to the
apparent success of Rilutek, there was a flurry of specialized drugs and
treatments that were introduced to clinical trials as a potential treatment.Examples of these trials included BDNF and GDNF which were injected into the
spinal fluid with a pump and the brain with an injection port.Other
specialized drugs were developed by Sanofi and other companies that were taken
orally or injected subcutaneously or peripherally.Unfortunately, all these
drugs failed their Phase III clinical trials that were to show efficacy and have
not been approved for use for ALS.
Clinical Trials | MDA ResearchBDNFOne possible exception
was a drug called Myotrophin that passed a Phase III in the US but failed in
Europe in 1997.This drug is actually a form of the brain protein called
IGF-1.In the Myotrophin study this drug was injected subcutaneously directly
into muscles of the patients. The theory behind IGF-1 is that it acts as a way
of protecting the motor neurons from damage caused by an external agitator.Currently, Myotrophin is undergoing a trial to determine a “final” answer to the
conflicting results of the two trials from the 90s.
http://www.rideforlife.com/news/als_research/clinical_trial_of_myotrophin.htmlRecent Research into
Pre-existing Drugs
The ALS research
community is mainly comprised of university researchers and a few non-profit and
for profit companies.Due to the multiple failures of very expensive developed
drugs in the late 90s, the ALS research community focused more on the use of
existing drugs to treat ALS. The advantage of using existing drugs is that they
do not have near the development cost and if found to be effective, can be
cross-prescribed for ALS patients.Some examples of pre-existing drugs taken to
trial for ALS research are:
Pre-existing drugs taken to Phase II or
III trials.
1. Celebrex. Failed Phase III trial.
2. Creatine Failed two Phase III trials.
3. Minocycline Currently in a Phase III trial.
4. Tamoxifen Completed a Phase II trial showing safety and possible
efficacy
5. Hydroxyurea. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
6. Ritonavir. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
7. Indinavir. Failed a Phase III trial.
8. Ceftriaxone. Currently in a Phase III trial.
9. Pentoxifylline. Failed a Phase III trial.
10. Sodium Phenyl Butryate (PBA). Currently in a Phase II trial
11. R+ Pramipexole. Currently in a Phase II trial
12. Thalidomide. Currently in a Phase II trial
13. Aramiclomol. Currently in trial.
14. Others.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspxSOD1 Mouse Studies
One important point about
these drugs is that nearly all were justified to the FDA and the funding
agencies as worthy of a human clinical trial, by the successful completion of a
SOD1 mouse test.In these tests, the mice are divided between control mice and
mice given a treatment.The variables of these tests include the point in their
lifetimes that the mouse should begin treatment, the amount of dose given, and
the length of time given the dose. Further there is a question of how many mice
must be used per test and how closely related the mice must be.Ideally, a
researcher should be able to take any two sets of mice, treat them identically
and the average lifetimes of both sets should be about the same. However, there
have been questions over the results of these reportedly successful mice tests.
ALS-TDF is a non-profit ALS research company started by James Heywood in 1999 as
a response to the diagnosis of his brother Stephen with ALS in 1998.ALS-TDF
first investigated the use of stem cell and gene therapy to treat Stephen’s ALS
in the late 90s.However by 2002, ALS-TDF started large scale testing of SOD1
mice in the hope that a pre-existing drug may substantially slow the rate of ALS
progression.To their surprise, as of 2006, and after testing several thousand
mice, they have not been able to reproduce with repeatability the results
reported from other researchers’ mice tests.This includes Celebrex, Creatine,
Minocycline, Tamoxifen, PBA and others.They have been able to find small (<
10%) life extensions which prompted them to help start a Phase II trial for
Hydroxyura and Ritonavir at the University of California in San Francisco (UCSF)
but have not been able to repeat these tests with consistency. The concept of
repeatability is a basis of science and experimentation.If a small set of PALS
were divided into two groups and their rate of survival tracked, it would be
expected that the average length of survival of both sets would not be exactly
the same. The two groups’ survival might be different by a few weeks or months.
If larger and larger groups were studied it would be expected that the
difference in survival between the two sets would diminish.The same is true
for mice.If small samples of mice are chosen to be in the control and in the
treated group there is some certainty that the two groups will have different
life spans by random chance.The way of proving that the treatment and not
random sampling is the cause of the treated group outliving the control group is
by repeatability, meaning that the test can be repeated by any competent
researcher anywhere and has approximately the same results.There is a large
question on whether the tests that have been published as “successful” are
actually repeatable.Other concerns over the
use of the SOD1 mice are the fact that the mutated SOD1 protein is not present
in most PALS both those with familial and sporadic forms.This has caused much
speculation that a successful SOD1 mouse test would not translate into a
successful human clinical trial.Also there is concern over the differences
between humans and mice on how they react to different drugs.Differences in
how drugs cross the blood brain barrier could easily complicate whether a drug
that affects or doesn’t affect a mouse would have the same type of result in a
human.To date, what is lacking is what is called a “positive control”.Essentially this is a drug or treatment that has proven success in mice and
humans which can be used to gauge how other reactions in mice might affect a
human. Since the SOD1 mouse is
one of the few animal models that closely mimic ALS, researchers will continue
to use them for drug discovery. What should be asked by PALS and closely noted
is how many mice were used, how many times was the test repeated using the same
parameters, and how many different laboratories also repeated the test.Past
research has shown that many if not all of the reportedly successful mouse tests
cannot answer these questions adequately.
Causes of ALS
ALS research is hampered
by the fact that how it is caused and how it progresses is mainly unknown.Although approximately 10% of ALS cases are known to be genetic, how the damaged
genes cause ALS is still not known.Since SOD1 is a gene that produces a SOD1
protein that acts as an anti-oxidant, some have theorized that oxidation could
be a key player in ALS.However, later research has pointed more towards the
concept that these proteins could be tangled or misfolded and thereby causes
cell death. In either case, one of
the current main focuses of ALS research is identifying what genes are defective
in familial ALS and if there are similar defective genes in sporadic ALS.
Currently there are several trials sponsored by the MDA that concern
identification of genes in ALS.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspx
Researchers are also
interested in environmental factors that could cause ALS but so far, none have
been proven.Besides the root cause, researchers have focused much of their
efforts into identifying what happens in the cells that cause ALS death.This
is a large subject but some of the areas of interest are:
1. Protein Misfolding
2. Immune system and Inflammation
3. Oxidation
4. Axonal transport
5. Excess Glutamate
6. Calcium
7. Mitochrondria malfunction
Biomarkers in ALS
Other interests of ALS
research include finding markers for the disease.For many diseases,
identification of biomarkers in the blood or cerebral fluid help to both
diagnose a patient with the disease and mark the efficacy of test drugs.To
date, Dr. Robert Bowser of the University of Pittsburgh has published a
biomarker study that identifies biomarkers in the cerebral fluid but it has not
been developed for general use.
Gene Therapy Studies
The concept of using gene
therapy has been investigated for ALS. There have been two basic approaches
examined.These are synthesis of growth factors and the use of gene silencing
Synthesis of
Growth Factors - In 2003, Dr.
Fred Gage of the Robert Packard Center announced that they had significantly
extended the life of a SOD1 mouse by the use of IGF-1 gene therapy. In this
approach, an AAV-1 virus is injected into various muscles of the mice.The
virus then moves up the nerve into the lower motor neuron nucleus located in
spinal cord. There it “infects” the motor neuron and changes its DNA
structure.This allows the motor neuron to synthesize a chemical called
IGF-1 that is thought to be protective.In the 2003 announcement it was
stated that trials could begin in one year but as of 2006, no human trial
has begun.
http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/press/2003/AUGUST/030807A.HTM
Another growth factor which has been theorized
as having a potential effect is VEGF.
http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/extract/291/23/2809-c
http://www.scienceblog.com/community/older/2004/10/20049657.shtml
Gene Silencing -
The use of a compound called
RNAi or sRNAi has been proposed for ALS to silence the effect of a defective
gene.This compound is essentially tailored to block the production of
specific proteins.In particular, for SOD1 mice, RNAi has been used to
block production of the SOD1 protein that is thought to be the cause of a
small number of ALS cases.In particular, this type of therapy is thought
to have potential to stop ALS progression where the actual defective gene
such as SOD1 is known.
One of the most discussed
topics of ALS research is the use of stem cells.Stem cells are the master
cells in the body that differentiate into other cells.Embryonic stem cells
which are the first cells created after conception are pluripotent meaning that
they have the ability to transform into any other cell in the body.Adult stem
cells are not pluripotent but do have the ability to turn into specific cells
such as neural or blood cells. Stem cells have not yet
been used for ALS by any legitimate research group although numerous scam
institutions around the world have used the controversy surrounding them to take
advantage of ALS and other patients. Despite that, the legitimate research
community has envisioned using stem cells in various ways for ALS.The most
ambitious may be the use of them to regrow the entire motor neuron network that
has already been lost due to the destruction wrought by ALS.The motor neurons
die in ALS and they are very large.The lower motor neurons are centered in the
spinal cord but their axons or nerves extend all the way to the muscles making
them up to 3 feet in length.The upper motor neurons are centered in the brain
and their axons extend down the spinal cord to connect to the lower motor
neurons.Recent work by Dr. Kerr at John Hopkins University has investigated
reconstructing motor neurons in rats.
Less ambitious but
perhaps not as complicated use of stem cells would be to use them to protect
existing motor neurons from destruction in ALS.It is thought that stem cells
could migrate to areas of the spinal cord not easily penetrable by drugs.They
could perhaps be pre-programmed to secrete growth factors or other protective
agents that could keep motor neurons alive.
ALS Research Funding
The majority of ALS
research is conducted by non-profit institutions or universities.This is
unfortunate because if for-profit pharmaceuticals had more of a role in this
research, more resources including personnel and equipment could be utilized. As
it is, the government through NINDS or the National Institute of Neurological
Disorders and Stroke is a major provider of the money for research,
approximately $50 million in 2006.Other providers are the MDA (Muscular
Dystrophy Association) and the ALSA or ALS Association.In addition to these are
smaller organizations developed by the families of PALS such as Project ALS
developed by the Estess family and ALS-TDF created by the Heywood family which
is also an active development laboratory that has been searching for drugs that
may slow or stop the disease.Websites are below:
http://www.als.net/
http://www.projectals.org/
CHAPTER 10
DEFINITIONS OF MEDICAL AND
RELATED TERMS AND SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
Age of Onset- ALS onset ranges from the early 20’s through the 70’s, with the
greatest frequency in the 50’s and 60’s. Average age of onset is 55.
Baclofen:
a prescription medication to reduce stiffness that often accompanies ALS.
BiPAP
– a small piece of medical equipment designed to take pressure off the
breathing muscles (diaphragm), usually when sleeping. The device is attached to
the nose or nose and mouth by a mask and kicks in right after the start of an
in-breath. It finishes the inhalation by blowing a volume of air into your
lungs, thereby resting the diaphragm. Can be hard to get comfortable with at
first, but becomes easier with practice.
Bulbar Onset – When symptoms first manifest in muscles that control swallowing,
chewing and speech.
Constipation- a common problem for PALS, fortunately numerous remedies are
available.
Cough Assist Machine
(Insufflator-Exsuflattor) – A type
of non invasive medical equipment that helps clear the lungs and throat of
secretions by producing a cough. For more Information, go to
J.H. Emerson - Cough Assist
Durable Medical
Equipment (DME) - Medical devices
designed to be used repeatedly such as bipaps, canes, cough assist machines,
wheelchairs, etc.
Electro Diagnostic
Tests - Studies including
electromyography (EMG) and nerve conduction velocity (NCV), that evaluate and
diagnose disorders of the muscles and motor neurons. Electrodes are inserted
into the muscle, or placed on the skin overlying a muscle or muscle group, and
electrical activity and muscle response are recorded.
Fasciculations: Small, involuntary, irregular, visible contractions of individual
muscle fibers. Often seen in the legs, arms and shoulders of PALS. This is often
described by people with ALS as "persistent rolling beneath the skin." Commonly
known as muscle twitches.
Feeding Tube or PEG
- Percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy tube - a tube placed directly into the
stomach through the abdominal wall to provide another way to receive nourishment
and liquids.
FVC (Forced Vital
Capacity) –
A formal measure of the
amount of volume of air that can be exhaled from the lungs using maximal effort.
You will be tested each time you attend clinic. Your performance is compared to
what the average person would score. The result is expressed as a percentage.
Hyperreflexia: Excessive response of muscle reflexes when a normal stimulus is
applied.One of the characteristic findings in ALS.
Limb Onset-
when first symptoms occur in legs, arms, feet or hands.
Lou Gehrig
– (1903-1941),
American professional baseball player, also known as the Iron
Horse because he established a record for the most consecutive games played by a
professional baseball player, appearing in 2130 games from 1925 to 1939. From
1923 until 1939 he played first base for the New York Yankees of the American
League. Gehrig was twice voted the league's most valuable player (MVP). Stricken
with the spinal disease ALS, which later became known as Lou Gehrig's disease.
Lower Motor Neuron-
Nerve cells starting at the spinal cord or brain stem and ending at the muscle
fibers. The loss of lower motor neurons leads to weakness, twitching of muscles
(fasciculations), and loss of muscle bulk (atrophy).
Miracle Cures –You have to be careful in this area. There are unscrupulous people
out there trying to sell useless and expensive products that are bogus. Be sure
to use common sense and don’t fall for false claims. Remember, no matter what
the advertising states, no matter what is promised, there is no current cure for
ALS. A good site to help you identify charlatans and false advertising can be
found at:
http://members.aol.com/alspinpoint/quack.htmlMotor Neurons-The cells that control voluntary muscle activity such as speaking,
walking, breathing, and swallowing.Electrical signals are sent from the brain
and spinal cord via neurons which in turn stimulate the muscles. In ALS, these
neurons slowly die off, leading to muscle atrophy and the other symptoms of the
disease.
Motor Neuron Disease- A group of disorders in which motor nerve cells (neurons) in the spinal cord and
brain stem deteriorate and die. ALS is the most common motor neuron disease.
Progression – ALS advances over time, it is not static. Some PALS progress slower or
faster than average.
Range of Motion (ROM)
- The extent that a joint will move from full extension to full flexion. Many
PALS do daily active or passive ROM exercise to maintain flexibility, as
recommended by a physical therapist, occupational therapist or other health
professional.
Rilutek- The only medication so far demonstrated to be effective in ALS, although only
modestly.It is quite expensive.
Spasticity - An upper motor neuron problem and is present to some degree in ALS.
For some patients it is minimal, for others extreme. Spasticity can actually be
helpful in maintaining function as the rigidity helps replace normal muscle
strength, but it causes jerky, hard to control movements. Spasticity causes a
tightening of muscles resulting in a stiffening of that part of the body in an
exaggerated reflex. It is actually triggering both the muscles to flex and the
muscles to extend that part of the body at the same time. It can occur in any
muscles - the arms, legs, back, abdomen, or neck. A simple touch can trigger it
and it may last only a moment or persist longer.
Sporadic ALS (SALS)
– When ALS occurs without afamily history vs. Familial ALS FALS) where ALS
occurs within the context of a strong family history.
Tracheotomy
or tracheostomy
is a
surgical procedure performed on the neck to open a direct airway through an
incision in the
trachea(the windpipe). Later in the course of ALS, the muscles that assist
in breathing weaken. Bipap is the first line of defense, but when that is no
longer adequate to maintain lung function, some PALS opt for a tracheotomy,
which is attached to a vent, a mechanical device that replaces spontaneous
breathing.Ventilation
or Vent-
A method to assist or replace spontaneous
breathing
using a mechanical device.See Tracheotomy.
Upper Motor Neurons- Nerve cells (motor neurons)that originate in the brain's motor cortex and run
through the spinal cord.In ALS upper motor neuron loss produces stiffness and
problems with balance.
Vitamins and
supplements - The vitamins and
supplements and the daily dosage range often used by PALS are vitamins C (1000
to 2000mg ), B complex, E (1000 IU), coenzyme Q 10 (200 to 1800 mg) and NAC
(1500mg)Some PALS take many other supplements, too, and use very few. There is
a school of alternative medicine that recommends a large variety of
controversial supplements and procedures. If interested, you can check this out,
but again use your common sense and think critically about claims being made.
CHAPTER 11
READING LIST
As suggested by Jodi Hall and other
Some people enjoy reading
personal stories of PALS’ lives from cover to cover. Another strategy is to read
only the early parts of the book, and then return later when you feel more ready
to process the later parts. There are so many excellent books, below is just a
small sampling.Learning to fall: The
Blessings of an Imperfect LifeBy: Philip Simmons
Philip Simmons was
diagnosed with ALS in 1993.An associate professor of English at Lake Forest
College in Illinois, Simmons was just 35. In his quest to help others-and
himself-Simmons turned his experience living with ALS into his first book,
LEARNING TO FALL: The Blessings of an Imperfect Life. The insights Simmons
shares in LEARNING TO FALL are less about self-improvement than celebrating the
everyday.
Tuesdays with Morrie
- An Old Man, A Young Man, And Life's Greatest LessonBy: Mitch Albom
Morrie Schwartz was Mitch Albom's college professor and mentor. Knowing he was dying, Morrie visited with
Mitch (an ALS patient) in his study every Tuesday. Their rekindled relationship
turned into one final "class": lessons in how to live. This book has been on the
best seller list over one year.
ALSA PAMPHLETS
Maintaining good nutrition with ALS-
A guide for patients, families and
friends
Caregiving-
When a loved one has ALS
Basic home care for ALS patients-
The ALS Association guide for patients
and families
Counting on Kindness:
The Dilemmas of DependencyBy: Wendy LustbaderIt deals with disability
and aging issues for those of us who rely on the help of others such as guilt
and resentment, why "little things" become so important, and the importance of
having a regular schedule. For example, disabled people often loose out on the
regular activities of life which provide structure, and days and weeks seem to
run together. Forgetting which day it is may just be a symptom of lack of
schedule rather than developing dementia. Regular visits, trips for meetings,
shopping, worship, or coffee can provide time structure, and gives one things to
look forward to and some sense of control to the powerless.
Closing Comments: ALS
A Spiritual Journey Into The Heart Of A Fatal Condition
By: Brian Smith
I Choose To Live, A Journey Through Life With ALS, By: William Sinton
Journey with ALS, By: David Fergenbaum
Tales from the Bed, on Living, Dying and Having It All
By: Jennifer Estess
Waking up
By: Terry Wise
Charlie's Victory By: Charlie Wedemeyer
His Brother's Keeper By: Jonathan Weiner
ALS: A Guide for Patients and Their Families By: Jonathan Weiner
Children's
books:
In my Dreams I Do,
By: Linda Saran
Lou Gehrig, the
Luckiest Man Alive, By: David
Adler
CLOSING COMMENTS
What began as an attempt
to develop a brief manual for newly diagnosed PALS and their CALS has grown into
a large guidebook. Whenever I tried to pare down the length, I realized instead
that something important had been left out.And so it grew. Still, there was so
much more that I wanted to include, but the manual would have become so lengthy
and unwieldy that it would have defeated its purpose. You will have much time to
learn more on your own, as soon as you are comfortable with the basics.The goals of the
guidebook were several: to ease the pain and suffering that follows the
diagnosis and to offer a more positive and hopeful perspective; to provide ideas
on how to cope effectively with ALS; to begin to lift the clouds of confusion
created by all the unfamiliar material to which you have been exposed; to
introduce you to the peer community of PALS and CALS and to provide introductory
information that will broaden your knowledge of both ALS and available resources
to battle it. And, all contained in one manual, integrating numerous sources of
information, and designed to meet the specific needs of those recently diagnosed
and their loved ones. I hope some of these aims were met.The emphasis in this
guidebook has been on living well with ALS and these pages have pointed you in
that direction.It will be the most difficult challenge that you and your CALS
have ever faced, but it can be done, as you have seen in the stories in this
guidebook. You can do it, too. And there are so many out there to help.I hope you will join me
and the many PALS and CALS at the Living with ALS group. You can learn
and gain encouragement from our posts and we need to hear your questions and
receive the benefits of your insights. We are all one in the fight against ALS.
To all new PALS and CALS,
welcome to our family.Randy Roberts, PhD
(psychologist, retired), age 60PALS, Diagnosed: 4/04
Email address:
- If you cannot swallow - get a gastrostomy.
- If you cannot breath - get a tracheostomy and a ventilator.
- If you get contractures (stiff joints and muscles) - get range of motion exercise.
- If you cannot talk - get a computerized machine that talks for you.
ALS AND PERSONAL GROWTH
By Randy Roberts
It may
seem strange or even repulsive to link this disease, which so cruelly ravages
our body, with anything even remotely positive. But as ALS pushes us to our very
limits, we have the motivation and opportunity to see ourselves and our lives in
very different ways. For me, it has been a spiritual awakening, in the broad
sense of that word. The psychological walls that I have constructed to protect
myself have been crumbling and my heart is open as never before.I have become
more sensitive to thesuffering felt by those who have lost their health and
more attuned to the pain experienced by so many in this world of ours.I have
come to feel a new appreciation of life and all the gifts given to us, gifts
that are taken for granted when healthy. I know now that it all isn’t about me
(surprise!) and that there exists a vast and indefinable presence that connects
all of us. And I have felt brief moments of peace that I have not experienced
before.I have
also seen the power of living in the present moment or, more precisely, of being
the moment. When we are able to still all the internal chatter of reliving the
past and thinking of the future, all of which are just dreams and imaginings,
what is left is moment by moment living. I have
also obtained a clearer distinction between image and reality in ALS. Image is a
projection of all of our negative ideas about what it is to be disabled, learned
from conventional societal attitudes. Reality is what people actually experience
when living with ALS, which can be much more positive than our images, as
personal stories in this Guidebook illustrate.Many
sources have helped contribute to my new found awareness, including my spiritual
training which began in earnest about a year ago, but reading the daily posts on
the Living with ALS forum has been an important factor. One’s
heart cannot but melt when reading posts of deep distress, helpfulness, courage,
compassion, caring, optimism, determination, good humor and encouragement.While ALS
takes away options that were once present, it can also act as a stimulus to
develop new ways of perceiving oneself and life. I feel that I have barely
scratched the surface and look forward to going more deeply into the spiritual
and personal development realms as time goes on.
ALS -- NOT CURABLE, BUT TREATABLE
By Edward Oppenheimer, M.D.
Dr.
Oppenheimer was on the faculty of UCLA Medical School Neurology Department. He
was a strong advocate for PALS and was a member of Living with ALSA, where he
often answered questions and wrote valuable, informative articles, such as the
one below.Many diseases can, of
course, cause death if not treated. High spinal cord injury, a serious
infection, an appendicitis, etc., can kill when neglected. When treated, these
are still serious conditions, but usually life can continue and death can be
prevented.
It's true that the average length of life of people with ALS today is about four
years. However, this reflects the fact that people with ALS often don't have
optimal treatment and resources.
If ALS is to be fully treated, people with the disease should have;
- Adequate
information about the treatments available
- Access to health
professionals who are interested in and experienced
- With all the
available options in the care of ALS
- The encouragement
to go forward
- The needed
resources to go forward
- The desire to use
available care
When the patient lacks
the desire to use available care, after having been fully informed and provided
with a positive approach from professionals such as doctors, nurses, physical
and occupational therapists, social workers and others, not proceeding is
acceptable. However, when any of the needs cited are insufficiently filled, not
treating ALS to the fullest is regrettable. Ideally, this situation shouldn't
exist.
What is "fully treated" ALS? The answer is my "wish list" for all people with
ALS;
1. A positive and experienced team approach to assist patients and their
caregivers in solving any of the problems that typically occur. This means a
patient should have access to a team of adept and enthusiastic health
professionals who are available even when the patient isn't taking part in a
research protocol. The team should include professionals who can make home
visits and coordinate care as needed.
2. Very good nutrition to maintain appropriate weight. At some point this may
include using a gastrostomy tube (feeding tube) if swallowing problems occur.
3. Regular social interaction with friends and the community. It's vital that
the person with ALS get out of the house by using mobility assistance, stay
engaged in living and maintain ways to communicate even if speech becomes
difficult. Good alternative and augmentative communication devices are
essential.
4. Personal assistance to cover each 24 hours as needed, without placing an
undue burden on family members.
5. Vigorous treatment for infections, particularly respiratory infections. This
can often be provided at home with appropriate antibiotics when needed.
Medication can be given by mouth, via a feeding tube or even intravenously,
depending on the person's condition.
6. Monitoring of breathing capacity so noninvasive assisted ventilation can be
available when capacity is decreased and related symptoms are present. An ALS
patient can receive mask-delivered or other noninvasive ventilation as long as
this works, and then shift to tracheostomy (invasive ventilation, via a tube
into the trachea) if that becomes necessary. Equally important are good
attention to effective coughing and clearing of secretions, and prevention of
aspiration (inhaling particles, such as food, into the lungs). The decision to
stop using a ventilator at any time, or to use only noninvasive ventilation and
not go on to tracheostomy ventilation, should be made by the patient.
7. Access to ALS research centers and protocols when desired, and access to
excellent ALS care even when there is no desire to participate in research.
8. Very good supportive care.
9. Good symptom-relieving care when major aspects of treatment are no longer
desired or appropriate.
When most of these aspects of care are available to people with ALS, they can
often continue living in a productive way and avoid life-threatening
complications related to ALS most of the time. ALS motor neuron impairment may
become severe, but life and spirit and social ties can continue.
Ideally, people with ALS should have choices. They should know that there are
options that will allow living to continue even if the resources needed are
considerable.
SIGNATURE EXPRESSIONS
Gathered from different
sites, these expressions, placed at the end of posts, illustrate coping
mechanisms in highly condensed form. They are little gems.
Don't forget to live!
Your friend in the fight
Laughing is good
exercise: it’s like jogging on the inside
Living & loving everyday
There is no such thing
in anyone's life as an unimportant day.
When you find yourself
in a hole . . . first stop digging!
It's not in our
abilities that we show who we truly are, it's in our choices
I know God will not give
me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn'ttrust me so much. (Mother Teresa)
Life's a dance, you
learn as you go
PSYCHOLOGICAL ISSUES OF NEW PALS AND COPING
IDEAS
By Randy Roberts
I am afraid of
dying: will itbe painful, will I
suffer, will it happen soon.
You are getting
way ahead of yourself; ALS is a gradually progressing illness.Morbid thinking
creates lowered mood, let such thoughts go. Focus on living now. Find
interesting activities to preoccupy your mind.Nobody, sick or
well, knows when they will die, only that all of us will pass away at
some time.Become involved
in spiritual work.There are many
ways to extend your life span. Be proactive, stay ahead of the disease.Remember, ALS
does not have to be fatal, you have a choice.
My life will
never be the same; how can I give up all my dreams, hopes and plans.
Grief is a
normal, painful stage that all PALS have to work through. It doesn’t
last forever, but may return after each new loss.You may continue
with your regular life for awhile and follow thru on some of your plans,
just sooner, like special vacations, etc.As you adjust to
your limitations, new plans and goals will be set.Reread the
personal stories in this section. Pay special attention to PALS’
descriptions of their meaningful, rewarding and happy lives even with
ALS.
I feel depressed
andanxious all the time.
Depression and
anxiety, like grief, are expected reactions.Identify what
you are thinking when you feel bad. Is it a negative?Observe how it
worsens your mood and then try to let the thoughts go.Stay aware of
such negative thoughts and let them go each time.Seek spiritual
guidance.Work at focusing
on positive goals, projects, things that interest you but you didn’t
have time for in the past.Focus on what
you still have. Appreciate that which is taken for granted when healthy
are truly special gifts.If bad feelings
persist, discuss antidepressant/anti anxiety meds with your doctor or
increase what you are now taking.Join
Living
with ALS, ask for suggestions, establish an on line peer support
network.Let yourself be inspired and encouraged by what you read.Consider
counseling or therapy.Communicate your
feelings to others. Don’t let yourself get cut off from family and old
friends. Build a new support network.A little humor
can work wonders. Find somebody or something that makes you laugh every
day.
I am fearful and
embarrassed about becoming dependent on others.
Again return to
the present. Let negative thoughts dissipate. You are getting ahead of
yourself.When the time
comes, you will be surprised that you will welcome the assistance, as it
becomes exhausting and risky to try to do something independently when
capacities diminish. You can now use your energy more productively on
other things that really matter.Aren’t all
people dependent on others, anyway?Your
embarrassment or shame will wither away as you realize that it is no big
deal and your caregiver views it as no big deal.
I keep thinking
of what liesdown theroad
Go back to the
present. Worrying about future events leads to worsened mood. Let the
thoughts go as they are preventing you from living well now.Nobody knows
what lies in the future, e.g. an effective drug against ALS could be
discovered soon. Become involved
in interesting and productive activities instead.
I am so angry
all the time
Anger is a
normal reaction to what has happened and is a stage that must be worked
through. It becomes a problem when it persists and you become bitter and
closed off. Then you are not living with ALS, but are being eaten up
inside.Chronic anger
and irritability may reflect underlying depression. Speak to your health
care professional about it. Try a
visualization technique. Imagine ALS to be an object of some sort. I
visualize a hideous looking scarecrow, and then proceed, in my
imagination, to inflict all kinds of punishment to him: kicking,
chopping, punching, bludgeoning, till he is reduced to pulp. I may do
this for 5 minutes and I always obtain a sense of satisfaction and
release. Just give back to him what he has done to you, no holds barred.Join
Living
with ALS. As you read the posts your heart may open up.Bitterness and
chronic anger prevents you from living your life to its fullest; they
close off options and keeps you imprisoned in their grasp.
How is my
illness going to affect my marriage or relationship with my significant
other.
It’s very
stressful on caregivers, but many handle it well. Some CALS, however,
are not able to manage.Discuss issues
directly with your CALS; don’t assume anything.Help make
arrangements to reduce stress, or encourage your spouse or other family
caregiver to do so, when things become too difficult for him/her, e.g.
paid care providers, help from family and friends, etcExpress your
appreciation. Thank yous, and expressions of affection are helpful.Don’t take out
your resentment on your spouse and make an effort to apologize if you
should slip.Working together
can bring you closer.If conflict or
dissatisfaction become intense, and can’t seem to be resolved, consider
counseling or begin to think of alternative living arrangements. The
earlier you can detect problems in your CALS’ commitment and/or major
shortcomings the better.
Why did this
happen to me?
Every PALS and
their CALS ask this painful question. It seems to demand an answer but
of course there is no answer. Coming to grips with it is part of the
acceptance process. It lessens in intensity and frequency over time.
COPING WITH ALS
By Loris Buccola
This piece integrates many of the ideas
presented in this chapter
I was diagnosed with limb onset ALS in November 1999 at age 58. I'm pretty much
completely quadriplegic, retaining head and neck movement. I still have my voice
with volume somewhat diminished, swallowing and breathing also diminished
(forced vital capacity below 30% at my last measurement a year ago) but intact.
I had a feeding tube placed December 2004 and use it for supplemental
nourishment once a day. I use a BiPAP at night and portable ventilator (LTV 900)
as needed during the day. I have a Permobil power wheelchair with four-way seat
adjustment, Switchit head controls and a Roho cushion. I sleep on a Pegasus
Airwave mattress and an adjustable bed. I use Dragon Naturally Speaking,
Smartnav head mouse, dwell click software and Skeleton Key (an on-screen
keyboard) to navigate the computer. I have a tablet computer for my wheelchair
with which I can control electronic devices. I have a Ford Windstar with a VMI
wheelchair access conversion. Although I'm retired from a 40 year teaching
career, I still continue to do professional counseling, writing and e-mail
correspondence with friends and family. I still "read" using the Talking Books
Program (through the Oregon State library) extensive library of books on tape.
I'm also a movie buff and subscribe to the Internet DVD service, Netflix. Here
are some techniques and attitudes I have discovered which have helped me to
continue adjusting to this disease, avoid depression and continue to appreciate
life.
1.Attitude is everything.
ALS is a challenge to adapt, rather than a battle to be won,
an opportunity to learn the art of acceptance. Learn how to pick your
"battles" by
learning new skills instead of struggling to deny the
reality of what is happening to your body. People will think you are really
wise and spiritual and
will want to be around you. It's magic.
Although it will be difficult at first, resolve immediately
to learn how to ask for and even enjoy getting help from other people. If
this disease can
teach us anything, it is that we cannot survive alone. It
will bring you closer to them and them to you. Some people may not be able
to handle whatis happening to you except by
staying away. That is their problem, not yours.
2.Plan realistically for the future.
The name of the game with this disease is adaptation. Try to
avoid wasting valuable time which you need to plan for the coming changes in
your life.
If you wait for a crisis, it will probably be already too
late.
Begin now learning to conserve your energy by not trying to
do more than you are realistically capable of. Deciding what is realistic
and what is thebest use of limited energy is a
major step in adaptation.
Anticipate the future just enough to ask yourself how you
will adapt as your physical strength declines. For example, I began learning
how to usespeech software before I really needed
it. By the time I did, I was proficient at it. It took six months to get
wheelchair I needed. Learning to usehead
controls, getting used to using breathing assistance, feeding tube, etc. all
takes more time than we anticipated.
If you have not already done so, consider attending an ALS
support group. It will be difficult at first to see people in all stages of
this disease. I hadto resolve to go back for
three group meetings. By that time I was already getting used to this look
into the future, learning how other people cope. with what is happening in.
We do not easily recover from setbacks from illness or
physical injury as we did prior to the onset of this disease. Time wasted is
time lost foradaptation. So, for example, don't
push yourself to continue walking until you fall and break a bone.
In spite of what you may hear, there is no cure for this
disease. Pursuing claims of cures will only cost you money and put you in a
time deficit. Once you have been diagnosed, avoid
falling into the trap of believing that it is something other than ALS (Lyme
disease, mercury fillings, etc.). When aneffective treatment is discovered we will all know about it and someone will
no doubt get the Nobel Peace Prize. My own rule on this: put me in touchwith three people who are clearly diagnosed who have at least six
months on this "treatment" and let me talk to them personally about how it
hasworked.
3.Dealing with Depression
ALS is a lousy disease and quite unfair. But try to avoid
taking it personally. It did not happen because of anything we did or did
not do. Giveyourself the luxury of feeling sorry for you only on a limited
basis, for example an hour a day or, even better, an hour a week.
Avoid dwelling on or worrying about all the awful stuff you
may have to go through in the future, or ruminating on all the things you
did not do in thepast. Of course, some of us with
ALS have other things to be depressed about besides the disease and this can
make avoiding depression much moredifficult.
4.Do something every day that gives you pleasure.
I love my morning coffee, having my head scratched, getting
a warm shower, watching a good movie, listening to a great book, listening
to jazz andblues, following the sports scene.
Be with people whom you love and who love you. You have a
right not to be with people who sap your energy. People will like being with
you if you
can help them get used to what is happening to you. Be nice.
Plan for things in the future that you can look forward to,
like visits from children and grandchildren, friends etc.
Cultivate a sense of humor about this disease. Some of it is
so ridiculous that it is actually funny. For example, I have unbitten
fingernails for thefirst time in my life.
Seriously consider antidepressant medication. It is not
addictive and it is not a weakness to need medication to help out with the
symptoms ofdepression.
If you have not already, begin to cultivate a spiritual
approach to life. There is more to this life than meets the eye. You will
have plenty of timeto think about these things,
the ultimate meaning of life, the nature and existence of something or
someone beyond us and upon which we depend. Youdon't have to have any formal religious training or upbringing. The process
of discovering meaning and purpose beyond our own little worlds is thebeginning of spirituality. Spirituality does not have to have any
complicated theology. In fact, the simpler the better.
Trust your instincts. In spite of a lifetime of religious
faith, I have come to believe that God did not cause me to have ALS, and in
fact is assaddened by the bad things that happen
to people as we are. I also am confident that God is with us in all of these
things just as he/she/it hasbeen with millions of
others over the centuries.
This disease can help us develop a sense of gratitude and
wonder about the mystery of life and death. It has taught me to embrace the
difficultexperiences of life as opportunities
instead of as obstacles to a meaningful life. I enjoyed "Learning to Fall"
by Philip Simmons, a teacher and writerwho had
ALS.
5.Taking care of your caregivers.
ALS is a social disease; it not only affects us who actually
have the physical symptoms, it also profoundly affects and changes the lives
of thosearound us who love us and care for us. We
have a responsibility, especially if we want to learn how to adapt and
prosper, to make sure we don'tovertax our
caregivers physically and emotionally. We will naturally tend to become
demanding, frustrated and impatient at times. But the more wedo this, the less people will want to be around us.
Make sure your network of care is wide enough to give people
some time away to recover and recuperate. Avoid the temptation to just pick
out oneor two favorites upon which to rely
completely. No one, no matter how much they love us can handle the load by
themselves.
You will learn gradually that you can tolerate not getting
immediate help that you don't really need: tolerating an itch you can't
reach.
TIPS ON DEALING WITH ALS BY alsfrombothsides
http://www.living-with-als.org/alsfrombothsides/
As someone quite amazed to
find herself in her 17th year of ALS and still busily,
happily, and contentedly engaged in living, I have reached the
point where I find myself saying "If I'd known I was going to
live this long, I would have taken better care of myself!"
For that reason, the main focus of this site is on dealing with
some of the medical complications we face as a result of ALS.
All too often these things are inadequately addressed because
the expectation is that we will not be around long enough to
worry about "long term" problems. These are problems that can
and must be minimized in order to assure a good quality of life
even if that life is short. In addition, I believe several
factors are going to extend the life of ALS patients in years to
come: The development of medications to slow progression.
Continued improvements in supportive care (nutrition,
respiratory support etc.)
Computer aided communication and environmental control equipment
will greatly improve the quality of life for ALS patients who
opt for ventilation. As a result more of us will take that
option and live for many more years.
There are also sections with practical tips for dealing with
some of the basic problems presented by immobility such as
traveling, and more sections to be added.
Safe Harbor
Rediscovering life on a ventilator.
Dress for success:
Toileting using a lift.
ALS Inservice for Nursing
Staff:
Read it or download it and pass it on.
Swelling of feet and legs:
Why it happens and how to minimize it.
Constipation:
Prevention and treatment tips.
Osteoporosis and Calcium in
ALS:
Why osteoporosis is "different" in patients
with neuromuscular disease.
BiPAP:
A non-life support breathing assistance
device.
Muscle Spasms -- Cramping and
Spasticity
Which is it and how can it be treated?
Travel Tips:
Some things I have learned while traveling.
The Attic:
No practical tips here, just my response to
a friend's question about what it is like to
livewith ALS.
Another aspect of coping
is knowing about assistive devices that can help compensate for weakened
capacities. At
http://living-with-als.org/
You can find reviews of
such devices, as can be viewed on the homepage:

Bathroom
Bedroom
Call Systems
Clothing
Computer
Eating/Drinking
Entertainment
Mobility
Respiratory
Speech &Communication
Travel
Miscellaneous

Many of the
questions on the
living-with-als group concern the equipment needed to deal with
disability. This section of our website was set up to help people
with ALS in their search for that equipment.
Unlike other sites that provide a
list of links to retailers and manufacturers, these pages are
reviews of specific brands written by people who have purchased or
tried them. The members of the living-with-als group hope this will
help others find the best possible equipment to keep them
living-well-with-als.
Computer Desk
Have you
designed, built, or adapted something that makes living with ALS
easier? Share your creative genius in the Do It Yourself (DIY)
section.
PEG Tubes
Buying a Van
Buying a Wheelchair
Hiring a Caregiver
ALS repeatedly presents challenges
that leave us stranded in unfamiliar territory. Dealing with
doctors, bureaucratic red tape, purchasing expensive equipment
without knowing what options are really needed, picking our way
through a financial minefield, as well as adjusting to disability is
all new and frustrating. These Tip Sheets are intended to be a
source of practical advice from the real experts -- PALS and CALS
who have been there, done that, and are wearing the T- shirt that
says "I wish I had known..."
Bathroom Design
#1
Bathroom Design #2
AccessibleHalf-Bath
Few homes
have been built with wheelchair accessibility in mind, so ALS often
requires some degree of remodeling. Share your remodeling project
with others here! Whether you want to share details such as floor
plans, before and after, tips and tricks, advice on getting the job
done, or just show off some pictures of the finished product, we'd
love to have your input.
Chapter 3A
ESPECIALLY FOR CALS
CALS go through the same
psychological stages as their PALS and, in addition, have the added
responsibilities of caring for the needs of their loved one, taking on financial
burdens and extra chores around the home. It can be overwhelming and CALS are
always vulnerable to exhaustion and burn out. The following articles convey the
strains felt by loving CALS, how to cope and how to take care of one’s own
needs.
My Story
By Trish
My name is Trish Wilson
and in my lifetime, have had many titles to my name, some being: sister, friend,
girlfriend, wife, mom and now my newest title, CALS or for you not familiar with
this new title, Caregiver of a person with ALS. Yep, Lou Gehrig’s disease.
Never in my wildest dreams did I ever imagine that this would be a title I would
have in my resume. When my wonderful husband Mike and I began searching for a
diagnosis to a problem he was having with his speech, we had no idea what this
search would lead to. We began as most of you will, with a simple visit to his
family doctor. From there we were sent without diagnosis to a neurologist due to
his tongue, speech and throat problems all along believing he had some growth in
this throat that was tying up his nerves in his mouth and neck.. Diagnosis' were
flying from friends and family only to make me a nervous wreck but having no
affect on my husband still believing it was some kind of growth that we could
have removed and move along with our lives. As we were put through an array of
testing, none of which we were told why they were being done, I became more and
more nervous every time they told me, "all of his tests are fine". I knew in my
gut he wasn't fine and wanted them to find SOMETHING wrong. I know, it sounds
insane, please find something wrong with my husband. I just wanted something to
be found so we could "fix it" and get back to normal.Needless to say, after our months of testing, two months to be exact which I now
find is a very fast time for diagnosis, the verdict was, "I think we are dealing
with Lou Gehrig’s Disease" were the words from our neurologists mouth. I, of
course, thought the man was a quack and after the initial shock, thought, I'll
take this into my own hands. If this doctor thinks Mike has ALS, I'll show him.
I'll go to an ALS specialist and prove he has no idea what he is talking about.
So, we did. We found the best specialist in Arizona only to discover once they
heard Mike was having swallowing problems, had lost over 35 pounds, felt
paralysis in his tongue, they rushed us in to see the doctor. Well, my feeling
of "that doctor was a quack" was becoming a nightmare. After seeing the ALS
specialist the very next day, it was confirmed. Mike has ALS. He was now a PALS
and I was now a CALS.Mike and I both have been through an array of emotions from extreme sadness, to
denial, which comes often, to acceptance. We have not been through the anger
simply because we do have an incredibly strong faith and believe God has chosen
our path and this is a path we have to live out with dignity. It is my husband
that shows me how to deal with this and it is my husband who is my hero for
taking this on in such a brave and unique way. Don't get me wrong, we both dream
of the days where "this can't be real" but for the most part, we are LIVING with
ALS and plan to continue doing this and embracing life for as long as God will
give us. ALS is not a death sentence, just a new way to appreciate your life.
CALS TO CALS
By Erin
Speaking CALS to CALS I want you to know you
have every right to feel the way you do. You wouldn't be human if you didn't.
Newly married or long time honeymooner's we all feel the loss, the frustration,
the anger, the loneliness.You will go in and out of all the above emotions. It is natural; it is just the
way it is.I have many years with my precious husband. But his progression was so fast we
didn't have one, two, or more years to come to grips with ALS. If he could only
do an nth of a fraction that some of our long time PALS here do, my husband and
I would have the world.So CALS, cry if you want to. Be mad, frustrated. Let those feelings happen but
then go look into your loved ones face, take their face into your hands and tell
them "I Love You". Everyday do that. After a while more love and new memories
will happen. You will always have the gamut of emotions, sometimes worse than
other times. But you will have what time is given to you on this earth with each
other.One thing for sure, you will learn the depths of love and compassion.
The emotional roller coaster can't be described. The emotions and stress, the
loss of living our day to day lives as we both knew it, as our children knew it,
is over.Some PALS with a slow progression have lived a good life for years.
Each CALS goes through a very isolated gamut of feelings and feels alone at
times. We could each write our own book and many of us have website's and blogs
to release our feelings, our progression, our journey. These sites and this
site, "Living with ALS" are the greatest help there is. Take it from me. My
husband’s progression was so fast we didn't have time to realize what was
happening. It wasn't until he finally reached a plateau that we could learn
about this thing called ALS.I never met anyone in an ALS group meeting that was at the stage of my husband.
No help there. It was early on and I needed answers, I needed help. I would
write to the ALS Digest and never get any answers. Very disappointing! It wasn't
until I discovered the "Living with ALS" site that I began to get answers and
discovered the most wonderful and compassionate people in the same boat as us.
What a base of humanity this site is to find this place with PALS and CALS that
know, that understand, that can cry with you, make you laugh with joy, allow you
to express the love, the sorrow, the frustrations, the unknown future. We all do
this together.I love you all.Erin CALS to Jeff
FROM ALSA’S INTERVIEW WITH SANDY
You and Bob continue to
enjoy vacations. What kind of preparation is needed before, during and after
travel with your husband?Travel requires a lot of
planning to be successful. At each stage of Bob's illness, we have traveled, and
the challenges increase as the illness progresses. However, the rewards are
worth it! Initially we just needed a wheelchair to get us through airports and a
roomier more comfortable car to rent at our destination. Now, we need a
wheelchair accessible room and bathroom with guaranteed access to all public
areas (make phone calls, and double/triple check!) We need to be sure that the
restaurants in the area have food Bob can eat comfortably or we need a
refrigerator so we can bring our own. We don't travel by air anymore - too many
hassles with his power wheelchair being damaged or mishandled, but we do have a
van that we are comfortable traveling in. We had an easy-lock device installed
to make tie downs fast and easy, I pack a cooler with pureed foods for him, lots
of water and syringes. Bob's computer goes on his chair up front with me, a good
map and a guidebook of accessible trails and we are off. I have to remember to
pack the charger for his chair, toilet necessities, pillows, extra clothes (he
gets cold),a blender, all his medications/vitamins, emergency communication
device(alphabet board) ,etc, and a smile. We have been very lucky and have found
that getting away even for 2 days gives us both a change of scenery and renews
our strength. We have seen some gorgeous mountain trails that are wheelchair
friendly! Once we get back home it is important to give Bob a lot of down time
in a comfortable chair, because one of the drawbacks of car travel is he is
confined to his wheelchair all the time.
How has Bob's diagnosis
of ALS changed your life?
In every way. It has
narrowed the focus of life to its essentials - love and respect, and has
deepened our love and commitment to each other. It also has me always alert
(sleeping is a challenge), and trying to care for the details of someone else's
life as well as my own is tough sometimes. With each change in Bob's condition,
using the wheelchair, having to feed him etc., we have grieved the loss and
struggled to handle it. I am, however, truly grateful for this time we have
together, and am amazed at the grace with which he makes each adaptation. No
matter how it has changed my life - his has changed a million times more!
What does the word
"Caregiver" mean to you?
For me, it is a lot of
responsibility with a lot of rewards. It is a chance to outwardly express my
respect and love for my husband. When hiring outside help I ask for kindness,
attentiveness, gentleness and respect for Bob and his changing needs. Knowing
that Bob's mind is functioning at top speed, even though his body doesn't, is a
challenge for some people. I need people who have the heart and inclination to
get to know this wonderful man.
As a primary caregiver,
it is often a challenge to maintain facets of your own personal life. How do you
maintain a sense of balance in your life?
Well, I didn't,
initially. But now, we have hired outside help (no help from the insurance
unfortunately) and I have re-established my friendships and work associations.
Not knowing how long we have together has made me reluctant to miss a moment,
but having help 5 days a week, 8 hours a day, makes the 16 hours a day I am
Bob's caregiver now have more balance. I also realized early on that I would
need guidance and I continue to see a counselor to help me deal with the
incredible loss and grief we experience daily. I try to get a massage at least
twice a month too!
LETTER FROM LINDA
ALLEN
Linda is a former CALS
and current Program Manager for Extra Hands for ALS. In this letter she
describes the challenges and rewards of long distance travel with her husband,
which personifies the idea of living fully with ALS, and also discusses the
innovative Extra Hands program, which links young people with PALS and their
families. Linda has given her personal email address and is willing to share her
knowledge about travel.Also check out the Extra Hands web site for a moving
description of the Program and its origins.
http://www.extrahands.org/linallen@swbell.net(email)and Linda@extrahands.org
My husband Marshall was
dx. Oct 31, 1996 at the age of 54 and earned his wings on Oct.27, 2000.You are
right when you say, “do all the things that you have planned on doing as soon
after dx”.We decided early on that we were going to continue to live our lives
despite ALS.We traveled by air, ship, bus, train, van, with the Permobile
wheelchair.(Europe AFOs), US and the Caribbean with wheelchair), we went to
restaurants, the theatre, sporting events, to visit grandchildren etc.We
learned to expect there would be road blocks a long the way but we believed that
we could navigate around them.We had some funny stories surrounding our
adventures, others that brought us to tears; times when we educated
management/housekeeping staff/ about things they could do to make their
establishments more handicap accessible, and coming up with innovative ideas to
solve a problem when we could not find a resource/solution for.Was it easy
“no it was not” was it worth it…you bet!I have so many wonderful memories
because we decided to continue to live life and so do our children, his two
sisters/brother-in-laws, my family and friends. I promised Marshall that
after he was gone that I would continue in the fight against ALS until there was
a cure. I am keeping that promise by working with Extra Hands for ALS.I hope
we can reach all our PALS/CALS in every area in every state with this program.What better way of spreading the word about ALS than through young people who
will be our doctors, researchers, lawyers, congressmen/women, etc. ALS families
have the opportunity to teach these young people about ALS and learn about the
disease first hand. The “extra hands” do household chores, yard work, playing
with the children, providing company to the PALS, whatever the ALS family needs
done that will take some of the burden off the shoulders of the caregiver.Instead of doing what needs to be done the caregiver can read, catch up on phone
calls, work in their shop, work on a hobby, spend quality time with the family
while the students are working etc.These students learn so many life lessons
that they would never learn if they had not been involved with an ALS family.Some PALS/CALS have had such an influence in the lives of the students that some
have decided to take up the same career as their PALS or CAL, or by learning
about ALS have decided to become a doctor, physical therapist, speech
pathologist etc.Also these kids let their families/friends know what they are
doing and teach them about ALS.The family members tell other family members,
colleagues, neighbors about what their kids are doing….more Awareness of ALS.It is my hope that we can
find teams of individual volunteers that would like to get involved and start
this program in their area. It takes a group of interested people, ALS families
that will use the service and a source in the community that will help to fund
the program.
TEN TIPS FOR FAMILY CAREGIVERS
1. Choose to take charge
of your life, and don't let your loved one's illness or disability always take
center stage.2.Remember to be good
to yourself.Love, honor and value yourself. You're doing a very hard job and
you deserve some quality time, just for you. 3. Watch out for signs of
depression, and don't delay in getting professional help when you need it.
4. When people offer to
help, accept the offer and suggest specific things that they can do. 5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
CHAPTER 4
MAJOR ORGANIZATIONS AND
WEBSITES
The first website to look
at is the Living with ALS group and the link to join is:
http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/living-with-als/messages
This forum has members
who are exclusively PALS and CALS and who range from newbies to 20 year
veterans.Posts cover a wide array of topics relevant to ALS, e.g. coping
strategies, personal issues/problems, symptom control, Medicare coverage,
equipment, just letting off steam, etc. Really, anything at all that involves
ALS. Practical and helpful information is offered, often more useful than what
professionals can provide. Members are enormously supportive, caring, wise and
knowledgeable. Many friendships are formed between members. Examples of a page
of posts are given below:
Subject
Author
Date
32205
Re: burning feetAre you taking any kind of blood thinner? Have you had a
doppler study done? I...
Danny
Oct10,2005
10:32 am
32206
Re: psychological impactI am sorry Fern that more people are not coming to see you.
When I was told I ...
COOKIEDD
Oct10,2005
10:33 am
32207
Re: Moms in the hospital again.she has no gall bladder, no appendix, no uterus, etc. they
have had to give her...
Mr. and
Mrs. Travis S...
Oct10,2005
10:34 am
32208
Re:
Nursing home
Thom, Fern and others Here is the starting page on starting
a search and how...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32209
Re: new pulse ox neededLinda I paid $199 for mine. I wouldn't pay any less.
http://www.savelives.com/...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32210
Re: Heart Race problemDanny You state the oxygen sat rate isn't affected by the
BiPAP. Here is a...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:43 pm
32211
Re: One Person Home CareJim, Our stories are amazingly similar including the size
differential and the ...
Jeff
Lester
Oct10,2005
3:06 pm
32212
Re: BiPAP Mark & LarryDear Lisa, I don't know if anyone else has mentioned this,
but is it possible...
Edith
Oct10,2005
3:30 pm
32213
Re: One Person Home CareJim, I like your innovative approach and determination. Can
you explain what...
Randy
Roberts
Oct10,2005
4:35 pm
32214
Re: Crazy Week
... of a ... say ... chair ... I know Susan, i wanted to
hide LOL! Things are...
Oct10,2005
6:57 pm
32215
Re: speech
Oct10,2005
7:00 pm
32216
(No
subject)
I was just wondering if anybody has a problem with waking up
and the covers ...
murrza
Oct10,2005
7:01 pm
32217
Re: Nursing homeA good place to find your local resources for possibly
living at home is your...
Oct10,2005
7:40 pm
32218
Re: One Person Home CareHi Randy, I was referring to a system with a overhead
hanging container...
Jim
Oct10,2005
9:26 pm
32219
peg tube stopped thanksThanks to all who answered my email. My hubby is calling the
gastro doc ...
Debbie
Oct10,2005
9:54 pm
32220
Re: One Person Home CareAllison, Jim and Jeff, THANK you for sharing your stories
with us on this...
Susan
Oct10,2005
9:57 pm
32221
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home CareHi all, I have read a few of the postings about the dilemma
about care at...
STOPALS
Oct11,2005
2:18 pm
32222
comfort curveI need to hear more feedback on the Comfort Curve mask.
Hospice won't pay for...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
2:22 pm
32223
Flu Shots for People with ALS
This is to remind PALS (people with ALS) it's time for your
annual flu shot....
Oct11,2005
5:15 pm
32224
Clinic TrialI went to my ALS clinic on Monday. They gave me my FVC
breathing test and they...
COOKIEDD
Oct11,2005
6:31 pm
32225
Re: comfort curveSherry, When I first got the Comfort Curve, I wore it only
in bed with my...
Randy
Roberts
Oct11,2005
6:33 pm
32226
Re: re [living-with-als] visionOn Thu, 8 Sep 2005 14:22:19 -0700 (PDT) Erin Smith
<erinzinn5@...> ... ...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32227
Re: Friends ~ Where Are They?Dear Sue, I can relate to that. Hang in there. God will send
new angels. Andi...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32228
Re: I'm new herewelcome Connie! Andi ... On Wed, 07 Sep 2005 06:57:09 -0000
"Connie ODonnell"...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32229
Re: comfort curve
Randy Thanks so much. I only have my bed on a partial turn.
I couldn't handle...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
8:18 pm
32230
ALS Registry Act Introduced in U.S. House of Representatives2005 Advocacy Update October 11, 2005 ALS Registry Act
Introduced in U.S. House...
lou_gehrig_054
Oct11,2005
8:19 pm
32231
Beds that turn youMy name is Bill and this is my first post. I have been
listening in for about...
netravelingman
Oct12,2005
9:04 am
32232
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home Care
Does your ride for life support your state only? In Calif, I
only get 1500 ...
rovall
Oct12,2005
9:05 am
32233
Re:
Friends ~ Where Are They?
Dear Sue, Sorry to hear that John's Mom and sister haven't
contacted you. It's...
COOKIEDD
Oct12,2005
10:00 am
The reader just clicks on
the first few lines of the post to get the complete post.
You can use a search
feature to get back posts on a subject of special interest. This site provides a
window into the world of ALS and can be inspiring, touching, informative, wise
and loving. There is also a chat room led by member of the forum and can be
accessed at:
http://www.mdausa.org/chat/calendar.html#lalsLocate the Living with
ALS chat and sign in as a visitor. Chats are held 2-5 pm on Sundays, 3-6 pm and
9-11 pm on Mondays and 7-10 pm Wednesdays. All times listed are Central time.
Transcripts of past chats are on file.
Another ALS peer forum,
Brain Talk Communities, is also quite good. Its strength lies in its many posts
on current research in the field and its section on personal experiences with
different treatments. The link is:http://brain.hastypastry.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=82The ALS Association (ALSA)is the only national not-for-profit health organization dedicated solely
to the fight against ALS. ALSA covers all the bases - research, patient and
community services, public education, and advocacy - in providing help and hope
to those facing the disease. The mission of The ALS Association (ALSA) is to
find a cure for and improve living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.
Its
website is chock full of information in every area related to ALS. The link is:
http://www.alsa.org/default.cfm?CFID=897541&CFTOKEN=9724212
The home page looks like this (below is a
photo you can’t click on it)
As you click on the blue
headings, subtopics pop up on every aspect of ALS. For comprehensive information
on any or all areas related to ALS, this should be your first stop. The amount
of information is awesome and can be overwhelming at first, but will become
easier with practice.
“The Muscular Dystrophy
Association is a voluntary health agency- a dedicated partnership between
scientists and concerned citizens aimed at conquering neuromuscular diseases….MDA
combats neuromuscular diseases through programs of worldwide research,
comprehensive medical and community services, andfar-reaching
professional and public health education.”MDA has an ALS division whose website is very
informative. It provides research updates, a newsletter, interesting articles
and very useful information. As organizations, there
is much overlap between the two. Both offer funds for research and patient
services, such as advocacy and support groups.MDA offers funds to help pay for
some or all of the cost of certain medical equipment, such as wheelchairs and
seat cushions, computers with speech synthesizers, etc. Local offices of both
ALSA and MDA have loan closets from which you can borrow durable medical
equipment of all sorts, including some your insurance will not cover. Contact
your local offices of both ALSA and MDA, which you can locate on their websites,
for more information. MDA has more dollars for research and services/DME, while
ALSA focuses more on advocacy atthe national level.
It can be reached at:
http://als.mdausa.org/
MDA’s ALS home page looks
like this: (also a photo only, not a live web page):

The ALS Therapy
Development Foundation is a nonprofit biotechnology company discovering
treatments for patients alive today.Their laboratory, the
leading drug discovery program for ALS, bridges a critical research gap.In-house expertise translates research into potential drug candidates by
screening drugs in the SOD1 mouse model of ALS. Their scientific
collaborations are designed to bring the most promising leads closer to patient
use.ALS-TDF shares emerging knowledge on the disease with patients,
physicians, and researchers as quickly and comprehensively as possible. Their
unique approach accelerates drug development for ALS. In addition, ALS-TDF
offers a forum for discussion of research issues. The link is:http://www.als.net/forum/Ride for Life is an
organization directed by a PALS that raises money for research and patient
services from various events, including their “Ride for Life”, a yearly event.
Their website is very worthwhile to view. It includes a number of personal
stories, research findings, information on grants and other material of interest
to PALS/CALS. The link is:Ride For Life Helping People Living With ALS - Lou Gehrig's DiseaseThe above are a few of my
favorites. There are hundreds of interesting and worthwhile websites that you
can choose.
Below is a list of
websites that are comprehensive and far reaching:
ALS and
Associated Web SitesCompiled By: Steve Weekes
(
)
ALS INFORMATION WEB SITES
ALS SOCIETIES, SUPPORT GROUPS &
PUBLICATIONSALS Association Chapter WebsitesALS Related Societies
ALS SOCIETIES AROUND THE WORLD(Over 40 Countries Represented)
ALS CHAT ROOMS
ALS FORUMS and DISCUSSION GROUPS
CAREGIVER WEBSITESTravel AssistanceCaregiver Chat Rooms, Forums and Discussion Groups
PALS / CALS - PERSONAL WEBSITESInternational PALS / CALS Personal Web Sites
MEDICAL SEARCHES, INFORMATION &
JOURNALSLyme and ALS Associated DiseasesAdvanced Therapies, Treatments and ResearchGeneral Health Care and Information
ASSISTIVE AIDS, DEVICES, and
SOFTWAREGeneral Assistance SitesCommunication Assistance and SupportComputer Adaptive Devices & EquipmentWheel Chairs, Scooters & VehiclesSpecific Assistance SitesMind and Spirit Resources
NATURAL & SUPPLEMENTARY THERAPIESDiagnostic LaboratoriesNon-Conventional Doctors, Clinics, Treatments, Therapies &
Theories
PRODUCTS,SUPPLIERS, ETC...
CHAPTER 5
BENEFITS AND ENTITLEMENTS
As PALS and CALS, it is
vitally important that you learn about your government benefits: disability
payments and Medicare/Medicare. It is also vital that you learn to deal
effectively with your insurance companies. What follows are some articles to
help you get started.
SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS
By Danny Dandignac
For the full version click
here
To download the full version in Microsoft
Word right click
here
choose save target as
How do we decide if you are disabled?
SSDI & SSI
The process we use to
decide if you are disabled involves five steps. They are: 1.Are you working?
If you are working and
your average monthly earnings, after considering the effect of work incentives,
are at the Substantial Gainful Activity (SGA) level, we generally cannot
consider you disabled. If your monthly earnings average less than the SGA level,
(in 2006 that level was $860 per month) we look at your medical condition using
steps 2 through 5.
2.Is your medical
condition "severe"?
For us to consider you
disabled, your impairment(s) must significantly limit your ability to do basic
work activities, for example walking, sitting, seeing, and remembering. If it
does not, we cannot consider you disabled. If it does, we go to the next step.
3.Is your medical
condition in the list of disabling impairments?
We maintain a Listing of
Impairments for each of the major body systems that are so severe we
automatically consider you disabled. If your medical condition(s) is/are not on
the list, we have to decide if it is of equal severity to an impairment on the
list. If it is, we approve your claim. If it is not, we go to the next step.
4.Can you do the
work you did previously?
If your medical condition
is severe, but not at the same or equal severity as an impairment on the list,
then we must decide if you can do your past relevant work. If you can, we will
deny your claim. If you cannot, we go to the next step.
5.Can you do any
other type of work?
If you cannot do your
past relevant work, we then see if you are able to do any other type of work. We
consider your age, education, past work experience, and transferable skills. If
you cannot do any other kind of work, we will approve your claim. If you can, we
will deny your claim.
FURTHER INFORMATION ON SOCIAL SECURITY
BENEFITS
(TAKEN FROM THE REGULATIONS)
By Randy Roberts
Find out if you're eligible for Social
Security Benefits
Benefit Eligibility
Screening Tool (BEST)
Use our screening tool to help identify all the different Social Security
programs for which you may be eligible.
Overview
We pay disability
benefits under two programs: the Social Security disability insuranceprogram and the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program.
If you qualify,
apply for Social Security disability benefits online.
No matter what kind of
disability benefits you are applying for, you must
give us information about your medical, work, and education history to help
us decide if you are disabled.
- Note: If you're an
Advocate, Attorney or Third Party Representative,
we need additional information from you on the application.
Detailed information
about each of these programs is available at the following websites:
You don't have to be
disabled or blind to collect
Supplemental Security Income (SSI) if you are 65 or older.For most people, the
medical requirements for disability payments are the same under both programs,
and your disability is determined by the same process. Use our
Disability Planner to find out medical and earnings requirements, what
happens once you’re approved, and more.Our
calculatorscan give you an estimate of disability benefit amounts based on
your record if you should become disabled. If you get Social Security (not SSI)
disability benefits you
possibly could be eligible for Medicare.
SSI is a program run by
Social Security that pays monthly checks to the elderly, the blind and people
with disabilities who don't own much or who don't have much income. If you get
SSI, you usually get food stamps and Medicaid, too. Medicaid helps pay doctor
and hospital bills.While eligibility for
Social Security disability is based on prior work under Social Security, SSI
disability payments are made on the basis of financial need.
Who Can Get Social Security Disability
Benefits
Children may qualify for disability benefitsunder either the Social
Security program or the SSI program.You can get Social
Security disability benefits until age 65. When you reach age 65, your
disability benefits automatically convert to retirement benefits, but the amount
remains the same. Certain members of your
family may qualify for benefits on your record. They include:
- Your spouse who is
age 62 or older, or any age if he or she is caring for a child of yours who
is under age 16 or disabled and also receiving checks.
- Your disabled widow
or widower age 50 or older.
- Your unmarried son
or daughter, including an adopted child, or, in some cases, a stepchild or
grandchild. The child must be under age 18 or under age 19 if in high school
full time.
- Your unmarried son
or daughter, age 18 or older, if he or she has a disability that started
before age 22.
If you become the parent
of a child (including an adopted child) after you begin receiving Social
Security benefits, be sure to notify us so that we can determine if the child
qualifies for benefits. For more information
about disability benefits for children, ask Social Security for the booklet,
Benefits for Children With Disabilities
(Publication No. 05-10026).Note: The SSI program
also pays benefits to needy disabled children under age 18.
How to Apply for Disability Benefits
Apply as soon as you
become disabled. You can file:
- Online using our
Internet Social Security Benefit Application
- By phone, mail or in
person at any Social Security office. Call for
an appointment.
Note: You may receive
back benefits from the date you became disabled, but they're limited to one year
before the date you filed for benefits.
How to Speed Up Your Disability Claim
It generally takes from 3
to 5 months to process claims for disability benefits. You can help shorten the
process by bringing certain documents with you when you apply and helping us to
get any other medical evidence you need to show you are disabled. These include:
- Your Social Security
number;
- Your birth or
baptismal certificate;
- Names, addresses and
phone numbers of the doctors, caseworkers, hospitals and clinics that took
care of you and dates of your visits;
- Names and dosage of
all the medicine you take;
- Medical records from
your doctors, therapists, caseworkers, hospitals, and clinics that you
already have in your possession;
- Laboratory and test
results;
- A summary of where
you worked and the kind of work you did; and
- A copy of your most
recent W-2 Form (Wage and Tax Statement) or, if you are self-employed, your
federal tax return for the past year.
You also should be ready to answer other questions we must ask.
Don't delay filing for
benefits just because you don't have all the information and documents you need.
The people at the Social Security office will be glad to help you.
Who Can Get SSI Benefits
To get SSI benefits, you
must be elderly or blind or have a disability.
- "Elderly" means you
are 65 or older.
- "Blind" means you
are either totally blind or have very poor eyesight. Children, as well as
adults, can get benefits because of blindness.
- A disability means
you have a physical or mental problem that is expected to last at least a
year or result in death. Children, as well as adults, can get benefits
because of disability.
You must live in the U.S.
or Northern Mariana Islands and be a U.S. citizen or national. (Certain
non-citizens also may be eligible for SSI. A Social Security representative can
tell you if you qualify.) Also, the things you own
and your income must be below certain amounts. See our publication on
Supplemental Security Income (SSI)
(Publication No. 05-11000) for details about the income limits.
How Much You Can Get from SSI
The amount of your
benefit depends on
where you live.
You could get more if you
live in a state that adds to the SSI check. Or you could get less if you or your
family has other money coming in each month. Your living arrangements also make
a difference in whether you can get SSI and the amount you can get.
MEDICARE
By Andy Etherington
Andy
was diagnosed in 2002 and is now trached and vented. He is 45, married and has
two young children. Formerly, he worked in the telecommunications industry,
writing software and working with
customers.I will try to help as
much as I can. Note that I am not an expert or a lawyer, just an affected person
with a vested interest in this topic, and have been studying these issues for
the last six months. So everything below here is my interpretation of the
issues, and may not be correct.We will start with some
definitions.
Medicare
- coveragefromthefederalgovernment that you are entitled to. There are
3
PartstoMedicare. Do not confuse the parts of Medicare with the supplement
plans described below, they are vastly different. Part A coversmosthospitalizationcosts,exceptfora deductible of
$952foreachhospital stay of less than 61 days. If you stay for more than 60
days, there is a co-insurance of $238/day for the next 30 days. After 90 days it
goes up to $476/day through day 150. As near as I can tell, no one knows what
happens after day 150. Days 91-150 are referred to as lifetime reserve
days, and can only be used once. Note also that if you are discharged
from the hospital after less than 60 days, and are re-admitted again less than
60 days after your initial admission, it counts as the same hospital stay. You
are not charged the deductible again, and counting of days does not
start over. Part A costs you nothing extra, it is funded through
a 1.45% payroll tax on all workers. Part A is not optional, but also costs
nothing.
Part B coversmostoutofthehospitalexpenses,usuallyatthe
80%/20%rate.Thisincludesdurablemedicalequipment
(DME)suchasventilators,cough assistmachines,etc.thisispaidforthrough
adeductionof $88.50permonthfromyourSSDIcheck. This part is optional, but
be careful. If you don't sign up for it when you become eligible, you must wait
until an open enrollment period (usually January 1-February 28).
For every year you are eligible for part B, but decline
coverage, you are subject to a 10% penalty for each year that you declined coverage. This penalty is cumulative, so if you had declined
for 2 years, and then enrolled this year, instead of paying $88.50 per month,
you would pay $106.20 per month. Furthermore, if the Medicare rate goes up by
$10 next year, yours would go up by $12, and would continue to rise 20% higher
than the standard each year. There is an exception to this,
however. If you are covered by an employer sponsored group health plan, either
through your employer or your spouse's, and the person whose
coverage you are under is considered to be an active employee,
even if you're not being paid, you have what is called a special
enrollment period.You may enroll in Part B without penalty
any time while you're still covered by the group health plan, or during the 8
months following the loss of that coverage. Note that COBRA coverage is provided
to people whose employment has terminated, and does not provide or extend a
special enrollment period.
Part D– the infamous prescription drug program. This is a program that is provided
through private insurance companies to help with the cost of medicine. This part
is also optional, but again, be careful! If you don't sign up for
one by May 15, you are again subject to penalties. This time it is 1% per
month for each month you are eligible, but choose not to participate.
There is, once again, an exception to the penalty. If you have
been covered by a prescription plan from your company or union, or their
retirement program (I am interpreting this to include COBRA), and it
provided equivalent or better coverage than Part D, you may join
without penalty. Part D plans cost anywhere from $0-$100 per month, depending on
the company. Each plan has it's own formulary, or list of covered
drugs. If you take prescriptions that are not on the formulary, not only do you
pay full price for it, but the amount you pay does not count toward your Part D
deductible or out of pocket maximum. So your best bet is to find a plan that
covers your high cost medications, and pay for the less expensive medicines
yourself. I also dropped rilutek, because it not only expensive, but even on
plans with it on the formulary, because limits are based on the full price of
the drugs, it was going to increase my out of pocket cost by over $1000/year.
Since I'm already on a ventilator, none of my doctors could (or would) give me a
recommendation. If you have trouble understanding the Part D limits, I have
another document that describes it in more detail.
You are eligible
for these,butnotrequiredto accept them(see above) as
of the date you became eligible for social security
disability.Mostpeopleinthesocialsecurityofficewilltellyouthatyou'renoteligibleuntil
24monthslater.These people are wrong! The law was changed
three years ago; the word just hasn't trickled down to the local offices yet. You also cannot be denied Medicare because of your ALS diagnosis!
That is what it's there for. Find more information at
www.medicare.gov
Medicare supplements
- standardized plans, labeled A-J,
often called Medigap
plans, are offered by private insurance companies to
cover the perceived "gaps" in Medicare coverage. Each company offering a
Medicare supplement is allowed to charge whatever the market will bear, but
unlike the prescription program, supplement policies are required to provide
standard coverage. Thus company 1 can provide a plan A supplement (not the same as Part A above) for $59/ month; while company 2 has a plan A
supplement for $150/month. By law, the coverage provided by both companies must be exactly the same,
despite the wide range of costs. In Texas,
I am only guaranteed to be able to obtain a supplement plan A. when I look at
the Medicare web site, I can find at least 20 companies willing to sell a plan A
to me, but only 2 say they would sell me a plan D policy, and they are such
small players that they don't even have web sites! Looking in Indiana, I only
see one company offering a plan A supplement for under 65 (Anthem), and only one
willing to sell a plan B (Bankers Fidelity). There were none selling any other
supplement policies to people under 65. That would imply to me that, with no
competition for either company, prices will be high. It may be worth it though.
Here is my take on what they provide:
Plan A supplement
–
covers the Part A co-insurance (not
the deductible, see above Part A discussion), and the Part B
co-insurance. Part A deductible is $952 for each hospital stay, but doesn't
reset until you've been out for 60 days, so it is physically impossible to incur
more than 6 of these per year. Plan A supplement also adds 365 additional
lifetime reserve days. The Part B co-insurance is the 20% that Medicare doesn't
cover for outpatient things like doctors' visits, outpatient surgery, and DME.
However, there is a comment, in the home health services section,
that says you pay 20% for DME, so I am not sure whether ventilator, cough
assist, etc. would fall in this category or not.
Plan B supplement
–
the only thing the Plan B
supplement adds is coverage for the Part A deductible (that $952 payment for
each hospital stay). Everything else under Plan A supplement is the same under
Plan B.I know that during your
initial enrollment period, they are not allowed to "rate" or reject you based on
pre-existing conditions (your ALS, for example). I don't know if they are
allowed to use underwriting (underwriting: using current or past medical
conditions to charge higher rates or reject applicants) if you're
outside your initial enrollment period. I may be finding out soon, I'll let you
know.
Medicare Select
– really a misnomer, because it applies only to the supplement policies
above, it provides the same coverage as the supplement plan it refers to (i.e.
Medicare Plan A Supplement Select), but only if you use their doctors and
facilities. Kind of like a Medicare HMO. A moot point, because the
Medicare site doesn't list any that will sell a select policy if you're under
65.
Medicare Advantage
–
you didn't mention these, but I'm
sure you've heard of them. Around here we see ads for these 40 times a day,
mostly during business hours. These plans completely replace Medicare and
supplement plans. If you choose to use a Medicare Advantage plan, you
will be unenrolled in Medicare! Every Medicare Advantage plan has
different terms and conditions. It's just like shopping for any other health
insurance. I don't know if any underwriting is involved, but it was never
mentioned during my investigation of the subject. If you decide to go this way
(I decided not to), there is one more thing to know: there are two kinds of
Medicare Advantage programs. Those that cover prescriptions and those that
don't. Consistent with the idea that you are out of the Medicare system if you
enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan, if you choose a Medicare Advantage
plan that does not cover prescriptions, you will not be allowed to join a
prescription only drug plan, and you will not be able to get prescription
coverage!
Medicaid – is a state-run program, primarily intended
for low-income patients. There are generally both income and asset limitations
for qualifying. States set their own limits, so they are different everywhere. I
have found anecdotal evidence that Indiana has their limits set to $1273/ month
in income, and $2000 in total assets (excluding certain items like house, 1 car,
etc. for a still living spouse). My SSDI payment is more than that, so I have
not pursued it. There are ways to get within these limits, but I am not familiar
with them. I would recommend that you consult an attorney that specializes in
elder care law for additional information if you're thinking of going this
route.
Risk pool
–
I don't know if Indiana has this concept,
but in Texas we have a Risk pool for individuals that are unable to get health
insurance otherwise. An ALS diagnosis automatically qualifies me for the pool.
There is no underwriting, but they are required to charge twice the going rate
for the opportunity to be in the risk pool. This policy (again, this is my interpretation
of how it works in Texas, Indiana may be
different, or may not even have a Risk pool) pays as secondary to
Medicare.See the discussion below for primary vs. secondary. Another thing to think about is respiratory therapy. Medicare does
not
cover respiratory therapy visits. The Risk pool does. That hasn't been
enough, in my case, to justify going this route yet. One more hitch, I cannot
join the Risk pool as long as I am eligible for COBRA, even
if I don't take it.
Primary vs. secondary
–
this is an issue when a patient
is covered by 2 different insurance policies, and is called coordination of
benefits, or COB. This can be caused by numerous things, like the Risk pool
example above, or group coverage from a spouse's employer. The way COB works is
that one policy gets the claim first, and forwards it to the secondary after
paying their portion. The secondary then processes the remainder of the claim
according to their policy. There are 2 ways I have heard this works. The more
favorable way, which is what I've experienced, the primary pays 80%, then the
secondary pays the rest, up to 80%. It's strange to think about, so here is an
example:My respiratory company
charges $590/ month for my cough assist machine. Medicare gets the claim, and
allows $400 (all these figures are hypothetical). My provider accepts
assignment, so they are happy with $400. Medicare then pays 80% of it, or $320.Now they pass the claim to my secondary. My provider is out of network for them,
so they would normally only pay 70%, or $280. But Medicare already paid $320, so
the secondary pays $80, and counts themselves lucky, because they paid $200 less
than what they are contractually obligated to pay.Obviously this is
advantageous to me, as I end up paying nothing. The other way that I have heard,
but not experienced, works like this:Same scenario as before,
company bills $590, Medicare allows $400, and pays $320. But now the secondary
gets it. They look at it and say "we would have paid $280 for this service.
Medicare has paid $320, so we don't have to pay anything."I'm not nearly as happy,
because I'm stuck with the $80 remainder, and am paying premiums for a policy
that never seems to pay out. Again, I have not experienced this happening, but
others on this board have reported it. How do companies decide which is primary?
In my case, Medicare became primary because I wasn't being paid, thus no FICA
taxes were being paid. If my coverage had been through my wife's employer, and
she was still having FICA withheld, Medicare would be secondary. Others have
said it has more to do with the number of employees being greater or less than
100, but I'm more inclined to believe mine, since I heard it from the COB desks
at both plans.
Medicare capped item
-
One more thing that you may want
to know about, especially if you're thinking about buying your equipment
supplier out, is the idea of Medicare capped items. Many of the things we use
are actually rented by Medicare. After 10 months of renting the equipment you
are given a choice to buy it or keep renting it. If you choose to buy it,
Medicare will pay for 2 more months (total of 12 months). Title to the equipment
goes to you, and no more payments are due, but you are responsible for upkeep.
If you choose to continue to rent, Medicare will continue to pay for 5 more
months (total of 15 months). Title to the equipment remains with the equipment
supplier, no more payments are due, and the supplier is responsible for upkeep.Now to the answer that
you didn't want, but I'm sure you knew was coming. No one can make the decision
for you. It is highly dependent on your financial position and your risk
tolerance. I would strongly recommend that you talk to a specialist in elder
care law before making a final decision.I will tell you what my
decision was. The gentleman that was here specifically to
sell me a Medicare Advantage
plan, told me to stay away from them because they weren't very good with DME
extensive conditions, of which ALS is certainly one. So I have decided that,
when they kick me off COBRA, I am going to immediately apply for a Medicare Part
D plan and a Plan A supplement. Good luck with your research. If you have any
other questions, feel free to ask. Just be forewarned: you may get another tome
like this one!
MORE ON MEDICARE PART DPRESCRIPTION COVERAGE
By Andy
Let me try to summarize
it for you.
Each state has several companies that offer Medicare Part D
coverage. each of these companies offers several plans, with different premiums,
different deductibles, and different coverage. All this adds up to an
overwhelming amount of information. In Texas I had 48 different plans that I
could choose from.
Every prescription drug
plan has a formulary, which lists the drugs they will cover, and the (up to 4)
different prices that they will charge for each drug. There are 4 different
levels of support included in each plan:
DeductibleThe
first $250 dollars of drug expenses are paid for out of pocket at full price.
Some plans have no deductible, and start coverage at the next level.
SupportAfter the
deductible is met, drugs can be obtained for either 25% or a fixed co-payment.
Each formulary uses a different base price for each drug, though formularies
within the same plan family tend to use the same price structure (Humana's
prescription drug only plans uses the same prices as the Humana Medicare
Advantage plans with drug coverage). Once you reach $2250 in total drug costs
(what you pay plus what the plan pays), you move to the next level Donut hole.
This is the part that is most confusing. Between the time that you reach $2250
in total drug costs and when you reach $3600 in out of pocket expenses, you pay
100% of the drug prices. Did you get that? That means that, between $2250 in
total drug costs and $5100 in total drug costs you pay 100% of your prescription
costs. Still with me? Ok, one more
thing.After you've paid $750 for your prescriptions
($250 deductible plus 25% of the next $2000), and before you've paid $3600 in
out of pocket expenses, you pay full price for all your medication. That's all
the ways I can think of to explain it.
Catastrophic coverageOnce you exceed the threshold of the donut hole, you get catastrophic
coverage, under which you pay the greater of $5 ($2 for generics) or 5% of the
full price.
For complete
information on all aspects of Medicare benefits, always go to
http://www.medicare.gov/
CHAPTER 6
PARTICIPATINGIN CLINICAL
TRIALS
By Randy Roberts
Clinical trials
are
formal tests of safety and efficacy of new drugs or procedures. There are three
phases in trials:
1) Safety- to assess if
the new compound can be tolerated without major side effects.
2) Safety and efficacy-involving more subjects, including a placebo group (no medication) or so called
“control” group;
3) Efficacy-
The final
phase-to determine efficacy using a much larger sample size and held at multiple
sites around the country, always uses a placebo group.
All drugs used in the
trials are free of charge. It is important to consider participating in a trial
at an early point in your illness because the studies require subjects to meet
certain criteria, e.g., FVC > 60 or 70 or the ability to walk unaided, and one
never knows how fast one will progress.PALS have to weigh potential benefits
against inconvenience, as the trial location may be many miles from home. And
PALS who volunteer are helping in the quest for a cure. Discuss the open trials
with a neurologist, to help guide your decision. Below is a current list of
trials that are recruiting patients, as of 11/06. Check back at the website
below monthly to get updates.The ALSA and MDA sites also keep updated lists of
trials, so check these, too.

Click the Logo above to see the ClinicalTrials.govweb site.
Chapter 7
ADVOCACY
Over the course of the
illness, many PALS become interested in advocating. Some become so engrossed
that it becomes a meaningful and satisfying focus of their lives. The following
articles provide you with comprehensive information on advocacy and the tools to
get involved.
Advocacy!
By Catherine Wolf
Catherine Wolf was
diagnosed with ALS in September, 1997 at age 50. Cathy had a tracheostomy in
2001 and is now completely ventilator dependent. She faces ALS with optimism, a
fiercely independent nature, and an occasional tear. Before ALS, she worked for
IBM, and was an avid runner and dancer. She has two adult daughters and is the
enthusiastic grandmother of one grandson. Cathy lives with her husband Joel in
Katonah, NY.
Introduction
What is advocacy? The
dictionary defines advocacy as “active support for a cause.“ Most people feel
better when they are doing something. We feel that our lives have
purpose. Although there is not yet a cure for ALS, PALS typically feel good when
they are involved in advocacy. As a newly diagnosed PALS, you have the physical
capability to do more than your less recently diagnosed fellow PALS. So get
involved! This chapter describes some of the ways you can become involved in
advocacy.
What are your skills
and interests?
When contemplating how to
get involved, assess your skills. Were you a bookkeeper? Perhaps you can
volunteer to keep the books for an ALS fund raiser, or help a fellow PALS
organize his/her finances. Were you a nurse? Now is the time to educate yourself
about ALS so you can explain the often mystifying jargon doctors sometimes use
about ALS. In my case, I had spent many years as a usability expert in software
design. I made sure when I was still working that the software I worked on was
usable by people with motor disabilities. And when I encountered programs made
by my company that were difficult for me to use, I suggested ways to improve
them. Perhaps most important, I made suggestions for improving the assistive
technology I used. Thus, I used my work skills to advocate for all PALS. Altogether your body will
lose physical function, there is no limit to what your mind can do, especially
when armed with a computer. Kyle Hahn, a musician, started the ALS March of
Faces, an awareness and advocacy organization. Will Hubben compiled and
distributed ALS research. David Jayne, stricken with ALS at 27, started
living-with-ALS and started a group to agitate for change in the Medicare laws
regarding homebound people. You may be thinking, “I don’t have the personality
for a major undertaking.“ Advocacy
takes many forms, large and small. For example, I shared what I learned from my
successful insurance battle with the MDA ALS News magazine.
Sometimes ALS can wake up
talents you didn’t know you had. In my case, it was poetry. I started writing
poetry about my reaction to ALS, as well as political poetry and sending it to
friends. One friend with connections finagled an article about me, ALS, and my
political poetry in my county’s section of the New York Times. That article
described ALS, and I’m sure helped raise awareness of ALS. Another article in
Neurology Now included some of my ALS poetry. The doctor who wrote it said my
poems gave her a new appreciation of the patient’s perspective. While I can’t
speak for all PALS, I know that there are many who share my optimistic
perspective. Since the magazine is distributed to every neurology office, I hope
my upbeat poems will be helpful to people afflicted with neurological diseases.
I use these examples from my life, not to toot my own horn, but because I know
them and to show one little person can make a difference.
Advocating for
yourself
Sooner or later, you will
find yourself in need of services your insurance company denies. Don’t take no
for an answer! Most insurance companies know that many people will not appeal a
denied claim. Have your doctor write a letter of medical necessity that explains
why you need the service. Notes from other health professionals can also help.
Demand that your insurance company gives you a letter of explanation for the
decision, not a cryptic code. Read your policy. Consult the social worker at
your ALS center, or if the stakes are high, hire a lawyer. MDA, ALSA, or the
local bar association can recommend one. Put everything in writing and send it
return receipt requested so you have a paper trail. If you speak to anyone from
your insurance company, get their names and make notes and date the
conversation. You’re not allowed to record the conversation without permission
from the other party. The insurance company is usually your enemy, but sometimes
you can sweet talk someone into giving you more information. I don’t know much about
Medicare or Medicaid.I assume that the same principles apply to these. There are, of course,
other reasons than insurance for which you might need to advocate for yourself.
Sometimes well-meaning caregivers or family members want to make decisions for
you. Your mind still works, and you should have as much control over decisions
affecting your care as you desire.
Advocating for a
fellow PALS
You can put your skills,
experience and knowledge to work to help a fellow PALS. Over the years, I have
helped several PALS, mostly by email. I have also written about what I have
learned in my ALS center’s newsletter. Every time you post something in
living-with-ALS you are making a fellow PALS’ life easier. As a newly diagnosed
PALS, you may have the energy and voice to help a more advanced PALS. For
example, you might organize a Share the Care group for someone in your local
support group.
Cause advocacy
Advocating for a specific
cause can be as easy as forwarding email you receive from a group supporting
that cause to everyone you know. For example, before the Senate vote on the stem
cell research bill in July 2006, I forwarded the United Spinal Association’s
email urging me to contact my senators to vote yes to family and friends. And I
emailed my senators. Sometimes you have to
write your own cause letter. The trick is to make it easy for your friends to
take action. This may include providing talking points, phone numbers or email
addresses. In June 2005 after the House of Representatives passed the stem cell
research bill, I emailed friends to put pressure on those representatives who
voted against it to change their minds. Here is an excerpt from my email.
Thank you for your help in
passing the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act. The House of Representatives
passed the bill 238-194, with 14 Democrats and 180 Republicans voting against
it. The Senate is expected to pass a similar bill soon. The sponsor of the
Senate bill, Republican Arlen Specter, says he has enough votes to override a
presidential veto. Bush said he will veto it when the bill reaches his desk. He
is obviously out of tune with most Americans, since a recent poll indicated only
28% of the people oppose embryonic stem cell research for therapeutic purposes.
Bush has little to lose by vetoing this bill because he is a second term
president. But the Representatives will have to defend their votes on this issue
in the 2006 elections. It takes a two-thirds majority to override a presidential
veto. Therefore, we should focus our efforts on the representatives who voted
against this bill or who did not vote. To see how your representative and others
voted go to
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/25/politics/25stem_rollcall.html
For convenience, I am including
the text of this article at the end of this email. . if you know people in
states with a large percentage of no votes, please consider forwarding this to
them.
To find out who your
representative (or any representative) is and how to contact him/her go to
http://www.house.gov/writerep/
[roll call vote by state
included]
Whether or not you agree with
me on stem cell research, the principles of cause advocacy are the same.
-
Be specific about
what you want your audience to do.
-
Provide
information on the topic, perhaps including talking points.
-
Provide contact
information for the people you want them to contact, or an easy way of getting
the information.
Organization advocacy
There are many groups that
raise money for ALS research or services, or raise awareness of ALS. These
include, but are not limited to, Muscular Dystrophy Association (MDA), ALS
Association (ALSA), ALS Therapy Development Foundation (ALS-TDF), Ride for Life,
ALS March of Faces, United Spinal Association, and your local ALS center. The
first two organizations have many local chapters which may hold fund raising
events such as walks, bike rides, dinners and golf outings. Some other
organizations, such as the Stamford, CT Fire Department, raise money for one of
the organizations in the first list. If you want to get involved, there are many
organizations and activities. If you’re not on the mailing list or email list
for these organizations, they will welcome your participation.
Your involvement can be as
simple as wearing a blue and white pin striped ribbon, to participating in an
event, being on the organizing committee for an event, or organizing your own
event. Fund raising is a good way to involve family, friends, colleagues and
your employer who often want to do something for you, but don’t know what. Time
for a personal story. I have always been reluctant to ask friends for
contributions. My cousin has been doing the ALSA bike ride in Boston along with
her husband and several co-workers who don’t even know me for several years.
This year they had only raised $350 towards their goal of $750. She asked me to
contact my friends for help. I figured if she could ask people who don’t know me
to ride and contribute, I could certainly ask my friends. The response was
phenomenal. We raised over $2000!
Working on the organizing
committee of a major organization, such as MDA, for a fund raising or an
awareness event has the benefit that the organization provides most of the
structure. When I worked on the organizing committee of a local MDA fund raiser,
they provided the solicitation letter, which I personalized.
If you want to organize your
own event, it is wise to recruit family and friends to help. Such events always
take more effort than anticipated. Alternatively, if you know someone who wants
to organize an event, you can let her/him be in the driver’s seat and help as
you can. Several years ago, one of my daughters organized a folk music concert
to benefit ALS-TDF and raised about $5000. ALS-TDF has family funds which are a
good way to honor a PALS and track your fund raising for the organization.
Try to attend the event, if possible. It helps to put a face on ALSWhatever form your
organizational advocacy takes, remember it is much easier to get businesses to
donate goods and services than money. It is not only a donation. It’s free
advertising.
Your life as a model
for advocacy
Finally, your advocacy
activities can inspire people with and without ALS to become advocates. Thus,
your own advocacy has a multiplier effect.
Conclusion
This chapter has
described some of the ways you can put your skills and experience to work to
become an advocate for PALS, including yourself. Advocacy can take as much or
little of your time and effort as you desire. The types of advocacy described
here are:
- Advocating for
yourself
- Advocating for a
fellow PALS
- Cause advocacy
- Organization
advocacy
- Your life as a model
for advocacy
EIGHT RULES TO GET WHAT YOUNEED
By Danny Dandignac
Danny
was Dx'd 12/2000. He retired from being a paramedic in 12/2004 after 23 years.
Currently he spends his time co-hosting the MDAchats
that are held 4 days a week and continuing the Will Hubben ResearchDigest hosted on the ALSTDF website. He is married with 2 children, ages 12 and
15. He has brought our attention to a very useful article.Bob’s friend Jason
doesn’t have ALS, but he faced a problem all too familiar to many who do: an
insurance company ruled that equipment he needed was “not medically necessary.”
Sound familiar?Jason might have started
fighting back by talking to his doctor first. His doctor may be as disagreeable
and rushed as Jason pictures him. Moreover, his doctor may work for the very HMO
that turned him down. But his doctor has a professional stake in preserving
Jason’s shoulders—and in seeing that his prescriptions are filled as written.When I picked up the
phone, Jason sounded desperate. Jason has cerebral palsy and has always walked
by leaning heavily on two canes. As a result of decades of wear and tear, he
developed severe arthritis and rotator-cuff tears in both shoulders. Most days
it’s hard for him to cross the room because of excruciating pain.His doctor told him the
pain and muscle tears were going to get worse—that rotator-cuff and
shoulder-replacement surgeries were on the horizon—unless he got a power
wheelchair. Although Jason’s doctor had sent the proper paperwork to his
insurance company, a Medicare HMO, the wheelchair was denied because it was “not
medically necessary.”“Not medically
necessary?” Jason screeched into the phone. “When will it be medically
necessary? When I can’t walk at all?”Sadly, the answer is
yes. But I’m getting ahead of the story. Because Jason’s speech is hard to
understand, he asked me to call the insurance company. In the process I
discovered that there are Eight Simple Rules for getting anything you need from
anyone.
Rule #1: Get Name,
Rank, and Phone Number
I called Jason’s
insurance company. After spending a turtle’s lifetime on hold, I was connected
to a customer representative. I tried to explain my friend’s circumstance, but
she said she couldn’t talk to me because I wasn’t “the insured” and hung up.I was massively ticked!
Back on the phone, and after another turtle’s lifetime, I was connected to a
different representative. This time I said that I was Jason and wrote down her
name, phone number, and title. All she did was repeat what Jason knew—that the
wheelchair was denied because it was not medically necessary. With an edge in my
voice I asked who made that decision. She told me that she was not allowed to
give out that information. I asked who could. She said that I would have to
speak to her supervisor, Ms. Lemon, and that she would transfer me. Before she
did, I got Ms. Lemon’s phone number—and good thing! I wasn’t transferred; I was
disconnected.
Rule #2: First Do
Your Homework
Since it was 5:00 p.m.,
I decided to do some research first and call Ms. Lemon the next day. On the
Internet I found the Medicare regulation for power-wheelchair medical necessity.It turns out that a
power chair is considered medically necessary only if you’re “bed or chair
confined,” not Jason’s situation—yet. I then got the name and phone number of
the president of Jason’s insurance company and went to the Web sites for the
Department of Health and the Insurance Commission in Jason’s state to find out
what process insurance companies must follow if they deny medical equipment. I
also decided I would keep dated notes of my phone conversations and take exact
quotes.
Rule #3: An Ally Is
Better Than an Adversary
At 9:01 the next morning
I called Ms. Lemon. Instead of screaming as I wanted to, I decided to take a
different tack: I started by saying, “Ms. Lemon, you are the only one who can
help me.” I told her that two of her representatives had hung up on me (hoping a
little guilt would soften her up) and explained the situation. She apologized. I
told her I needed to know who had denied the power chair. Pleasant as you
please, she volunteered that she had denied the chair. Aha! I had her! Victory
was mine. My homework had uncovered that this state’s law permits only a
physician to deny medical equipment.When I told her this,
she stammered and said she was sure that one of the medical directors, a
physician, had ultimately signed her denial. When I asked for the medical
director’s name and phone number, she said she was not allowed to give out that
information. However, she said she’d transfer me and (you know what’s coming) I
was disconnected.
Rule #4: Go Right
to the Top!
It was clear I was
getting nowhere talking to the hired help. So my next call was to the president
of the insurance company—let’s call him “Robert Bucks”. Of course I didn’t get
Mr. Bucks on the phone; I got one of his personal assistants. Starting again
with “You are the only one who can help me,” I quickly explained the hang-ups,
the denial by a clerical worker, and the refusal to let me talk to the medical
director.The assistant sounded
both shocked and concerned. He apologized and confirmed that indeed only a
medical director can deny a power chair and gave me the name and number of the
medical director assigned to the case.
Rule #5: Be a Name
Dropper
I immediately called the
medical director’s office and got his secretary. I asked to speak to the doctor
and was told that “insureds” were not allowed to speak to medical directors and
how had I gotten the number? I said that I had just spoken to “Bob” Bucks, and
was told to call the doctor directly. Implying that “my buddy Bob” told me to
call got me through to the medical director in a flash.The doctor explained
that he had indeed signed the denial based on the Medicare regulation that
required someone to have “severe weakness” in the arms, be unable to push a
manual chair, and be “bed or chair confined” before a power chair could be
approved.Still speaking as Jason,
I told him that my arms might not yet be severely weak, but that severe shoulder
pain prevented me from pushing a manual chair and that shoulder degeneration
would soon make me bed- or chair-confined if I kept on as I was. With the
Medicare regulation in front of me, I then quoted another paragraph which said
that “a patient who uses a power wheelchair is usually totally non-ambulatory.”
I suggested that the word “usually” gave him some leeway, since it means not
everyone who gets a power chair is totally unable to walk.To my amazement the
doctor listened! He agreed the shoulders would just get worse and that I would
eventually be chair or bed confined. “Tell your doctor to write a new
prescription and an appeal letter explaining that your shoulders are falling
apart, that you can’t push a manual wheelchair and soon won’t be able to walk,”
he said. “I can argue that it would be better to give you the power chair sooner
rather than later and save your shoulders.”
Rule #6: Tell,
Don’t Ask
Ecstatic, I called
Jason. I explained that his doctor only had to send a prescription, write a
letter, and the power wheelchair was his. But Jason hemmed and hawed. He said
his doctor was very busy and hadn’t liked filling out the insurance forms for
the power chair in the first place. I told Jason he needed to advocate for
himself. I told him he needed not to ask but to tell his doctor—quietly but
firmly—that he “was the only person who could help” and to write that letter.
Indeed, Jason’s doctor was not happy, but write a letter he did.Within two weeks the
power wheelchair was approved. I was king of the world ... until Jason called me
a month later.
Rule #7: Call in
the Marines!
Jason told me that he
was greeted one morning by a truck driver with a huge box. Inside was the
promised power chair. Jason’s excitement gave way to confusion and anger when he
discovered the wheelchair was twice as wide as he was. I asked him how this
could have happened when he had been fitted for the chair. Jason told me the
delivery was a total surprise because he had never been fitted.I immediately called the
medical director to find out what had gone wrong. The doctor coolly explained
that the insurance company provides only one type of power wheelchair from only
one manufacturer. When I told him the chair had never been fitted and was too
wide, the doctor’s response was as simple as it was final: “We had a doctor’s
prescription.” Click.The doctor’s answer was
not only ridiculous, it smelled way bad. Why would an insurance company provide
only one type of power wheelchair that was drop-shipped from another state
without being fitted?I called Jason’s state
insurance commissioner and was told that insurance companies cannot provide only
one brand of wheelchair, that wheelchairs are indeed custom items that must be
fitted. I was referred to the state department of health’s office responsible
for overseeing HMOs. And I heard the same thing. For good measure I called the
state attorney general’s office. What the insurance company was doing smelled
bad to everybody. And, since this was a Medicare issue, I called Jason’s
congressman too.Turned out that the
insurance company and the wheelchair manufacturer were under federal
investigation for—guess what?—a kickback scheme involving payoffs by the
wheelchair maker to the insurance firm.I once again called my
buddy the medical director. I told him about all the offices I had just called
and—my voice calm and even—explained that everyone believed that his insurance
company was involved in a kickback scheme with the wheelchair manufacturer that
broke bushels of state and federal laws. I told him that it wasn’t my idea to
testify against him in court or to speak at a television press conference, but
that I’d do what the attorney general asked if it would get me a usable power
chair.
Rule #8: One White
Lie May Be Worth a Thousand Truths
Of course, no one I
talked to had mentioned testifying in court or a TV press conference. But the
medical director didn’t know that, and there was no way that he was going to
find out. What was he going to do, call the attorney general and ask if he was
going to be indicted? Which is why I heard the doctor’s voice raise an octave.
“No, no, no! “he said. “You must have misunderstood me.”He quickly explained
that the brand of wheelchair that was shipped was the company’s first choice,
not the only choice, and that of course every patient’s wheelchair should be
individually fitted. He told me that the insurance company would arrange for the
chair to be returned, that a local vendor would be in contact, and that any
brand of power chair that met my needs would be provided.True to his word, within
a week the offending wheelchair had been removed and Jason was fitted for a
chair that met his needs. Jason and his shoulders are now happily rolling along.God
Bless Alexander Graham BellSince helping Jason, I
have told others about “The Eight Simple Rules” and how they have proved helpful
in dealing with everything from refusals by employers to provide reasonable
accommodations under the ADA to reversing denials for Social Security disability
benefits.The phone can be a
powerful weapon. Don’t be afraid to call anyone and everyone who could possibly
help you. State officials, congresspersons, and senators. Elected officials love
to help their constituents (read: voters).Sometimes, however, the
pen can be mightier than the phone. You can file official complaints under the
ADA, state civil rights and consumer laws with your state’s insurance
commissioner and with the attorney general. Ultimately, you may need a lawyer
specializing in disability or consumer issues if it’s time to lock and load and
take the bums to court.But if you follow “The
Eight Simple Rules”, you may get what you need without paperwork or lawsuits by
doing your homework, being pleasant but assertive, using your wits, and using
Alexander Graham Bell’s marvelous invention.
TIPS AND INFORMATION ON ADVOCACY
By David Abell
David was
diagnosed with ALS in June 1996. He was 29 and serving in the US Navy when he
was diagnosed. He has adapted to being paralyzed, ventilator dependent, fed
through a feeding tube. His attitude is “Iwill never give up.”He rarely
feels sad and has discovered numerous, meaningful ways to enrich his life.Advocacy & Awareness are important in getting funding for research andcare for ALS. Some great advocates groups for ALS areThe March of Faces
http://march-of-faces.org/
Project ALS
http://projectals.org/
Ride For Life
http://www.rideforlife.com/
There are many others but
these are my favorites.
It is up to all of us to raise awareness if possible. When friendsask if there is anything they can do, ask them to write a letter totheir Congressperson & Senators. (see below) Check the www.ALSA.orgwww.MDA.org or NORD
http://www.rarediseases.org/
for sample lettersthat you can modify for personal info. If you believe in stem cellresearch www.stemcellaction.org and
http://www.curesnow.org/ havepetitions to sign and sample letters.
Write to your congressperson. It's hard to represent you properly ifthe congressperson isn't aware of your feelings.
Select your state or territory and enter your ZIP code. You'll be givena form that will be sent directly to your representative.
If you want to contact your senator, go here:
http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm
And to contact members of the House, go here:
http://www.house.gov/writerep/
This website has tips on How to write your congressperson.
http://www.protest.net/activists_handbook/write.html
Writing a real letter or fax will not get ignored as easily as Emailbut it takes a long time for a response especially since the anthraxidiot. I do both sometimes.Anyway, there are some ideas. We can make a difference.
Thoughts on Advocacy
By Chuck Hummer
Chuck retiredas a
senior executive with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in Washington, D.C., in
1989, culminating a thirtyyear career as a government worker.He was diagnosed
withALS in October 2004, after a three yearjourney to determine why he was
falling and experiencing slurred speech.He and his wife, Sandra, live in
Pinellas Park, Florida.Advocacy is defined as
the act of pleading or arguing in favor of something, such as a cause, idea, or
policy; active support.How does this apply to ALS?In the strictest sense,
advocacy is often limited to a type of lobbying, or seeking legislation to
provide for some service or rights.In the broadest sense, I take it to mean
speaking out and up to assure public awareness of the disease called ALS.Without this basic understanding of what ALS is, how it affects those who have
been diagnosed with ALS and the sorry fact that no one knows the cause or
causes, there are no real pharmaceutical therapies to treat the disease, and
there is no cure.Unless and until we get
that message out to the broadest possible audience, including health care
workers, politicians and even our own families and friends, it seems futile to
think that we can plead or argue for any relief from the disease.In short,
education seems to be a first crucial step to advocating for those of us with
ALS.At first, this seems pretty elementary and an objective easily achieved.But if my case is typical, then it grossly underestimates the existing ignorance
about ALS or Lou Gehrig’s disease.I had heard of it, and in fact an uncle had
it and died from it.When I was diagnosed, I
suddenly learned a great deal about this disease and the gloomy prognosis for
those so afflicted.Once that sunk in, it inspired me and my wife to learn all
we could and to tell as many people as would listen that I had an incurable
terminal illness that would likely take my life in a short period of time.No
cure, no effective medicines, no confirmatory diagnostic test or tests, all of
this came as an incredible shock and led us to think, just what we can do to
learn to live with this disease and somehow stimulate the search for effective
therapies and a cure.That is when advocacy suddenly came into clear and
distinct focus for us.We had to help get the word out, the public educated and
the research community put on a fast track.It came as another shock to learn
that there is no national database of ALS patients.Without this crucial basis
on which to seek funds for therapies and a cure we were simply bouncing around
in a very dim room without much hope for an early resolution to the seemingly
endless ignorance that surrounded the disease that I now had, was dying from, my
body shutting down the use oflimbs,
speech, breathing.I was encouraged when ALSA made the National ALS Registry
one of its key legislative goals.And so it seems that the
first order of business is to educate using every avenue available, educate as
to the lack of a diagnostic test or tests, no effective therapies and certainly
no cure, nor the hope for one on the horizon.Because unless we make major
inroads on the ignorance about ALS, it seems any effort to inspire research, or
for legislation to fund increased research would be a whisper in the hurricane
of all the diseases for which cures and therapies are being sought.Now the sad fact is that
those of us with ALS don’t stay around long enough to build an effective voice
made up entirely of the afflicted.In the U.S. it is estimated that there are
no more than 30,000 people with ALS at any one time.Of those, more than likely
only a quarter or less than 10,000 are healthy enough or still have the ability
to do much more than try to deal with the rapid progression of the disease.That is not a large constituency by any means, and without any cure on the
horizon these numbers are not likely to change much.About as many die from the
disease as are diagnosed.Remember what advocacy
is, it is arguing or soliciting aid and if there are not sufficient numbers of
people with ALS to constitute an effective voice what avenues are open to us.I
think that the answer lies in those who care for us, those who are family,
friends, and acquaintances, colleagues in the work place or faith community.These are the groups that can be large enough to have sufficient voice and
volume to speak on our behalf.If one looks that those involved with the
national organizations that have grown to represent us, you will find that many
have had their lives touched by a loved one with ALS or a coworker, or friend.Thank God for that, because we PALS are a pretty anemic group if counted on our
own.Awareness, education,
appreciation, all of these must be our goal and those who we hope will advocate
for us.While we are healthy enough to speak on own behalf, we must do so, but
we must also enlarge the community around us to achieve a noise level that will
be heard when we ask for more research, for better patient care and services,
accessibility as our mobility spirals downward.We, the PALS, have to be at the
center of this effort because it is a life and death challenge for us.But we
must also grow the community around us through education, to become an effective
voice for us with enough depth and volume to make our needs heard in all the
places where action must be taken on our behalf if we are ever to realize our
hope for better therapies, therapies that will bring ALS into the community of
chronic but treatable illnesses and finally, one day, a cure.
How do we do this?I think that it requires a
multifaceted approach, but that approach needs some healthy but vocal PALS at
its center. Awareness events such as the ALSA Walk to Dfeet ALS, the Ride for
Life, Faces of Courage, and the many other public initiatives are an essential
part of this awareness effort. Seeking celebrity spokespersons, maximum
exposure and use of all aspects of the media are vital parts to this campaign.We need to use the national organizations that represent us to be our advocates
and wemust be our own advocates to
keep the rest of the advocates heading in the right direction with enough
passion and vigor to make a difference.I found that participating in the
annual ALSA Advocacy Day and Public Policy Conference has all sorts of good
results.It allows our advocates to network and in doing so become a
harmonized chorus, rather than a bunch of distinct weak voices each singing
in isolation.It also brought the face of ALS and our needs to our
legislators.Some states have set up similar events to interface with
their state legislators. It remains that the true strength comes from those
who care for us.Their lives have been touched on a very personal
level, and they willround to keep advocating on behalf long after we have gone.If their voices
become strong enough, then maybe we will see therapies come along that will
extend the lives of PALS significantly and we can break above that 30,000
ceiling that has plagued us for so long.Simply stated, each of us
has to be our own advocates arguing on our own behalf, but we need to be active
in growing and extending the advocacy communities made up of our family, friends
and coworkers, the researchers and service organization volunteers and staffs
that work for us.It isn’t going to work if we shrink into our own lonely
little space and do not reach out to others and continuously make that group of
others larger and larger, better organized and educated, to carry the message of
awareness and education that will make advocacy work for better times for all
PALS.
A Letter to Advocate for
Greater Research for ALS
By Randy Roberts
I wrote
this letter some time ago to draw attention to the fact that ALS
isunder-funded compared to other diseases. It has been
modified from the original.Dear Senator/Congressman,I am writing this letter
to bring to your attention to the fact that ALS (Lou Gehrig’s Disease), an
illness that receives far too little publicity in view of its devastating impact
on the lives of so many Americans, is under-funded by NIH (FY 05) when compared
to other diseases and to ask for your help. But first, a few words about this
disease. ALS attacks the motor neurons (nerves) that send commands and nourish
muscles. As the neurons die, the muscles that they support weaken and atrophy.
Although the disease can progress in different ways, a typical scenario is for a
limb to weaken first, and then spread to other limbs, rendering the body
paralyzed. Over time it progresses to muscles controlling speech, swallowing and
finally breathing itself.While ALS ravages the
body, it generally leaves the mind intact, so patients are fully aware of what
is happening to them. One patient who wrote about his experience with ALS said
"With keen mind and open eyes We watch ourselves die “.
In a testimony to the human spirit, many ALS patients manage to rise above
their suffering and continue to find meaning in their lives up to the end. ALS
is not an inherited disease: (95%) of all cases do not have a family history of
ALS. And it is not nearly so rare as people think, i.e., it is diagnosed about
2/3 the frequency ofMS (Multiple Sclerosis), a much more recognized illness.
It can strike at any age from the 20’s thru the 70’s (Lou Gehrig himself was
diagnosed at age 36) but tends to peak in late middle age. There is no
effective therapeutic agent against ALS and no understanding of causation.
Nobody is safe from this killer.MS seems to offer a
reasonable standard of comparison as it has about the roughly similar incidence
as ALS (10,000 new cases per year for MS vs. 6000-7000 for ALS). There are
approximately 400,000 people in theUS living with MS vs. about 30,000 with
ALS. Why the difference in prevalence if the diseases have a somewhat similar
incidence rate? The major factor is lethality. MS patients live a normal life
span while, as mentioned earlier, while ALS patients have a much shorter life
span. If ALS were not such an effective killer, its prevalence rate would
obviously be much higher.It seems reasonable that the two diseases should
have nearly equal public funding, since they both occur with the similar
frequency, but this is not the case.NIH budgets $110 million on MS research
but $41 m on ALS.It is immoral to base funding on prevalence in the context of
similar incidence rates, thereby penalizing ALS patients for the lethality of
their diseaseThe next disease for
comparison is Huntington’s disease, another disorder caused by degeneration of
brain cells, i.e. neurons, in certain areas of the brain. This degeneration
causes uncontrolled movements,loss of
intellectual faculties, and emotional disturbance. HD is a fully inherited
disease, passed from parent to child through a mutation in a certain gene. Its
incidence and prevalence rate are much lower than ALS and patients usually live
10-25 years after diagnosis. Yet, this disease has an NIH budget of $48m vs. $41
m for ALS.For the, 3rd and final
comparison, I will move from diseases involving neuron damage to one caused by a
viral infection, HIV/AIDS. This illness has a large incidence (85,000) and
prevalence (1,100,000) but thanks to advances in treatment, mortality has been
significantly reduced. The number of patients who die from this disease each
year is only about a bit more than twice the number of ALS deaths, yet HIV/AIDS
has a research budget of nearly $3b vs. $41m for ALS.CONCLUSION I: Given
itsincidence rates and high lethality, ALS is woefully under-funded compared
to other diseasesand this may explain, at least inpart, why so little has
been learned about this disease since Lou Gehrig’s death 65 years ago and why
there have been no significant advances in treatment. It does not get the
recognition it deserves because its high lethality severely limits the number of
Americans who are living with the disease at any one point in time.
RECOMMENDATION I:The NIH budget for ALS research should be immediately increased to $110m or roughly
the same amount as MS.A second issue I wish to
address is the fact that the low prevalence rate of ALS, due to its high
lethality, does not provide any incentive for major pharmaceutical companies to
search for a cure.The only drug for ALS, Rilutek, about 15 years old now,
extends life only 2-3 months, is used by many patients at high cost, yet the
maker of the drug, Aventis, claims that it loses substantial money on Rilutek.
MS, in comparison, with its 400,000 prevalence in the US alone, presents
significant incentive for drug companies to invest in research. In fact, there
are 5 meds that have proven very beneficial and sales are big. Avonex, for
example, had close to $1b in sales in the last year. Another drug, Copaxone, may
have the greatest potential to alter the course of MS and sales, once the issue
of side effects is resolved, should be huge. If we accept the view that it costs
the companies $800 m over 10 years to develop and bring to market a successful
drug, then about $4 billionhas been spent to produce thesedisease
mitigatingmedications, or $400 m per year, not including current research.The FDA offers an orphan
disease program to provide incentives to companies to invest in research of
diseases having a prevalence of fewer than 200,000. The program provides tax
incentives and other advantages for only small grants; unfortunately the
incentives offered are too small to interest large companies with all their
research potential.
Conclusion II:Because
of ALS’s high lethality, prevalence will always be low.As a consequence, big
pharma will not have the incentive to invest in ALS research and the high tech
power of drug companies won’t be harnessed to find new therapeutic agents in the
fight against ALS.
Recommendation II:Federal health agencies must provide the incentive to big pharma to invest in
ALS research.The FDA Orphan Disease Program must be substantially increased to
accomplish this.$80m per year in incentives must be allotted to get major
companies interested in working on this research.Funding could include a
combination of grants, tax credits and exclusive marketing rights, etc.The
grants could be reduced as companies come closer to marketing the new agents.
Under-funding of ALS will
not be righted without your active intervention. I am askingfor your help on behalf
of boththe 30,000+ Americans living with the disease today and the estimated
70,000 who will die every 10 years until a cure is found. ALS has been neglected
far too long.
Thank you for your
interest. We and our families are counting on you.
Randy RobertsPerson with ALS,
diagnosed 4/04
A FINAL WORD ON ADVOCACY
Our numbers are small,
our voices are too weak to be above the din, wecannot “act up” like the early
AIDS activists and we have no famous person to champion our cause.But we must
try to keep public awareness on ALS and help raise funds for research. This
chapter has shown you some ways. Use your energy and creativity to help us in
this fight.
CHAPTER 8
MATERIALS AND RESOURCES
AVAILABLE AT NO CHARGE
By Catherine Wolf
Introduction
Many organizations offer
free stuff, grants and/or services to people with ALS and their families. As a
newly diagnosed PALS, you’re probably overwhelmed by the challenges ahead. This
chapter puts in one place information about free stuff, grants and services that
can make your life easier and save you money. The conditions that apply, if any,
and how to contact the organization are included here. There may be other
organizations offering services to PALS. These are the ones we know about.
Muscular Dystrophy
Association (MDA)MDA services are
administered by the local offices. To find your local office, go to
http://www.mdausa.org/.
To receive services, you must register with the
local office, but registration is free.
Financial benefits.
These apply after all insurance has
been paid.
-
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of wheelchairs or leg braces every five years. This benefit may be used
for wheelchair upgrades.
-
Up to $500 annually for
wheelchair repairs.
-
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of augmentative communication devices. This is a one time benefit.
Other services and
free stuff
-
One physical, occupational, and
speech therapy evaluation per year
-
Annual flu shot
-
Transportation to MDA clinics
-
Loan closet containing items
such as wheelchairs, hoyer lifts, hospital beds, commodes, etc
-
Research updates, informative
publications (MDA ALS News Magazine, Quest), resources & referrals, web site
-
Support groups for
Pals, Caregivers and Family
ALS Association (ALSA)ALSA is organized
differently from MDA. Each local chapter decides what services to offer. To find
your local chapter, go to
Welcome - The ALS Association.To receive services, you must register with your local chapter, but
registration is free. I will use the services of the Greater New York
chapter as an example. But please contact your local chapter since services
and eligibility are sure to differ.
Loan of
augmentative communication devices. To qualify, you must have no
functional speech. Also, you must be in the process of applying for coverage
of such a device by your insurance, have no insurance coverage for such
devices, or have no insurance.Listening library.
Loan of books on CD or tape by mail to PALS who can no longer hold a book or
turn pages easily. Check your local library for loan of audio books. The
Library of Congress offers audio books by mail, -
www.loc.gov/nls. The New York chapter
lists a variety of nationally available sources of audio books. Go to
http://www.als-ny.org/ and click on Patient Services, then Patient and
Family Programs, then Listening Library. Loan closet
with similar items to MDA loan closet. To qualify, the equipment must be
recommended by a health professional and you must be in theprocess of applying for coverage of the equipment by your insurance,
have no insurance coverage for the equipment, or have no insurance.Transportation to
ALSA clinics and support groups. To be eligible, you must have no other
way of getting there.Home visits by
nurses, social workers and assistive technology specialists Support groups
for PALS, caregivers and family Your local chapter
can provide referrals and the national website has educational materials and
publications, see
Welcome - The ALS
Association and click Resources and Patient, Family, Caregivers
Ride for Life
Ride for Life is an
awareness and fund raising organization whose main event is a ride for PALS in
their wheelchairs in the New York area. Financial benefits
-
Respite care grants. Ride for
Life periodically offers a limited number of Care for Life grants of up to $1500
for the purpose of giving your caregiver a break. See
http://www.rideforlife.com/
-
Legal grants. A limited number
of grants of up to $750 are periodically offered for legal expenses such as
wills, dealing with insurance companies, and applying for disability benefits
under the Plan for Life program.
-
While not a direct benefit to
you, when you enter certain online stores from
http://www.rideforlife.com/, Ride for Life gets a percentage of the purchase
price.
Other services and
free stuff
-
Information, educational
materials on the web site
United Spinal
Association Membership in the United
Spinal Association is open to people with spinal cord injuries or diseases that
affect the spinal cord, including ALS. See the web site at
http://unitedspinal.org/
.Although this organization is not well known in ALS community, it provides
valuable services to PALS. To receive services, you must join the organization,
but membership is free. United Spinal is headquartered in Jackson Heights, NY
with several regional offices.
Financial benefits
-
Under the Wheelchair Medic
program, you get a 10% discount on the price of wheelchairs and scooters and 15%
off on parts. See
http://www.wheelchairmedic.com/
-
Low income members can get up to
$5000 for accessibility modifications to the home. See
http://www.unitedspinal.org/publications/action/2006/03/24/affording-accessibility-home-modifications/
-
Low income members may qualify
for grants for assistive technology and automobile refits. Call : 800-404-2898
or email
Other services and
free stuff
For a more complete
description of services see
http://www.unitedspinal.org/how-we-serve/1.ABLE to Travel is full service
travel agency that can arrange accessible transportation to and from the
airport, book flights, arrange accessible
accommodations, give information on access to medical equipment, and answer your
questions about wheelchair and disability travel. See
http://www.abletotravel.org/
2.Personalized consultations with experts in the areas
of
-
Accessibility Rights
-
Benefits Counseling
-
Social Services
-
Adaptive Sports & Recreation
-
Self Advocacy
-
Legislative Issues
-
Healthcare & Service Locating
-
Peer Counseling
-
Spinal Cord Issues
-
Veterans Benefits
-
Accessible Travel
-
Wheelchairs & Assistive
Technology
-
Design of accessible home
modifications
3.Special services for veterans under the
VetsFirst program
4.Educational materials and excellent ACTION
Online magazine,
Conclusion
You are not alone in your
fight against ALS. These organizations and others are ready to help you in a
myriad of ways. This information is accurate to the best of our
abilities.
CHAPTER 9
RESEARCH
Some PALS and CALS are
interested in learning about developments in ALS research and in looking beyond
the surface of the latest headline finding displayed on websites. Because PALS
and CALS are not familiar with the technical terms, I (RR)have supplied some
simple definitions taken from ALSA’s website and other sources which will make
the article that follows easier to read.Amino
Acids: They are the building blocks of proteins.Blood Brain Barrier
(BBB):A protective barrier formed
by the blood vessels and glia of the brain. It prevents some substances in the
blood from entering brain tissue.Central Nervous System
(CNS): The brain and spinal cord
combined.Embryonic Stem Cells:Embryonic stem cells are the "blank slates" of an organism, capable of
developing into all types of tissue in the body. Gene:Genes are the basic biological units of
heredity. They are composed of DNA.
Glutamate:Glutamate is one of the most common amino acids found in nature. It is the main
component of many proteins, and is present in most tissues. Glutamate is also
produced in the body and plays an essential role in human metabolism. It is a
primary excitatory neurotransmitter in the human CNS. L-glutamate is present at
a majority of synapses. Over-stimulation of these same receptors is thought to
trigger the neuronal damage associated with a wide variety of neurological
insults and diseases, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), lathyrisms,
and Alzheimer's disease.Glutamate
toxicity:Toxicity resulting from excess glutamated synapse.
Mutation:A
permanent change, a structural alteration, in the DNA or RNA. Mutations can be
caused by many factors including environmental insults such as radiation and
mutagenic chemicals. Mutations are sometimes attributed to random chance events.
Neuron:Neurons are the nerve cells which make up the central nervous system. They
consist of a nucleus, a single axon which conveys electrical signals to other
neurons and a host of dendrites which deliver incoming signals.
Neurotransmitters:Chemical substances that carry
impulses from one nerve cell to another; found in the space (synapse) that
separates the transmitting neuron's terminal (axon) from the receiving neuron's
terminal (dendrite).
Protein:Proteins are large molecules required for the structure, function, and
regulation of the body's cells, tissues, and organs. Each protein has unique
functions. Proteins are essential components of muscles, skin, bones and the
body as a whole. Protein is also one of the three types of nutrients used as
energy sources by the body.
RNA:
A
long-chain, usually single-stranded. The primary function of RNA is protein
synthesis within a cell. However, RNA is involved in various ways in the
processes of expression and repression of hereditary information. The three main
functionally distinct varieties of RNA molecules are: (1) messenger RNA (mRNA)
which is involved in the transmission of DNA information, (2) ribosomal RNA
(rRNA) which makes up the physical machinery of the synthetic process, and (3)
transfer RNA (tRNA) which also constitutes another functional part of the
machinery of protein synthesis.
Stem Cells:Cells that can differentiate into many different cell types when subjected to
the right biochemical signals. Stem cells are a promising new therapeutic
approach to treating CNS disorder. The most versatile stem cells, called
pluripotent stem cells, are present in the first days after an egg is fertilized
by sperm. Researchers believe they can coax stem cells to become whatever
tissues patients need. Stem cells come from embryos, bone marrow and umbilical
chords.
Superoxide Dismutase:An enzyme that destroys
superoxide. One form of the enzyme contains manganese and another contains zinc.
Superoxide is a highly reactive form of oxygen. For ALS, 20% of the total
patient population has mutations in the gene for copper/zinc superoxide
dismutase type SOD1. SOD1 normally breaks down free radicals, but mutant SOD1 is
unable to perform this function.
Synapse:A
tiny gap between the ends of nerve fibers across which nerve impulses pass from
one neuron to another; at the synapse, an impulse causes the release of a
neurotransmitter, which diffuses across the gap and triggers an electrical
impulse in the next neuron.
Toxin:A
poisonous substance of animal or plant origin.
Transgenic:An
organism whose sperm or egg contains genetic material originally derived from an
organism other than the parents or in addition to the parental genetic material.
RESEARCH OVERVIEW
By Wayne Gimlin
Wayne is 39 years old and
is an aerospace engineer.He is married with 3 kids.In Fall 2002, the ALS
clinic said that he had motor neuron disease with uppermotor neuron symptoms.They changed the "official" diagnosis to PLS in2003 but won't rule out
ALS.Today in 2006, he walks very stiff with awalking stick and trips
and falls on a semi-regular basis, speakswith aslur, and has general
weakness from head to toe.However, he still worksas an engineer and
“enjoys” life.Wayne posts regularly on Brain Talk and is a frequent
contributor to ALS-TDF.The Modern Era of ALS
Research BeginsThe modern era of
research into ALS began in 1991 with the discovery of the cause of a small
subset of ALS in its familial form, namely the SOD1 gene.
http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2006-04/nu-dsa042506.phpSoon after, this same
gene was modified in mice and a paralyzing disease similar to what human ALS
occurred.By over expressing the defective SOD1 gene in mice, scientists can
cause mice to show symptoms in their legs at approximately 90 days with death
occurring from 110 to 150 days.Although other mice and rat models (e.g. the wobbler mouse) have been used when studying ALS, the SOD1 mouse has been the
mostly widely used in the last 12 years.
The First Approved
Drug
In 1995, the FDA approved
the drug Rilutek as atreatmentforALShttp://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/796_als.htmlRilutek was first
proposed as an ALS treatment in the late 1980s with Phase I and II clinical
trials meant to show safety completed in the early 90s.By 1993, two large
Phase III trials in Europe and the US evaluated the efficacy of Rilutek.These
trials divided ALS patients into placebo and treated groups and compared the
survival rate of both groups over 18 months.In both trials, there was reported
a small statistical difference between the two groups and therefore Rilutek was
determined to be marginally effective in slowing ALS.The method of action of
Rilutek is the reduction of a chemical called glutamate that is used by motor
neurons to pass signals.It is theorized that an excessive amount of glutamate
is present that damages and eventually kills a motor neuron in a process called
excitotoxicity.http://products.sanofi-aventis.us/rilutek/rilutek.htmlDue in part to the
apparent success of Rilutek, there was a flurry of specialized drugs and
treatments that were introduced to clinical trials as a potential treatment.Examples of these trials included BDNF and GDNF which were injected into the
spinal fluid with a pump and the brain with an injection port.Other
specialized drugs were developed by Sanofi and other companies that were taken
orally or injected subcutaneously or peripherally.Unfortunately, all these
drugs failed their Phase III clinical trials that were to show efficacy and have
not been approved for use for ALS.
Clinical Trials | MDA ResearchBDNFOne possible exception
was a drug called Myotrophin that passed a Phase III in the US but failed in
Europe in 1997.This drug is actually a form of the brain protein called
IGF-1.In the Myotrophin study this drug was injected subcutaneously directly
into muscles of the patients. The theory behind IGF-1 is that it acts as a way
of protecting the motor neurons from damage caused by an external agitator.Currently, Myotrophin is undergoing a trial to determine a “final” answer to the
conflicting results of the two trials from the 90s.
http://www.rideforlife.com/news/als_research/clinical_trial_of_myotrophin.htmlRecent Research into
Pre-existing Drugs
The ALS research
community is mainly comprised of university researchers and a few non-profit and
for profit companies.Due to the multiple failures of very expensive developed
drugs in the late 90s, the ALS research community focused more on the use of
existing drugs to treat ALS. The advantage of using existing drugs is that they
do not have near the development cost and if found to be effective, can be
cross-prescribed for ALS patients.Some examples of pre-existing drugs taken to
trial for ALS research are:
Pre-existing drugs taken to Phase II or
III trials.
1. Celebrex. Failed Phase III trial.
2. Creatine Failed two Phase III trials.
3. Minocycline Currently in a Phase III trial.
4. Tamoxifen Completed a Phase II trial showing safety and possible
efficacy
5. Hydroxyurea. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
6. Ritonavir. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
7. Indinavir. Failed a Phase III trial.
8. Ceftriaxone. Currently in a Phase III trial.
9. Pentoxifylline. Failed a Phase III trial.
10. Sodium Phenyl Butryate (PBA). Currently in a Phase II trial
11. R+ Pramipexole. Currently in a Phase II trial
12. Thalidomide. Currently in a Phase II trial
13. Aramiclomol. Currently in trial.
14. Others.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspxSOD1 Mouse Studies
One important point about
these drugs is that nearly all were justified to the FDA and the funding
agencies as worthy of a human clinical trial, by the successful completion of a
SOD1 mouse test.In these tests, the mice are divided between control mice and
mice given a treatment.The variables of these tests include the point in their
lifetimes that the mouse should begin treatment, the amount of dose given, and
the length of time given the dose. Further there is a question of how many mice
must be used per test and how closely related the mice must be.Ideally, a
researcher should be able to take any two sets of mice, treat them identically
and the average lifetimes of both sets should be about the same. However, there
have been questions over the results of these reportedly successful mice tests.
ALS-TDF is a non-profit ALS research company started by James Heywood in 1999 as
a response to the diagnosis of his brother Stephen with ALS in 1998.ALS-TDF
first investigated the use of stem cell and gene therapy to treat Stephen’s ALS
in the late 90s.However by 2002, ALS-TDF started large scale testing of SOD1
mice in the hope that a pre-existing drug may substantially slow the rate of ALS
progression.To their surprise, as of 2006, and after testing several thousand
mice, they have not been able to reproduce with repeatability the results
reported from other researchers’ mice tests.This includes Celebrex, Creatine,
Minocycline, Tamoxifen, PBA and others.They have been able to find small (<
10%) life extensions which prompted them to help start a Phase II trial for
Hydroxyura and Ritonavir at the University of California in San Francisco (UCSF)
but have not been able to repeat these tests with consistency. The concept of
repeatability is a basis of science and experimentation.If a small set of PALS
were divided into two groups and their rate of survival tracked, it would be
expected that the average length of survival of both sets would not be exactly
the same. The two groups’ survival might be different by a few weeks or months.
If larger and larger groups were studied it would be expected that the
difference in survival between the two sets would diminish.The same is true
for mice.If small samples of mice are chosen to be in the control and in the
treated group there is some certainty that the two groups will have different
life spans by random chance.The way of proving that the treatment and not
random sampling is the cause of the treated group outliving the control group is
by repeatability, meaning that the test can be repeated by any competent
researcher anywhere and has approximately the same results.There is a large
question on whether the tests that have been published as “successful” are
actually repeatable.Other concerns over the
use of the SOD1 mice are the fact that the mutated SOD1 protein is not present
in most PALS both those with familial and sporadic forms.This has caused much
speculation that a successful SOD1 mouse test would not translate into a
successful human clinical trial.Also there is concern over the differences
between humans and mice on how they react to different drugs.Differences in
how drugs cross the blood brain barrier could easily complicate whether a drug
that affects or doesn’t affect a mouse would have the same type of result in a
human.To date, what is lacking is what is called a “positive control”.Essentially this is a drug or treatment that has proven success in mice and
humans which can be used to gauge how other reactions in mice might affect a
human. Since the SOD1 mouse is
one of the few animal models that closely mimic ALS, researchers will continue
to use them for drug discovery. What should be asked by PALS and closely noted
is how many mice were used, how many times was the test repeated using the same
parameters, and how many different laboratories also repeated the test.Past
research has shown that many if not all of the reportedly successful mouse tests
cannot answer these questions adequately.
Causes of ALS
ALS research is hampered
by the fact that how it is caused and how it progresses is mainly unknown.Although approximately 10% of ALS cases are known to be genetic, how the damaged
genes cause ALS is still not known.Since SOD1 is a gene that produces a SOD1
protein that acts as an anti-oxidant, some have theorized that oxidation could
be a key player in ALS.However, later research has pointed more towards the
concept that these proteins could be tangled or misfolded and thereby causes
cell death. In either case, one of
the current main focuses of ALS research is identifying what genes are defective
in familial ALS and if there are similar defective genes in sporadic ALS.
Currently there are several trials sponsored by the MDA that concern
identification of genes in ALS.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspx
Researchers are also
interested in environmental factors that could cause ALS but so far, none have
been proven.Besides the root cause, researchers have focused much of their
efforts into identifying what happens in the cells that cause ALS death.This
is a large subject but some of the areas of interest are:
1. Protein Misfolding
2. Immune system and Inflammation
3. Oxidation
4. Axonal transport
5. Excess Glutamate
6. Calcium
7. Mitochrondria malfunction
Biomarkers in ALS
Other interests of ALS
research include finding markers for the disease.For many diseases,
identification of biomarkers in the blood or cerebral fluid help to both
diagnose a patient with the disease and mark the efficacy of test drugs.To
date, Dr. Robert Bowser of the University of Pittsburgh has published a
biomarker study that identifies biomarkers in the cerebral fluid but it has not
been developed for general use.
Gene Therapy Studies
The concept of using gene
therapy has been investigated for ALS. There have been two basic approaches
examined.These are synthesis of growth factors and the use of gene silencing
Synthesis of
Growth Factors - In 2003, Dr.
Fred Gage of the Robert Packard Center announced that they had significantly
extended the life of a SOD1 mouse by the use of IGF-1 gene therapy. In this
approach, an AAV-1 virus is injected into various muscles of the mice.The
virus then moves up the nerve into the lower motor neuron nucleus located in
spinal cord. There it “infects” the motor neuron and changes its DNA
structure.This allows the motor neuron to synthesize a chemical called
IGF-1 that is thought to be protective.In the 2003 announcement it was
stated that trials could begin in one year but as of 2006, no human trial
has begun.
http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/press/2003/AUGUST/030807A.HTM
Another growth factor which has been theorized
as having a potential effect is VEGF.
http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/extract/291/23/2809-c
http://www.scienceblog.com/community/older/2004/10/20049657.shtml
Gene Silencing -
The use of a compound called
RNAi or sRNAi has been proposed for ALS to silence the effect of a defective
gene.This compound is essentially tailored to block the production of
specific proteins.In particular, for SOD1 mice, RNAi has been used to
block production of the SOD1 protein that is thought to be the cause of a
small number of ALS cases.In particular, this type of therapy is thought
to have potential to stop ALS progression where the actual defective gene
such as SOD1 is known.
One of the most discussed
topics of ALS research is the use of stem cells.Stem cells are the master
cells in the body that differentiate into other cells.Embryonic stem cells
which are the first cells created after conception are pluripotent meaning that
they have the ability to transform into any other cell in the body.Adult stem
cells are not pluripotent but do have the ability to turn into specific cells
such as neural or blood cells. Stem cells have not yet
been used for ALS by any legitimate research group although numerous scam
institutions around the world have used the controversy surrounding them to take
advantage of ALS and other patients. Despite that, the legitimate research
community has envisioned using stem cells in various ways for ALS.The most
ambitious may be the use of them to regrow the entire motor neuron network that
has already been lost due to the destruction wrought by ALS.The motor neurons
die in ALS and they are very large.The lower motor neurons are centered in the
spinal cord but their axons or nerves extend all the way to the muscles making
them up to 3 feet in length.The upper motor neurons are centered in the brain
and their axons extend down the spinal cord to connect to the lower motor
neurons.Recent work by Dr. Kerr at John Hopkins University has investigated
reconstructing motor neurons in rats.
Less ambitious but
perhaps not as complicated use of stem cells would be to use them to protect
existing motor neurons from destruction in ALS.It is thought that stem cells
could migrate to areas of the spinal cord not easily penetrable by drugs.They
could perhaps be pre-programmed to secrete growth factors or other protective
agents that could keep motor neurons alive.
ALS Research Funding
The majority of ALS
research is conducted by non-profit institutions or universities.This is
unfortunate because if for-profit pharmaceuticals had more of a role in this
research, more resources including personnel and equipment could be utilized. As
it is, the government through NINDS or the National Institute of Neurological
Disorders and Stroke is a major provider of the money for research,
approximately $50 million in 2006.Other providers are the MDA (Muscular
Dystrophy Association) and the ALSA or ALS Association.In addition to these are
smaller organizations developed by the families of PALS such as Project ALS
developed by the Estess family and ALS-TDF created by the Heywood family which
is also an active development laboratory that has been searching for drugs that
may slow or stop the disease.Websites are below:
http://www.als.net/
http://www.projectals.org/
CHAPTER 10
DEFINITIONS OF MEDICAL AND
RELATED TERMS AND SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
Age of Onset- ALS onset ranges from the early 20’s through the 70’s, with the
greatest frequency in the 50’s and 60’s. Average age of onset is 55.
Baclofen:
a prescription medication to reduce stiffness that often accompanies ALS.
BiPAP
– a small piece of medical equipment designed to take pressure off the
breathing muscles (diaphragm), usually when sleeping. The device is attached to
the nose or nose and mouth by a mask and kicks in right after the start of an
in-breath. It finishes the inhalation by blowing a volume of air into your
lungs, thereby resting the diaphragm. Can be hard to get comfortable with at
first, but becomes easier with practice.
Bulbar Onset – When symptoms first manifest in muscles that control swallowing,
chewing and speech.
Constipation- a common problem for PALS, fortunately numerous remedies are
available.
Cough Assist Machine
(Insufflator-Exsuflattor) – A type
of non invasive medical equipment that helps clear the lungs and throat of
secretions by producing a cough. For more Information, go to
J.H. Emerson - Cough Assist
Durable Medical
Equipment (DME) - Medical devices
designed to be used repeatedly such as bipaps, canes, cough assist machines,
wheelchairs, etc.
Electro Diagnostic
Tests - Studies including
electromyography (EMG) and nerve conduction velocity (NCV), that evaluate and
diagnose disorders of the muscles and motor neurons. Electrodes are inserted
into the muscle, or placed on the skin overlying a muscle or muscle group, and
electrical activity and muscle response are recorded.
Fasciculations: Small, involuntary, irregular, visible contractions of individual
muscle fibers. Often seen in the legs, arms and shoulders of PALS. This is often
described by people with ALS as "persistent rolling beneath the skin." Commonly
known as muscle twitches.
Feeding Tube or PEG
- Percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy tube - a tube placed directly into the
stomach through the abdominal wall to provide another way to receive nourishment
and liquids.
FVC (Forced Vital
Capacity) –
A formal measure of the
amount of volume of air that can be exhaled from the lungs using maximal effort.
You will be tested each time you attend clinic. Your performance is compared to
what the average person would score. The result is expressed as a percentage.
Hyperreflexia: Excessive response of muscle reflexes when a normal stimulus is
applied.One of the characteristic findings in ALS.
Limb Onset-
when first symptoms occur in legs, arms, feet or hands.
Lou Gehrig
– (1903-1941),
American professional baseball player, also known as the Iron
Horse because he established a record for the most consecutive games played by a
professional baseball player, appearing in 2130 games from 1925 to 1939. From
1923 until 1939 he played first base for the New York Yankees of the American
League. Gehrig was twice voted the league's most valuable player (MVP). Stricken
with the spinal disease ALS, which later became known as Lou Gehrig's disease.
Lower Motor Neuron-
Nerve cells starting at the spinal cord or brain stem and ending at the muscle
fibers. The loss of lower motor neurons leads to weakness, twitching of muscles
(fasciculations), and loss of muscle bulk (atrophy).
Miracle Cures –You have to be careful in this area. There are unscrupulous people
out there trying to sell useless and expensive products that are bogus. Be sure
to use common sense and don’t fall for false claims. Remember, no matter what
the advertising states, no matter what is promised, there is no current cure for
ALS. A good site to help you identify charlatans and false advertising can be
found at:
http://members.aol.com/alspinpoint/quack.htmlMotor Neurons-The cells that control voluntary muscle activity such as speaking,
walking, breathing, and swallowing.Electrical signals are sent from the brain
and spinal cord via neurons which in turn stimulate the muscles. In ALS, these
neurons slowly die off, leading to muscle atrophy and the other symptoms of the
disease.
Motor Neuron Disease- A group of disorders in which motor nerve cells (neurons) in the spinal cord and
brain stem deteriorate and die. ALS is the most common motor neuron disease.
Progression – ALS advances over time, it is not static. Some PALS progress slower or
faster than average.
Range of Motion (ROM)
- The extent that a joint will move from full extension to full flexion. Many
PALS do daily active or passive ROM exercise to maintain flexibility, as
recommended by a physical therapist, occupational therapist or other health
professional.
Rilutek- The only medication so far demonstrated to be effective in ALS, although only
modestly.It is quite expensive.
Spasticity - An upper motor neuron problem and is present to some degree in ALS.
For some patients it is minimal, for others extreme. Spasticity can actually be
helpful in maintaining function as the rigidity helps replace normal muscle
strength, but it causes jerky, hard to control movements. Spasticity causes a
tightening of muscles resulting in a stiffening of that part of the body in an
exaggerated reflex. It is actually triggering both the muscles to flex and the
muscles to extend that part of the body at the same time. It can occur in any
muscles - the arms, legs, back, abdomen, or neck. A simple touch can trigger it
and it may last only a moment or persist longer.
Sporadic ALS (SALS)
– When ALS occurs without afamily history vs. Familial ALS FALS) where ALS
occurs within the context of a strong family history.
Tracheotomy
or tracheostomy
is a
surgical procedure performed on the neck to open a direct airway through an
incision in the
trachea(the windpipe). Later in the course of ALS, the muscles that assist
in breathing weaken. Bipap is the first line of defense, but when that is no
longer adequate to maintain lung function, some PALS opt for a tracheotomy,
which is attached to a vent, a mechanical device that replaces spontaneous
breathing.Ventilation
or Vent-
A method to assist or replace spontaneous
breathing
using a mechanical device.See Tracheotomy.
Upper Motor Neurons- Nerve cells (motor neurons)that originate in the brain's motor cortex and run
through the spinal cord.In ALS upper motor neuron loss produces stiffness and
problems with balance.
Vitamins and
supplements - The vitamins and
supplements and the daily dosage range often used by PALS are vitamins C (1000
to 2000mg ), B complex, E (1000 IU), coenzyme Q 10 (200 to 1800 mg) and NAC
(1500mg)Some PALS take many other supplements, too, and use very few. There is
a school of alternative medicine that recommends a large variety of
controversial supplements and procedures. If interested, you can check this out,
but again use your common sense and think critically about claims being made.
CHAPTER 11
READING LIST
As suggested by Jodi Hall and other
Some people enjoy reading
personal stories of PALS’ lives from cover to cover. Another strategy is to read
only the early parts of the book, and then return later when you feel more ready
to process the later parts. There are so many excellent books, below is just a
small sampling.Learning to fall: The
Blessings of an Imperfect LifeBy: Philip Simmons
Philip Simmons was
diagnosed with ALS in 1993.An associate professor of English at Lake Forest
College in Illinois, Simmons was just 35. In his quest to help others-and
himself-Simmons turned his experience living with ALS into his first book,
LEARNING TO FALL: The Blessings of an Imperfect Life. The insights Simmons
shares in LEARNING TO FALL are less about self-improvement than celebrating the
everyday.
Tuesdays with Morrie
- An Old Man, A Young Man, And Life's Greatest LessonBy: Mitch Albom
Morrie Schwartz was Mitch Albom's college professor and mentor. Knowing he was dying, Morrie visited with
Mitch (an ALS patient) in his study every Tuesday. Their rekindled relationship
turned into one final "class": lessons in how to live. This book has been on the
best seller list over one year.
ALSA PAMPHLETS
Maintaining good nutrition with ALS-
A guide for patients, families and
friends
Caregiving-
When a loved one has ALS
Basic home care for ALS patients-
The ALS Association guide for patients
and families
Counting on Kindness:
The Dilemmas of DependencyBy: Wendy LustbaderIt deals with disability
and aging issues for those of us who rely on the help of others such as guilt
and resentment, why "little things" become so important, and the importance of
having a regular schedule. For example, disabled people often loose out on the
regular activities of life which provide structure, and days and weeks seem to
run together. Forgetting which day it is may just be a symptom of lack of
schedule rather than developing dementia. Regular visits, trips for meetings,
shopping, worship, or coffee can provide time structure, and gives one things to
look forward to and some sense of control to the powerless.
Closing Comments: ALS
A Spiritual Journey Into The Heart Of A Fatal Condition
By: Brian Smith
I Choose To Live, A Journey Through Life With ALS, By: William Sinton
Journey with ALS, By: David Fergenbaum
Tales from the Bed, on Living, Dying and Having It All
By: Jennifer Estess
Waking up
By: Terry Wise
Charlie's Victory By: Charlie Wedemeyer
His Brother's Keeper By: Jonathan Weiner
ALS: A Guide for Patients and Their Families By: Jonathan Weiner
Children's
books:
In my Dreams I Do,
By: Linda Saran
Lou Gehrig, the
Luckiest Man Alive, By: David
Adler
CLOSING COMMENTS
What began as an attempt
to develop a brief manual for newly diagnosed PALS and their CALS has grown into
a large guidebook. Whenever I tried to pare down the length, I realized instead
that something important had been left out.And so it grew. Still, there was so
much more that I wanted to include, but the manual would have become so lengthy
and unwieldy that it would have defeated its purpose. You will have much time to
learn more on your own, as soon as you are comfortable with the basics.The goals of the
guidebook were several: to ease the pain and suffering that follows the
diagnosis and to offer a more positive and hopeful perspective; to provide ideas
on how to cope effectively with ALS; to begin to lift the clouds of confusion
created by all the unfamiliar material to which you have been exposed; to
introduce you to the peer community of PALS and CALS and to provide introductory
information that will broaden your knowledge of both ALS and available resources
to battle it. And, all contained in one manual, integrating numerous sources of
information, and designed to meet the specific needs of those recently diagnosed
and their loved ones. I hope some of these aims were met.The emphasis in this
guidebook has been on living well with ALS and these pages have pointed you in
that direction.It will be the most difficult challenge that you and your CALS
have ever faced, but it can be done, as you have seen in the stories in this
guidebook. You can do it, too. And there are so many out there to help.I hope you will join me
and the many PALS and CALS at the Living with ALS group. You can learn
and gain encouragement from our posts and we need to hear your questions and
receive the benefits of your insights. We are all one in the fight against ALS.
To all new PALS and CALS,
welcome to our family.Randy Roberts, PhD
(psychologist, retired), age 60PALS, Diagnosed: 4/04
Email address:
- Adequate information about the treatments available
- Access to health professionals who are interested in and experienced
- With all the available options in the care of ALS
- The encouragement to go forward
- The needed resources to go forward
- The desire to use available care
SIGNATURE EXPRESSIONS
Gathered from different
sites, these expressions, placed at the end of posts, illustrate coping
mechanisms in highly condensed form. They are little gems.
Don't forget to live!
Your friend in the fight
Laughing is good
exercise: it’s like jogging on the inside
Living & loving everyday
There is no such thing
in anyone's life as an unimportant day.
When you find yourself
in a hole . . . first stop digging!
It's not in our
abilities that we show who we truly are, it's in our choices
I know God will not give
me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn'ttrust me so much. (Mother Teresa)
Life's a dance, you
learn as you go
Don't forget to live!
Your friend in the fight
Laughing is good
exercise: it’s like jogging on the inside
Living & loving everyday
There is no such thing
in anyone's life as an unimportant day.
When you find yourself
in a hole . . . first stop digging!
It's not in our
abilities that we show who we truly are, it's in our choices
I know God will not give
me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn'ttrust me so much. (Mother Teresa)
Life's a dance, you
learn as you go
| I am afraid of dying: will itbe painful, will I suffer, will it happen soon. | You are getting way ahead of yourself; ALS is a gradually progressing illness.Morbid thinking creates lowered mood, let such thoughts go. Focus on living now. Find interesting activities to preoccupy your mind.Nobody, sick or well, knows when they will die, only that all of us will pass away at some time.Become involved in spiritual work.There are many ways to extend your life span. Be proactive, stay ahead of the disease.Remember, ALS does not have to be fatal, you have a choice. |
| My life will never be the same; how can I give up all my dreams, hopes and plans. | Grief is a normal, painful stage that all PALS have to work through. It doesn’t last forever, but may return after each new loss.You may continue with your regular life for awhile and follow thru on some of your plans, just sooner, like special vacations, etc.As you adjust to your limitations, new plans and goals will be set.Reread the personal stories in this section. Pay special attention to PALS’ descriptions of their meaningful, rewarding and happy lives even with ALS. |
| I feel depressed andanxious all the time. | Depression and anxiety, like grief, are expected reactions.Identify what you are thinking when you feel bad. Is it a negative?Observe how it worsens your mood and then try to let the thoughts go.Stay aware of such negative thoughts and let them go each time.Seek spiritual guidance.Work at focusing on positive goals, projects, things that interest you but you didn’t have time for in the past.Focus on what you still have. Appreciate that which is taken for granted when healthy are truly special gifts.If bad feelings persist, discuss antidepressant/anti anxiety meds with your doctor or increase what you are now taking.Join Living with ALS, ask for suggestions, establish an on line peer support network.Let yourself be inspired and encouraged by what you read.Consider counseling or therapy.Communicate your feelings to others. Don’t let yourself get cut off from family and old friends. Build a new support network.A little humor can work wonders. Find somebody or something that makes you laugh every day. |
| I am fearful and embarrassed about becoming dependent on others. | Again return to the present. Let negative thoughts dissipate. You are getting ahead of yourself.When the time comes, you will be surprised that you will welcome the assistance, as it becomes exhausting and risky to try to do something independently when capacities diminish. You can now use your energy more productively on other things that really matter.Aren’t all people dependent on others, anyway?Your embarrassment or shame will wither away as you realize that it is no big deal and your caregiver views it as no big deal. |
| I keep thinking of what liesdown theroad | Go back to the present. Worrying about future events leads to worsened mood. Let the thoughts go as they are preventing you from living well now.Nobody knows what lies in the future, e.g. an effective drug against ALS could be discovered soon. Become involved in interesting and productive activities instead. |
| I am so angry all the time | Anger is a normal reaction to what has happened and is a stage that must be worked through. It becomes a problem when it persists and you become bitter and closed off. Then you are not living with ALS, but are being eaten up inside.Chronic anger and irritability may reflect underlying depression. Speak to your health care professional about it. Try a visualization technique. Imagine ALS to be an object of some sort. I visualize a hideous looking scarecrow, and then proceed, in my imagination, to inflict all kinds of punishment to him: kicking, chopping, punching, bludgeoning, till he is reduced to pulp. I may do this for 5 minutes and I always obtain a sense of satisfaction and release. Just give back to him what he has done to you, no holds barred.Join Living with ALS. As you read the posts your heart may open up.Bitterness and chronic anger prevents you from living your life to its fullest; they close off options and keeps you imprisoned in their grasp. |
| How is my illness going to affect my marriage or relationship with my significant other. | It’s very stressful on caregivers, but many handle it well. Some CALS, however, are not able to manage.Discuss issues directly with your CALS; don’t assume anything.Help make arrangements to reduce stress, or encourage your spouse or other family caregiver to do so, when things become too difficult for him/her, e.g. paid care providers, help from family and friends, etcExpress your appreciation. Thank yous, and expressions of affection are helpful.Don’t take out your resentment on your spouse and make an effort to apologize if you should slip.Working together can bring you closer.If conflict or dissatisfaction become intense, and can’t seem to be resolved, consider counseling or begin to think of alternative living arrangements. The earlier you can detect problems in your CALS’ commitment and/or major shortcomings the better. |
| Why did this happen to me? | Every PALS and their CALS ask this painful question. It seems to demand an answer but of course there is no answer. Coming to grips with it is part of the acceptance process. It lessens in intensity and frequency over time. |
COPING WITH ALS
This piece integrates many of the ideas
presented in this chapter
I was diagnosed with limb onset ALS in November 1999 at age 58. I'm pretty much
completely quadriplegic, retaining head and neck movement. I still have my voice
with volume somewhat diminished, swallowing and breathing also diminished
(forced vital capacity below 30% at my last measurement a year ago) but intact.
I had a feeding tube placed December 2004 and use it for supplemental
nourishment once a day. I use a BiPAP at night and portable ventilator (LTV 900)
as needed during the day. I have a Permobil power wheelchair with four-way seat
adjustment, Switchit head controls and a Roho cushion. I sleep on a Pegasus
Airwave mattress and an adjustable bed. I use Dragon Naturally Speaking,
Smartnav head mouse, dwell click software and Skeleton Key (an on-screen
keyboard) to navigate the computer. I have a tablet computer for my wheelchair
with which I can control electronic devices. I have a Ford Windstar with a VMI
wheelchair access conversion. Although I'm retired from a 40 year teaching
career, I still continue to do professional counseling, writing and e-mail
correspondence with friends and family. I still "read" using the Talking Books
Program (through the Oregon State library) extensive library of books on tape.
I'm also a movie buff and subscribe to the Internet DVD service, Netflix. Here
are some techniques and attitudes I have discovered which have helped me to
continue adjusting to this disease, avoid depression and continue to appreciate
life.
1.Attitude is everything. ALS is a challenge to adapt, rather than a battle to be won,
an opportunity to learn the art of acceptance. Learn how to pick your
"battles" by learning new skills instead of struggling to deny the
reality of what is happening to your body. People will think you are really
wise and spiritual and will want to be around you. It's magic.
Although it will be difficult at first, resolve immediately
to learn how to ask for and even enjoy getting help from other people. If
this disease can teach us anything, it is that we cannot survive alone. It
will bring you closer to them and them to you. Some people may not be able
to handle whatis happening to you except by
staying away. That is their problem, not yours.
2.Plan realistically for the future.
The name of the game with this disease is adaptation. Try to
avoid wasting valuable time which you need to plan for the coming changes in
your life. If you wait for a crisis, it will probably be already too
late.
Begin now learning to conserve your energy by not trying to
do more than you are realistically capable of. Deciding what is realistic
and what is thebest use of limited energy is a
major step in adaptation.
Anticipate the future just enough to ask yourself how you
will adapt as your physical strength declines. For example, I began learning
how to usespeech software before I really needed
it. By the time I did, I was proficient at it. It took six months to get
wheelchair I needed. Learning to usehead
controls, getting used to using breathing assistance, feeding tube, etc. all
takes more time than we anticipated.
If you have not already done so, consider attending an ALS
support group. It will be difficult at first to see people in all stages of
this disease. I hadto resolve to go back for
three group meetings. By that time I was already getting used to this look
into the future, learning how other people cope. with what is happening in.
We do not easily recover from setbacks from illness or
physical injury as we did prior to the onset of this disease. Time wasted is
time lost foradaptation. So, for example, don't
push yourself to continue walking until you fall and break a bone.
In spite of what you may hear, there is no cure for this
disease. Pursuing claims of cures will only cost you money and put you in a
time deficit. Once you have been diagnosed, avoid
falling into the trap of believing that it is something other than ALS (Lyme
disease, mercury fillings, etc.). When aneffective treatment is discovered we will all know about it and someone will
no doubt get the Nobel Peace Prize. My own rule on this: put me in touchwith three people who are clearly diagnosed who have at least six
months on this "treatment" and let me talk to them personally about how it
hasworked.
3.Dealing with Depression
ALS is a lousy disease and quite unfair. But try to avoid
taking it personally. It did not happen because of anything we did or did
not do. Giveyourself the luxury of feeling sorry for you only on a limited
basis, for example an hour a day or, even better, an hour a week. Avoid dwelling on or worrying about all the awful stuff you
may have to go through in the future, or ruminating on all the things you
did not do in thepast. Of course, some of us with
ALS have other things to be depressed about besides the disease and this can
make avoiding depression much moredifficult.
4.Do something every day that gives you pleasure.
I love my morning coffee, having my head scratched, getting
a warm shower, watching a good movie, listening to a great book, listening
to jazz andblues, following the sports scene. Be with people whom you love and who love you. You have a
right not to be with people who sap your energy. People will like being with
you if you can help them get used to what is happening to you. Be nice. Plan for things in the future that you can look forward to,
like visits from children and grandchildren, friends etc. Cultivate a sense of humor about this disease. Some of it is
so ridiculous that it is actually funny. For example, I have unbitten
fingernails for thefirst time in my life. Seriously consider antidepressant medication. It is not
addictive and it is not a weakness to need medication to help out with the
symptoms ofdepression. If you have not already, begin to cultivate a spiritual
approach to life. There is more to this life than meets the eye. You will
have plenty of timeto think about these things,
the ultimate meaning of life, the nature and existence of something or
someone beyond us and upon which we depend. Youdon't have to have any formal religious training or upbringing. The process
of discovering meaning and purpose beyond our own little worlds is thebeginning of spirituality. Spirituality does not have to have any
complicated theology. In fact, the simpler the better. Trust your instincts. In spite of a lifetime of religious
faith, I have come to believe that God did not cause me to have ALS, and in
fact is assaddened by the bad things that happen
to people as we are. I also am confident that God is with us in all of these
things just as he/she/it hasbeen with millions of
others over the centuries. This disease can help us develop a sense of gratitude and
wonder about the mystery of life and death. It has taught me to embrace the
difficultexperiences of life as opportunities
instead of as obstacles to a meaningful life. I enjoyed "Learning to Fall"
by Philip Simmons, a teacher and writerwho had
ALS.
5.Taking care of your caregivers.
ALS is a social disease; it not only affects us who actually
have the physical symptoms, it also profoundly affects and changes the lives
of thosearound us who love us and care for us. We
have a responsibility, especially if we want to learn how to adapt and
prosper, to make sure we don'tovertax our
caregivers physically and emotionally. We will naturally tend to become
demanding, frustrated and impatient at times. But the more wedo this, the less people will want to be around us. Make sure your network of care is wide enough to give people
some time away to recover and recuperate. Avoid the temptation to just pick
out oneor two favorites upon which to rely
completely. No one, no matter how much they love us can handle the load by
themselves. You will learn gradually that you can tolerate not getting
immediate help that you don't really need: tolerating an itch you can't
reach.
By Loris Buccola
![]() As someone quite amazed to find herself in her 17th year of ALS and still busily, happily, and contentedly engaged in living, I have reached the point where I find myself saying "If I'd known I was going to live this long, I would have taken better care of myself!" For that reason, the main focus of this site is on dealing with some of the medical complications we face as a result of ALS. All too often these things are inadequately addressed because the expectation is that we will not be around long enough to worry about "long term" problems. These are problems that can and must be minimized in order to assure a good quality of life even if that life is short. In addition, I believe several factors are going to extend the life of ALS patients in years to come: The development of medications to slow progression. Continued improvements in supportive care (nutrition, respiratory support etc.) Computer aided communication and environmental control equipment will greatly improve the quality of life for ALS patients who opt for ventilation. As a result more of us will take that option and live for many more years. There are also sections with practical tips for dealing with some of the basic problems presented by immobility such as traveling, and more sections to be added.
|
Another aspect of coping is knowing about assistive devices that can help compensate for weakened capacities. At http://living-with-als.org/
|
|
|
Bathroom Bedroom Call Systems Clothing Computer Eating/Drinking Entertainment Mobility Respiratory Speech &Communication Travel Miscellaneous |
Many of the questions on the living-with-als group concern the equipment needed to deal with disability. This section of our website was set up to help people with ALS in their search for that equipment. Unlike other sites that provide a list of links to retailers and manufacturers, these pages are reviews of specific brands written by people who have purchased or tried them. The members of the living-with-als group hope this will help others find the best possible equipment to keep them living-well-with-als. |
Computer Desk |
|
PEG TubesBuying a Wheelchair Hiring a Caregiver |
|
Bathroom Design
#1
Bathroom Design #2
AccessibleHalf-Bath |
|
ESPECIALLY FOR CALS
My Story
By Trish
My name is Trish Wilson
and in my lifetime, have had many titles to my name, some being: sister, friend,
girlfriend, wife, mom and now my newest title, CALS or for you not familiar with
this new title, Caregiver of a person with ALS. Yep, Lou Gehrig’s disease.
Never in my wildest dreams did I ever imagine that this would be a title I would
have in my resume. When my wonderful husband Mike and I began searching for a
diagnosis to a problem he was having with his speech, we had no idea what this
search would lead to. We began as most of you will, with a simple visit to his
family doctor. From there we were sent without diagnosis to a neurologist due to
his tongue, speech and throat problems all along believing he had some growth in
this throat that was tying up his nerves in his mouth and neck.. Diagnosis' were
flying from friends and family only to make me a nervous wreck but having no
affect on my husband still believing it was some kind of growth that we could
have removed and move along with our lives. As we were put through an array of
testing, none of which we were told why they were being done, I became more and
more nervous every time they told me, "all of his tests are fine". I knew in my
gut he wasn't fine and wanted them to find SOMETHING wrong. I know, it sounds
insane, please find something wrong with my husband. I just wanted something to
be found so we could "fix it" and get back to normal.Needless to say, after our months of testing, two months to be exact which I now
find is a very fast time for diagnosis, the verdict was, "I think we are dealing
with Lou Gehrig’s Disease" were the words from our neurologists mouth. I, of
course, thought the man was a quack and after the initial shock, thought, I'll
take this into my own hands. If this doctor thinks Mike has ALS, I'll show him.
I'll go to an ALS specialist and prove he has no idea what he is talking about.
So, we did. We found the best specialist in Arizona only to discover once they
heard Mike was having swallowing problems, had lost over 35 pounds, felt
paralysis in his tongue, they rushed us in to see the doctor. Well, my feeling
of "that doctor was a quack" was becoming a nightmare. After seeing the ALS
specialist the very next day, it was confirmed. Mike has ALS. He was now a PALS
and I was now a CALS.Mike and I both have been through an array of emotions from extreme sadness, to
denial, which comes often, to acceptance. We have not been through the anger
simply because we do have an incredibly strong faith and believe God has chosen
our path and this is a path we have to live out with dignity. It is my husband
that shows me how to deal with this and it is my husband who is my hero for
taking this on in such a brave and unique way. Don't get me wrong, we both dream
of the days where "this can't be real" but for the most part, we are LIVING with
ALS and plan to continue doing this and embracing life for as long as God will
give us. ALS is not a death sentence, just a new way to appreciate your life.
CALS TO CALS
By Erin
Speaking CALS to CALS I want you to know you
have every right to feel the way you do. You wouldn't be human if you didn't.
Newly married or long time honeymooner's we all feel the loss, the frustration,
the anger, the loneliness.You will go in and out of all the above emotions. It is natural; it is just the
way it is.I have many years with my precious husband. But his progression was so fast we
didn't have one, two, or more years to come to grips with ALS. If he could only
do an nth of a fraction that some of our long time PALS here do, my husband and
I would have the world.So CALS, cry if you want to. Be mad, frustrated. Let those feelings happen but
then go look into your loved ones face, take their face into your hands and tell
them "I Love You". Everyday do that. After a while more love and new memories
will happen. You will always have the gamut of emotions, sometimes worse than
other times. But you will have what time is given to you on this earth with each
other.One thing for sure, you will learn the depths of love and compassion.
The emotional roller coaster can't be described. The emotions and stress, the
loss of living our day to day lives as we both knew it, as our children knew it,
is over.Some PALS with a slow progression have lived a good life for years.
Each CALS goes through a very isolated gamut of feelings and feels alone at
times. We could each write our own book and many of us have website's and blogs
to release our feelings, our progression, our journey. These sites and this
site, "Living with ALS" are the greatest help there is. Take it from me. My
husband’s progression was so fast we didn't have time to realize what was
happening. It wasn't until he finally reached a plateau that we could learn
about this thing called ALS.I never met anyone in an ALS group meeting that was at the stage of my husband.
No help there. It was early on and I needed answers, I needed help. I would
write to the ALS Digest and never get any answers. Very disappointing! It wasn't
until I discovered the "Living with ALS" site that I began to get answers and
discovered the most wonderful and compassionate people in the same boat as us.
What a base of humanity this site is to find this place with PALS and CALS that
know, that understand, that can cry with you, make you laugh with joy, allow you
to express the love, the sorrow, the frustrations, the unknown future. We all do
this together.I love you all.Erin CALS to Jeff
Speaking CALS to CALS I want you to know you have every right to feel the way you do. You wouldn't be human if you didn't. Newly married or long time honeymooner's we all feel the loss, the frustration, the anger, the loneliness.You will go in and out of all the above emotions. It is natural; it is just the way it is.I have many years with my precious husband. But his progression was so fast we didn't have one, two, or more years to come to grips with ALS. If he could only do an nth of a fraction that some of our long time PALS here do, my husband and I would have the world.So CALS, cry if you want to. Be mad, frustrated. Let those feelings happen but then go look into your loved ones face, take their face into your hands and tell them "I Love You". Everyday do that. After a while more love and new memories will happen. You will always have the gamut of emotions, sometimes worse than other times. But you will have what time is given to you on this earth with each other.One thing for sure, you will learn the depths of love and compassion. The emotional roller coaster can't be described. The emotions and stress, the loss of living our day to day lives as we both knew it, as our children knew it, is over.Some PALS with a slow progression have lived a good life for years. Each CALS goes through a very isolated gamut of feelings and feels alone at times. We could each write our own book and many of us have website's and blogs to release our feelings, our progression, our journey. These sites and this site, "Living with ALS" are the greatest help there is. Take it from me. My husband’s progression was so fast we didn't have time to realize what was happening. It wasn't until he finally reached a plateau that we could learn about this thing called ALS.I never met anyone in an ALS group meeting that was at the stage of my husband. No help there. It was early on and I needed answers, I needed help. I would write to the ALS Digest and never get any answers. Very disappointing! It wasn't until I discovered the "Living with ALS" site that I began to get answers and discovered the most wonderful and compassionate people in the same boat as us. What a base of humanity this site is to find this place with PALS and CALS that know, that understand, that can cry with you, make you laugh with joy, allow you to express the love, the sorrow, the frustrations, the unknown future. We all do this together.I love you all.Erin CALS to Jeff
FROM ALSA’S INTERVIEW WITH SANDY
You and Bob continue to
enjoy vacations. What kind of preparation is needed before, during and after
travel with your husband?Travel requires a lot of
planning to be successful. At each stage of Bob's illness, we have traveled, and
the challenges increase as the illness progresses. However, the rewards are
worth it! Initially we just needed a wheelchair to get us through airports and a
roomier more comfortable car to rent at our destination. Now, we need a
wheelchair accessible room and bathroom with guaranteed access to all public
areas (make phone calls, and double/triple check!) We need to be sure that the
restaurants in the area have food Bob can eat comfortably or we need a
refrigerator so we can bring our own. We don't travel by air anymore - too many
hassles with his power wheelchair being damaged or mishandled, but we do have a
van that we are comfortable traveling in. We had an easy-lock device installed
to make tie downs fast and easy, I pack a cooler with pureed foods for him, lots
of water and syringes. Bob's computer goes on his chair up front with me, a good
map and a guidebook of accessible trails and we are off. I have to remember to
pack the charger for his chair, toilet necessities, pillows, extra clothes (he
gets cold),a blender, all his medications/vitamins, emergency communication
device(alphabet board) ,etc, and a smile. We have been very lucky and have found
that getting away even for 2 days gives us both a change of scenery and renews
our strength. We have seen some gorgeous mountain trails that are wheelchair
friendly! Once we get back home it is important to give Bob a lot of down time
in a comfortable chair, because one of the drawbacks of car travel is he is
confined to his wheelchair all the time.
How has Bob's diagnosis
of ALS changed your life?
In every way. It has
narrowed the focus of life to its essentials - love and respect, and has
deepened our love and commitment to each other. It also has me always alert
(sleeping is a challenge), and trying to care for the details of someone else's
life as well as my own is tough sometimes. With each change in Bob's condition,
using the wheelchair, having to feed him etc., we have grieved the loss and
struggled to handle it. I am, however, truly grateful for this time we have
together, and am amazed at the grace with which he makes each adaptation. No
matter how it has changed my life - his has changed a million times more!
What does the word
"Caregiver" mean to you?
For me, it is a lot of
responsibility with a lot of rewards. It is a chance to outwardly express my
respect and love for my husband. When hiring outside help I ask for kindness,
attentiveness, gentleness and respect for Bob and his changing needs. Knowing
that Bob's mind is functioning at top speed, even though his body doesn't, is a
challenge for some people. I need people who have the heart and inclination to
get to know this wonderful man.
As a primary caregiver,
it is often a challenge to maintain facets of your own personal life. How do you
maintain a sense of balance in your life?
Well, I didn't,
initially. But now, we have hired outside help (no help from the insurance
unfortunately) and I have re-established my friendships and work associations.
Not knowing how long we have together has made me reluctant to miss a moment,
but having help 5 days a week, 8 hours a day, makes the 16 hours a day I am
Bob's caregiver now have more balance. I also realized early on that I would
need guidance and I continue to see a counselor to help me deal with the
incredible loss and grief we experience daily. I try to get a massage at least
twice a month too!
LETTER FROM LINDA
ALLEN
Linda is a former CALS
and current Program Manager for Extra Hands for ALS. In this letter she
describes the challenges and rewards of long distance travel with her husband,
which personifies the idea of living fully with ALS, and also discusses the
innovative Extra Hands program, which links young people with PALS and their
families. Linda has given her personal email address and is willing to share her
knowledge about travel.Also check out the Extra Hands web site for a moving
description of the Program and its origins.
http://www.extrahands.org/linallen@swbell.net(email)and Linda@extrahands.org
My husband Marshall was
dx. Oct 31, 1996 at the age of 54 and earned his wings on Oct.27, 2000.You are
right when you say, “do all the things that you have planned on doing as soon
after dx”.We decided early on that we were going to continue to live our lives
despite ALS.We traveled by air, ship, bus, train, van, with the Permobile
wheelchair.(Europe AFOs), US and the Caribbean with wheelchair), we went to
restaurants, the theatre, sporting events, to visit grandchildren etc.We
learned to expect there would be road blocks a long the way but we believed that
we could navigate around them.We had some funny stories surrounding our
adventures, others that brought us to tears; times when we educated
management/housekeeping staff/ about things they could do to make their
establishments more handicap accessible, and coming up with innovative ideas to
solve a problem when we could not find a resource/solution for.Was it easy
“no it was not” was it worth it…you bet!I have so many wonderful memories
because we decided to continue to live life and so do our children, his two
sisters/brother-in-laws, my family and friends. I promised Marshall that
after he was gone that I would continue in the fight against ALS until there was
a cure. I am keeping that promise by working with Extra Hands for ALS.I hope
we can reach all our PALS/CALS in every area in every state with this program.What better way of spreading the word about ALS than through young people who
will be our doctors, researchers, lawyers, congressmen/women, etc. ALS families
have the opportunity to teach these young people about ALS and learn about the
disease first hand. The “extra hands” do household chores, yard work, playing
with the children, providing company to the PALS, whatever the ALS family needs
done that will take some of the burden off the shoulders of the caregiver.Instead of doing what needs to be done the caregiver can read, catch up on phone
calls, work in their shop, work on a hobby, spend quality time with the family
while the students are working etc.These students learn so many life lessons
that they would never learn if they had not been involved with an ALS family.Some PALS/CALS have had such an influence in the lives of the students that some
have decided to take up the same career as their PALS or CAL, or by learning
about ALS have decided to become a doctor, physical therapist, speech
pathologist etc.Also these kids let their families/friends know what they are
doing and teach them about ALS.The family members tell other family members,
colleagues, neighbors about what their kids are doing….more Awareness of ALS.It is my hope that we can
find teams of individual volunteers that would like to get involved and start
this program in their area. It takes a group of interested people, ALS families
that will use the service and a source in the community that will help to fund
the program.
http://www.extrahands.org/linallen@swbell.net(email)and Linda@extrahands.org
My husband Marshall was dx. Oct 31, 1996 at the age of 54 and earned his wings on Oct.27, 2000.You are right when you say, “do all the things that you have planned on doing as soon after dx”.We decided early on that we were going to continue to live our lives despite ALS.We traveled by air, ship, bus, train, van, with the Permobile wheelchair.(Europe AFOs), US and the Caribbean with wheelchair), we went to restaurants, the theatre, sporting events, to visit grandchildren etc.We learned to expect there would be road blocks a long the way but we believed that we could navigate around them.We had some funny stories surrounding our adventures, others that brought us to tears; times when we educated management/housekeeping staff/ about things they could do to make their establishments more handicap accessible, and coming up with innovative ideas to solve a problem when we could not find a resource/solution for.Was it easy “no it was not” was it worth it…you bet!I have so many wonderful memories because we decided to continue to live life and so do our children, his two sisters/brother-in-laws, my family and friends. I promised Marshall that after he was gone that I would continue in the fight against ALS until there was a cure. I am keeping that promise by working with Extra Hands for ALS.I hope we can reach all our PALS/CALS in every area in every state with this program.What better way of spreading the word about ALS than through young people who will be our doctors, researchers, lawyers, congressmen/women, etc. ALS families have the opportunity to teach these young people about ALS and learn about the disease first hand. The “extra hands” do household chores, yard work, playing with the children, providing company to the PALS, whatever the ALS family needs done that will take some of the burden off the shoulders of the caregiver.Instead of doing what needs to be done the caregiver can read, catch up on phone calls, work in their shop, work on a hobby, spend quality time with the family while the students are working etc.These students learn so many life lessons that they would never learn if they had not been involved with an ALS family.Some PALS/CALS have had such an influence in the lives of the students that some have decided to take up the same career as their PALS or CAL, or by learning about ALS have decided to become a doctor, physical therapist, speech pathologist etc.Also these kids let their families/friends know what they are doing and teach them about ALS.The family members tell other family members, colleagues, neighbors about what their kids are doing….more Awareness of ALS.It is my hope that we can find teams of individual volunteers that would like to get involved and start this program in their area. It takes a group of interested people, ALS families that will use the service and a source in the community that will help to fund the program.
TEN TIPS FOR FAMILY CAREGIVERS
1. Choose to take charge
of your life, and don't let your loved one's illness or disability always take
center stage.2.Remember to be good
to yourself.Love, honor and value yourself. You're doing a very hard job and
you deserve some quality time, just for you. 3. Watch out for signs of
depression, and don't delay in getting professional help when you need it.
4. When people offer to
help, accept the offer and suggest specific things that they can do. 5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
1. Choose to take charge
of your life, and don't let your loved one's illness or disability always take
center stage.2.Remember to be good
to yourself.Love, honor and value yourself. You're doing a very hard job and
you deserve some quality time, just for you. 3. Watch out for signs of
depression, and don't delay in getting professional help when you need it.
4. When people offer to
help, accept the offer and suggest specific things that they can do. 5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
3. Watch out for signs of
depression, and don't delay in getting professional help when you need it.
4. When people offer to
help, accept the offer and suggest specific things that they can do. 5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
5. Educate yourself about
your loved one's condition. Information is empowering. 6. There's a difference
between caring and doing. Be open to technologies and ideas that promote your
loved one's independence. 7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
7. Trust your instincts,
most of the time they'll lead you in the right direction.8. Grieve for your
losses, and then allow yourself to dream new dreams.9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
9. Stand up for your
rights as a caregiver and a citizen, especially when dealing with public
agencies. 10. Seek support from
other caregivers. There is great strength in knowing you are not alone.
CHAPTER 4
MAJOR ORGANIZATIONS AND
WEBSITES The first website to look
at is the Living with ALS group and the link to join is:
http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/living-with-als/messages
Its
website is chock full of information in every area related to ALS. The link is:
http://www.alsa.org/default.cfm?CFID=897541&CFTOKEN=9724212 The home page looks like this (below is a
photo you can’t click on it)
It can be reached at:
http://als.mdausa.org/ MDA’s ALS home page looks
like this: (also a photo only, not a live web page):
ALS and
Associated Web Sites Compiled By: Steve Weekes
(
)
CHAPTER 5
BENEFITS AND ENTITLEMENTS
How do we decide if you are disabled?
Find out if you're eligible for Social
Security Benefits
Overview
We pay disability
benefits under two programs: the Social Security disability insuranceprogram and the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program.
If you qualify,
apply for Social Security disability benefits online.
No matter what kind of
disability benefits you are applying for, you must
give us information about your medical, work, and education history to help
us decide if you are disabled.
How to Speed Up Your Disability Claim
Risk pool
–
I don't know if Indiana has this concept,
but in Texas we have a Risk pool for individuals that are unable to get health
insurance otherwise. An ALS diagnosis automatically qualifies me for the pool.
There is no underwriting, but they are required to charge twice the going rate
for the opportunity to be in the risk pool. This policy (again, this is my interpretation
of how it works in Texas, Indiana may be
different, or may not even have a Risk pool) pays as secondary to
Medicare.See the discussion below for primary vs. secondary. Another thing to think about is respiratory therapy. Medicare does
not
cover respiratory therapy visits. The Risk pool does. That hasn't been
enough, in my case, to justify going this route yet. One more hitch, I cannot
join the Risk pool as long as I am eligible for COBRA, even
if I don't take it.
Primary vs. secondary
–
this is an issue when a patient
is covered by 2 different insurance policies, and is called coordination of
benefits, or COB. This can be caused by numerous things, like the Risk pool
example above, or group coverage from a spouse's employer. The way COB works is
that one policy gets the claim first, and forwards it to the secondary after
paying their portion. The secondary then processes the remainder of the claim
according to their policy. There are 2 ways I have heard this works. The more
favorable way, which is what I've experienced, the primary pays 80%, then the
secondary pays the rest, up to 80%. It's strange to think about, so here is an
example:My respiratory company
charges $590/ month for my cough assist machine. Medicare gets the claim, and
allows $400 (all these figures are hypothetical). My provider accepts
assignment, so they are happy with $400. Medicare then pays 80% of it, or $320.Now they pass the claim to my secondary. My provider is out of network for them,
so they would normally only pay 70%, or $280. But Medicare already paid $320, so
the secondary pays $80, and counts themselves lucky, because they paid $200 less
than what they are contractually obligated to pay.Obviously this is
advantageous to me, as I end up paying nothing. The other way that I have heard,
but not experienced, works like this:Same scenario as before,
company bills $590, Medicare allows $400, and pays $320. But now the secondary
gets it. They look at it and say "we would have paid $280 for this service.
Medicare has paid $320, so we don't have to pay anything."I'm not nearly as happy,
because I'm stuck with the $80 remainder, and am paying premiums for a policy
that never seems to pay out. Again, I have not experienced this happening, but
others on this board have reported it. How do companies decide which is primary?
In my case, Medicare became primary because I wasn't being paid, thus no FICA
taxes were being paid. If my coverage had been through my wife's employer, and
she was still having FICA withheld, Medicare would be secondary. Others have
said it has more to do with the number of employees being greater or less than
100, but I'm more inclined to believe mine, since I heard it from the COB desks
at both plans.
Medicare capped item
-
One more thing that you may want
to know about, especially if you're thinking about buying your equipment
supplier out, is the idea of Medicare capped items. Many of the things we use
are actually rented by Medicare. After 10 months of renting the equipment you
are given a choice to buy it or keep renting it. If you choose to buy it,
Medicare will pay for 2 more months (total of 12 months). Title to the equipment
goes to you, and no more payments are due, but you are responsible for upkeep.
If you choose to continue to rent, Medicare will continue to pay for 5 more
months (total of 15 months). Title to the equipment remains with the equipment
supplier, no more payments are due, and the supplier is responsible for upkeep.Now to the answer that
you didn't want, but I'm sure you knew was coming. No one can make the decision
for you. It is highly dependent on your financial position and your risk
tolerance. I would strongly recommend that you talk to a specialist in elder
care law before making a final decision.I will tell you what my
decision was. The gentleman that was here specifically to
sell me a Medicare Advantage
plan, told me to stay away from them because they weren't very good with DME
extensive conditions, of which ALS is certainly one. So I have decided that,
when they kick me off COBRA, I am going to immediately apply for a Medicare Part
D plan and a Plan A supplement. Good luck with your research. If you have any
other questions, feel free to ask. Just be forewarned: you may get another tome
like this one!
CHAPTER 6
PARTICIPATINGIN CLINICAL
TRIALS
By Randy Roberts
Chapter 7
ADVOCACY
Thank you for your help in
passing the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act. The House of Representatives
passed the bill 238-194, with 14 Democrats and 180 Republicans voting against
it. The Senate is expected to pass a similar bill soon. The sponsor of the
Senate bill, Republican Arlen Specter, says he has enough votes to override a
presidential veto. Bush said he will veto it when the bill reaches his desk. He
is obviously out of tune with most Americans, since a recent poll indicated only
28% of the people oppose embryonic stem cell research for therapeutic purposes.
Bush has little to lose by vetoing this bill because he is a second term
president. But the Representatives will have to defend their votes on this issue
in the 2006 elections. It takes a two-thirds majority to override a presidential
veto. Therefore, we should focus our efforts on the representatives who voted
against this bill or who did not vote. To see how your representative and others
voted go to
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/05/25/politics/25stem_rollcall.html
For convenience, I am including
the text of this article at the end of this email. . if you know people in
states with a large percentage of no votes, please consider forwarding this to
them.
To find out who your
representative (or any representative) is and how to contact him/her go to
http://www.house.gov/writerep/
[roll call vote by state
included]
Whether or not you agree with
me on stem cell research, the principles of cause advocacy are the same.
Be specific about
what you want your audience to do.
Provide
information on the topic, perhaps including talking points.
Provide contact
information for the people you want them to contact, or an easy way of getting
the information.
Organization advocacy
There are many groups that
raise money for ALS research or services, or raise awareness of ALS. These
include, but are not limited to, Muscular Dystrophy Association (MDA), ALS
Association (ALSA), ALS Therapy Development Foundation (ALS-TDF), Ride for Life,
ALS March of Faces, United Spinal Association, and your local ALS center. The
first two organizations have many local chapters which may hold fund raising
events such as walks, bike rides, dinners and golf outings. Some other
organizations, such as the Stamford, CT Fire Department, raise money for one of
the organizations in the first list. If you want to get involved, there are many
organizations and activities. If you’re not on the mailing list or email list
for these organizations, they will welcome your participation.
Your involvement can be as
simple as wearing a blue and white pin striped ribbon, to participating in an
event, being on the organizing committee for an event, or organizing your own
event. Fund raising is a good way to involve family, friends, colleagues and
your employer who often want to do something for you, but don’t know what. Time
for a personal story. I have always been reluctant to ask friends for
contributions. My cousin has been doing the ALSA bike ride in Boston along with
her husband and several co-workers who don’t even know me for several years.
This year they had only raised $350 towards their goal of $750. She asked me to
contact my friends for help. I figured if she could ask people who don’t know me
to ride and contribute, I could certainly ask my friends. The response was
phenomenal. We raised over $2000!
Working on the organizing
committee of a major organization, such as MDA, for a fund raising or an
awareness event has the benefit that the organization provides most of the
structure. When I worked on the organizing committee of a local MDA fund raiser,
they provided the solicitation letter, which I personalized.
If you want to organize your
own event, it is wise to recruit family and friends to help. Such events always
take more effort than anticipated. Alternatively, if you know someone who wants
to organize an event, you can let her/him be in the driver’s seat and help as
you can. Several years ago, one of my daughters organized a folk music concert
to benefit ALS-TDF and raised about $5000. ALS-TDF has family funds which are a
good way to honor a PALS and track your fund raising for the organization.
Try to attend the event, if possible. It helps to put a face on ALSWhatever form your
organizational advocacy takes, remember it is much easier to get businesses to
donate goods and services than money. It is not only a donation. It’s free
advertising.
Your life as a model
for advocacy
Finally, your advocacy
activities can inspire people with and without ALS to become advocates. Thus,
your own advocacy has a multiplier effect.
Conclusion
This chapter has
described some of the ways you can put your skills and experience to work to
become an advocate for PALS, including yourself. Advocacy can take as much or
little of your time and effort as you desire. The types of advocacy described
here are: EIGHT RULES TO GET WHAT YOUNEED
How do we do this?I think that it requires a
multifaceted approach, but that approach needs some healthy but vocal PALS at
its center. Awareness events such as the ALSA Walk to Dfeet ALS, the Ride for
Life, Faces of Courage, and the many other public initiatives are an essential
part of this awareness effort. Seeking celebrity spokespersons, maximum
exposure and use of all aspects of the media are vital parts to this campaign.We need to use the national organizations that represent us to be our advocates
and wemust be our own advocates to
keep the rest of the advocates heading in the right direction with enough
passion and vigor to make a difference.I found that participating in the
annual ALSA Advocacy Day and Public Policy Conference has all sorts of good
results.It allows our advocates to network and in doing so become a
harmonized chorus, rather than a bunch of distinct weak voices each singing
in isolation.It also brought the face of ALS and our needs to our
legislators.Some states have set up similar events to interface with
their state legislators. It remains that the true strength comes from those
who care for us.Their lives have been touched on a very personal
level, and they willround to keep advocating on behalf long after we have gone.If their voices
become strong enough, then maybe we will see therapies come along that will
extend the lives of PALS significantly and we can break above that 30,000
ceiling that has plagued us for so long.Simply stated, each of us
has to be our own advocates arguing on our own behalf, but we need to be active
in growing and extending the advocacy communities made up of our family, friends
and coworkers, the researchers and service organization volunteers and staffs
that work for us.It isn’t going to work if we shrink into our own lonely
little space and do not reach out to others and continuously make that group of
others larger and larger, better organized and educated, to carry the message of
awareness and education that will make advocacy work for better times for all
PALS.
A Letter to Advocate for
Greater Research for ALS
CHAPTER 8
MATERIALS AND RESOURCES
AVAILABLE AT NO CHARGE
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of wheelchairs or leg braces every five years. This benefit may be used
for wheelchair upgrades.
Up to $500 annually for
wheelchair repairs.
Up to $2,000 towards the
purchase of augmentative communication devices. This is a one time benefit.
One physical, occupational, and
speech therapy evaluation per year
Annual flu shot
Transportation to MDA clinics
Loan closet containing items
such as wheelchairs, hoyer lifts, hospital beds, commodes, etc
Research updates, informative
publications (MDA ALS News Magazine, Quest), resources & referrals, web site
Support groups for
Pals, Caregivers and Family
Respite care grants. Ride for
Life periodically offers a limited number of Care for Life grants of up to $1500
for the purpose of giving your caregiver a break. See
http://www.rideforlife.com/
Legal grants. A limited number
of grants of up to $750 are periodically offered for legal expenses such as
wills, dealing with insurance companies, and applying for disability benefits
under the Plan for Life program.
While not a direct benefit to
you, when you enter certain online stores from
http://www.rideforlife.com/, Ride for Life gets a percentage of the purchase
price.
Information, educational
materials on the web site
Under the Wheelchair Medic
program, you get a 10% discount on the price of wheelchairs and scooters and 15%
off on parts. See
http://www.wheelchairmedic.com/
Low income members can get up to
$5000 for accessibility modifications to the home. See
http://www.unitedspinal.org/publications/action/2006/03/24/affording-accessibility-home-modifications/
Low income members may qualify
for grants for assistive technology and automobile refits. Call : 800-404-2898
or email
Accessibility Rights
Benefits Counseling
Social Services
Adaptive Sports & Recreation
Self Advocacy
Legislative Issues
Healthcare & Service Locating
Peer Counseling
Spinal Cord Issues
Veterans Benefits
Accessible Travel
Wheelchairs & Assistive
Technology
Design of accessible home
modifications
CHAPTER 9
RESEARCH
Synthesis of
Growth Factors - In 2003, Dr.
Fred Gage of the Robert Packard Center announced that they had significantly
extended the life of a SOD1 mouse by the use of IGF-1 gene therapy. In this
approach, an AAV-1 virus is injected into various muscles of the mice.The
virus then moves up the nerve into the lower motor neuron nucleus located in
spinal cord. There it “infects” the motor neuron and changes its DNA
structure.This allows the motor neuron to synthesize a chemical called
IGF-1 that is thought to be protective.In the 2003 announcement it was
stated that trials could begin in one year but as of 2006, no human trial
has begun.
http://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/press/2003/AUGUST/030807A.HTM
http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/extract/291/23/2809-c
http://www.scienceblog.com/community/older/2004/10/20049657.shtml Gene Silencing -
The use of a compound called
RNAi or sRNAi has been proposed for ALS to silence the effect of a defective
gene.This compound is essentially tailored to block the production of
specific proteins.In particular, for SOD1 mice, RNAi has been used to
block production of the SOD1 protein that is thought to be the cause of a
small number of ALS cases.In particular, this type of therapy is thought
to have potential to stop ALS progression where the actual defective gene
such as SOD1 is known.
One of the most discussed
topics of ALS research is the use of stem cells.Stem cells are the master
cells in the body that differentiate into other cells.Embryonic stem cells
which are the first cells created after conception are pluripotent meaning that
they have the ability to transform into any other cell in the body.Adult stem
cells are not pluripotent but do have the ability to turn into specific cells
such as neural or blood cells. Stem cells have not yet
been used for ALS by any legitimate research group although numerous scam
institutions around the world have used the controversy surrounding them to take
advantage of ALS and other patients. Despite that, the legitimate research
community has envisioned using stem cells in various ways for ALS.The most
ambitious may be the use of them to regrow the entire motor neuron network that
has already been lost due to the destruction wrought by ALS.The motor neurons
die in ALS and they are very large.The lower motor neurons are centered in the
spinal cord but their axons or nerves extend all the way to the muscles making
them up to 3 feet in length.The upper motor neurons are centered in the brain
and their axons extend down the spinal cord to connect to the lower motor
neurons.Recent work by Dr. Kerr at John Hopkins University has investigated
reconstructing motor neurons in rats.
CHAPTER 10
CHAPTER 11
Learning to fall: The
Blessings of an Imperfect LifeBy: Philip Simmons
Philip Simmons was
diagnosed with ALS in 1993.An associate professor of English at Lake Forest
College in Illinois, Simmons was just 35. In his quest to help others-and
himself-Simmons turned his experience living with ALS into his first book,
LEARNING TO FALL: The Blessings of an Imperfect Life. The insights Simmons
shares in LEARNING TO FALL are less about self-improvement than celebrating the
everyday.
Tuesdays with Morrie
- An Old Man, A Young Man, And Life's Greatest LessonBy: Mitch Albom
Morrie Schwartz was Mitch Albom's college professor and mentor. Knowing he was dying, Morrie visited with
Mitch (an ALS patient) in his study every Tuesday. Their rekindled relationship
turned into one final "class": lessons in how to live. This book has been on the
best seller list over one year.
ALSA PAMPHLETS
Subject
Author
Date
32205
Re: burning feetAre you taking any kind of blood thinner? Have you had a
doppler study done? I...
Danny
Oct10,2005
10:32 am
32206
Re: psychological impactI am sorry Fern that more people are not coming to see you.
When I was told I ...
COOKIEDD
Oct10,2005
10:33 am
32207
Re: Moms in the hospital again.she has no gall bladder, no appendix, no uterus, etc. they
have had to give her...
Mr. and
Mrs. Travis S...
Oct10,2005
10:34 am
32208
Re:
Nursing home
Thom, Fern and others Here is the starting page on starting
a search and how...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32209
Re: new pulse ox neededLinda I paid $199 for mine. I wouldn't pay any less.
http://www.savelives.com/...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:41 pm
32210
Re: Heart Race problemDanny You state the oxygen sat rate isn't affected by the
BiPAP. Here is a...
Sherry
Oct10,2005
12:43 pm
32211
Re: One Person Home CareJim, Our stories are amazingly similar including the size
differential and the ...
Jeff
Lester
Oct10,2005
3:06 pm
32212
Re: BiPAP Mark & LarryDear Lisa, I don't know if anyone else has mentioned this,
but is it possible...
Edith
Oct10,2005
3:30 pm
32213
Re: One Person Home CareJim, I like your innovative approach and determination. Can
you explain what...
Randy
Roberts
Oct10,2005
4:35 pm
32214
Re: Crazy Week
... of a ... say ... chair ... I know Susan, i wanted to
hide LOL! Things are...
Oct10,2005
6:57 pm
32215
Re: speech
Oct10,2005
7:00 pm
32216
(No
subject)
I was just wondering if anybody has a problem with waking up
and the covers ...
murrza
Oct10,2005
7:01 pm
32217
Re: Nursing homeA good place to find your local resources for possibly
living at home is your...
Oct10,2005
7:40 pm
32218
Re: One Person Home CareHi Randy, I was referring to a system with a overhead
hanging container...
Jim
Oct10,2005
9:26 pm
32219
peg tube stopped thanksThanks to all who answered my email. My hubby is calling the
gastro doc ...
Debbie
Oct10,2005
9:54 pm
32220
Re: One Person Home CareAllison, Jim and Jeff, THANK you for sharing your stories
with us on this...
Susan
Oct10,2005
9:57 pm
32221
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home CareHi all, I have read a few of the postings about the dilemma
about care at...
STOPALS
Oct11,2005
2:18 pm
32222
comfort curveI need to hear more feedback on the Comfort Curve mask.
Hospice won't pay for...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
2:22 pm
32223
Flu Shots for People with ALS
This is to remind PALS (people with ALS) it's time for your
annual flu shot....
Oct11,2005
5:15 pm
32224
Clinic TrialI went to my ALS clinic on Monday. They gave me my FVC
breathing test and they...
COOKIEDD
Oct11,2005
6:31 pm
32225
Re: comfort curveSherry, When I first got the Comfort Curve, I wore it only
in bed with my...
Randy
Roberts
Oct11,2005
6:33 pm
32226
Re: re [living-with-als] visionOn Thu, 8 Sep 2005 14:22:19 -0700 (PDT) Erin Smith
<erinzinn5@...> ... ...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32227
Re: Friends ~ Where Are They?Dear Sue, I can relate to that. Hang in there. God will send
new angels. Andi...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32228
Re: I'm new herewelcome Connie! Andi ... On Wed, 07 Sep 2005 06:57:09 -0000
"Connie ODonnell"...
almanna
Oct11,2005
8:17 pm
32229
Re: comfort curve
Randy Thanks so much. I only have my bed on a partial turn.
I couldn't handle...
Sherry
Oct11,2005
8:18 pm
32230
ALS Registry Act Introduced in U.S. House of Representatives2005 Advocacy Update October 11, 2005 ALS Registry Act
Introduced in U.S. House...
lou_gehrig_054
Oct11,2005
8:19 pm
32231
Beds that turn youMy name is Bill and this is my first post. I have been
listening in for about...
netravelingman
Oct12,2005
9:04 am
32232
Re: Nursing Home vs. In-home Care
Does your ride for life support your state only? In Calif, I
only get 1500 ...
rovall
Oct12,2005
9:05 am
32233
Re:
Friends ~ Where Are They?
Dear Sue, Sorry to hear that John's Mom and sister haven't
contacted you. It's...
COOKIEDD
Oct12,2005
10:00 am

Below is a list of
websites that are comprehensive and far reaching:
ALS INFORMATION WEB SITES
ALS SOCIETIES, SUPPORT GROUPS &
PUBLICATIONSALS Association Chapter WebsitesALS Related Societies
ALS SOCIETIES AROUND THE WORLD(Over 40 Countries Represented)
ALS CHAT ROOMS
ALS FORUMS and DISCUSSION GROUPS
CAREGIVER WEBSITESTravel AssistanceCaregiver Chat Rooms, Forums and Discussion Groups
PALS / CALS - PERSONAL WEBSITESInternational PALS / CALS Personal Web Sites
MEDICAL SEARCHES, INFORMATION &
JOURNALSLyme and ALS Associated DiseasesAdvanced Therapies, Treatments and ResearchGeneral Health Care and Information
ASSISTIVE AIDS, DEVICES, and
SOFTWAREGeneral Assistance SitesCommunication Assistance and SupportComputer Adaptive Devices & EquipmentWheel Chairs, Scooters & VehiclesSpecific Assistance SitesMind and Spirit Resources
NATURAL & SUPPLEMENTARY THERAPIESDiagnostic LaboratoriesNon-Conventional Doctors, Clinics, Treatments, Therapies &
Theories
PRODUCTS,SUPPLIERS, ETC...
SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS
By Danny Dandignac
For the full version click
here
To download the full version in Microsoft
Word right click
here
choose save target as
FURTHER INFORMATION ON SOCIAL SECURITY
BENEFITS
(TAKEN FROM THE REGULATIONS)
By Randy Roberts
Who Can Get Social Security Disability
Benefits
Children may qualify for disability benefitsunder either the Social
Security program or the SSI program.You can get Social
Security disability benefits until age 65. When you reach age 65, your
disability benefits automatically convert to retirement benefits, but the amount
remains the same. Certain members of your
family may qualify for benefits on your record. They include:
How to Apply for Disability Benefits
You also should be ready to answer other questions we must ask.
Don't delay filing for
benefits just because you don't have all the information and documents you need.
The people at the Social Security office will be glad to help you.
Who Can Get SSI Benefits
How Much You Can Get from SSI
MEDICARE
By Andy Etherington
MORE ON MEDICARE PART DPRESCRIPTION COVERAGE
By Andy
The
first $250 dollars of drug expenses are paid for out of pocket at full price.
Some plans have no deductible, and start coverage at the next level.
SupportAfter the
deductible is met, drugs can be obtained for either 25% or a fixed co-payment.
Each formulary uses a different base price for each drug, though formularies
within the same plan family tend to use the same price structure (Humana's
prescription drug only plans uses the same prices as the Humana Medicare
Advantage plans with drug coverage). Once you reach $2250 in total drug costs
(what you pay plus what the plan pays), you move to the next level Donut hole.
This is the part that is most confusing. Between the time that you reach $2250
in total drug costs and when you reach $3600 in out of pocket expenses, you pay
100% of the drug prices. Did you get that? That means that, between $2250 in
total drug costs and $5100 in total drug costs you pay 100% of your prescription
costs. Still with me? Ok, one more
thing.After you've paid $750 for your prescriptions
($250 deductible plus 25% of the next $2000), and before you've paid $3600 in
out of pocket expenses, you pay full price for all your medication. That's all
the ways I can think of to explain it.
Catastrophic coverageOnce you exceed the threshold of the donut hole, you get catastrophic
coverage, under which you pay the greater of $5 ($2 for generics) or 5% of the
full price.
For complete
information on all aspects of Medicare benefits, always go to
http://www.medicare.gov/
![]()
Click the Logo above to
see the ClinicalTrials.gov
web site.
Advocacy!
By Catherine Wolf
By Danny Dandignac
TIPS AND INFORMATION ON ADVOCACY
By David Abell
Thoughts on Advocacy
By Chuck Hummer
By Randy Roberts
By Catherine Wolf
http://www.mdausa.org/.
To receive services, you must register with the
local office, but registration is free. .
These apply after all insurance has
been paid.
Other services and
free stuff
Ride for Life
Ride for Life is an
awareness and fund raising organization whose main event is a ride for PALS in
their wheelchairs in the New York area.
Financial benefits
Financial benefits
RESEARCH OVERVIEW
By Wayne Gimlin
http://www.rideforlife.com/news/als_research/clinical_trial_of_myotrophin.htmlRecent Research into
Pre-existing Drugs
The ALS research
community is mainly comprised of university researchers and a few non-profit and
for profit companies.Due to the multiple failures of very expensive developed
drugs in the late 90s, the ALS research community focused more on the use of
existing drugs to treat ALS. The advantage of using existing drugs is that they
do not have near the development cost and if found to be effective, can be
cross-prescribed for ALS patients.Some examples of pre-existing drugs taken to
trial for ALS research are:Pre-existing drugs taken to Phase II or
III trials.
1. Celebrex. Failed Phase III trial.
2. Creatine Failed two Phase III trials.
3. Minocycline Currently in a Phase III trial.
4. Tamoxifen Completed a Phase II trial showing safety and possible
efficacy
5. Hydroxyurea. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
6. Ritonavir. Currently in a Phase II trial for safety and possible
efficacy.
7. Indinavir. Failed a Phase III trial.
8. Ceftriaxone. Currently in a Phase III trial.
9. Pentoxifylline. Failed a Phase III trial.
10. Sodium Phenyl Butryate (PBA). Currently in a Phase II trial
11. R+ Pramipexole. Currently in a Phase II trial
12. Thalidomide. Currently in a Phase II trial
13. Aramiclomol. Currently in trial.
14. Others.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspxSOD1 Mouse Studies
One important point about
these drugs is that nearly all were justified to the FDA and the funding
agencies as worthy of a human clinical trial, by the successful completion of a
SOD1 mouse test.In these tests, the mice are divided between control mice and
mice given a treatment.The variables of these tests include the point in their
lifetimes that the mouse should begin treatment, the amount of dose given, and
the length of time given the dose. Further there is a question of how many mice
must be used per test and how closely related the mice must be.Ideally, a
researcher should be able to take any two sets of mice, treat them identically
and the average lifetimes of both sets should be about the same. However, there
have been questions over the results of these reportedly successful mice tests.
ALS-TDF is a non-profit ALS research company started by James Heywood in 1999 as
a response to the diagnosis of his brother Stephen with ALS in 1998.ALS-TDF
first investigated the use of stem cell and gene therapy to treat Stephen’s ALS
in the late 90s.However by 2002, ALS-TDF started large scale testing of SOD1
mice in the hope that a pre-existing drug may substantially slow the rate of ALS
progression.To their surprise, as of 2006, and after testing several thousand
mice, they have not been able to reproduce with repeatability the results
reported from other researchers’ mice tests.This includes Celebrex, Creatine,
Minocycline, Tamoxifen, PBA and others.They have been able to find small (<
10%) life extensions which prompted them to help start a Phase II trial for
Hydroxyura and Ritonavir at the University of California in San Francisco (UCSF)
but have not been able to repeat these tests with consistency. The concept of
repeatability is a basis of science and experimentation.If a small set of PALS
were divided into two groups and their rate of survival tracked, it would be
expected that the average length of survival of both sets would not be exactly
the same. The two groups’ survival might be different by a few weeks or months.
If larger and larger groups were studied it would be expected that the
difference in survival between the two sets would diminish.The same is true
for mice.If small samples of mice are chosen to be in the control and in the
treated group there is some certainty that the two groups will have different
life spans by random chance.The way of proving that the treatment and not
random sampling is the cause of the treated group outliving the control group is
by repeatability, meaning that the test can be repeated by any competent
researcher anywhere and has approximately the same results.There is a large
question on whether the tests that have been published as “successful” are
actually repeatable.Other concerns over the
use of the SOD1 mice are the fact that the mutated SOD1 protein is not present
in most PALS both those with familial and sporadic forms.This has caused much
speculation that a successful SOD1 mouse test would not translate into a
successful human clinical trial.Also there is concern over the differences
between humans and mice on how they react to different drugs.Differences in
how drugs cross the blood brain barrier could easily complicate whether a drug
that affects or doesn’t affect a mouse would have the same type of result in a
human.To date, what is lacking is what is called a “positive control”.Essentially this is a drug or treatment that has proven success in mice and
humans which can be used to gauge how other reactions in mice might affect a
human. Since the SOD1 mouse is
one of the few animal models that closely mimic ALS, researchers will continue
to use them for drug discovery. What should be asked by PALS and closely noted
is how many mice were used, how many times was the test repeated using the same
parameters, and how many different laboratories also repeated the test.Past
research has shown that many if not all of the reportedly successful mouse tests
cannot answer these questions adequately.
Causes of ALS
ALS research is hampered
by the fact that how it is caused and how it progresses is mainly unknown.Although approximately 10% of ALS cases are known to be genetic, how the damaged
genes cause ALS is still not known.Since SOD1 is a gene that produces a SOD1
protein that acts as an anti-oxidant, some have theorized that oxidation could
be a key player in ALS.However, later research has pointed more towards the
concept that these proteins could be tangled or misfolded and thereby causes
cell death. In either case, one of
the current main focuses of ALS research is identifying what genes are defective
in familial ALS and if there are similar defective genes in sporadic ALS.
Currently there are several trials sponsored by the MDA that concern
identification of genes in ALS.
http://www.mda.org/research/ctrials.aspx
Researchers are also
interested in environmental factors that could cause ALS but so far, none have
been proven.Besides the root cause, researchers have focused much of their
efforts into identifying what happens in the cells that cause ALS death.This
is a large subject but some of the areas of interest are:Another growth factor which has been theorized
as having a potential effect is VEGF.
Less ambitious but
perhaps not as complicated use of stem cells would be to use them to protect
existing motor neurons from destruction in ALS.It is thought that stem cells
could migrate to areas of the spinal cord not easily penetrable by drugs.They
could perhaps be pre-programmed to secrete growth factors or other protective
agents that could keep motor neurons alive.
ALS Research Funding
The majority of ALS
research is conducted by non-profit institutions or universities.This is
unfortunate because if for-profit pharmaceuticals had more of a role in this
research, more resources including personnel and equipment could be utilized. As
it is, the government through NINDS or the National Institute of Neurological
Disorders and Stroke is a major provider of the money for research,
approximately $50 million in 2006.Other providers are the MDA (Muscular
Dystrophy Association) and the ALSA or ALS Association.In addition to these are
smaller organizations developed by the families of PALS such as Project ALS
developed by the Estess family and ALS-TDF created by the Heywood family which
is also an active development laboratory that has been searching for drugs that
may slow or stop the disease.Websites are below:
http://www.als.net/
http://www.projectals.org/
DEFINITIONS OF MEDICAL AND
RELATED TERMS AND SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
READING LIST
As suggested by Jodi Hall and other
Maintaining good nutrition with ALS-
A guide for patients, families and
friends
Caregiving-
When a loved one has ALS
Basic home care for ALS patients-
The ALS Association guide for patients
and families
Counting on Kindness:
The Dilemmas of DependencyBy: Wendy LustbaderIt deals with disability
and aging issues for those of us who rely on the help of others such as guilt
and resentment, why "little things" become so important, and the importance of
having a regular schedule. For example, disabled people often loose out on the
regular activities of life which provide structure, and days and weeks seem to
run together. Forgetting which day it is may just be a symptom of lack of
schedule rather than developing dementia. Regular visits, trips for meetings,
shopping, worship, or coffee can provide time structure, and gives one things to
look forward to and some sense of control to the powerless.
Closing Comments: ALS
A Spiritual Journey Into The Heart Of A Fatal Condition
By: Brian Smith
I Choose To Live, A Journey Through Life With ALS, By: William Sinton
Journey with ALS, By: David Fergenbaum
Tales from the Bed, on Living, Dying and Having It All
By: Jennifer Estess
Waking up
By: Terry Wise
Charlie's Victory By: Charlie Wedemeyer
His Brother's Keeper By: Jonathan Weiner
ALS: A Guide for Patients and Their Families By: Jonathan Weiner
CLOSING COMMENTS
E
mail address: